Some believe that, as it is the job of a court to protect society, therefore, sending a child to an adult prison is only right for offenders so that they are out the way of society. Minors who spend time in adult penitentiaries are presumed to have changed the way they act and no longer commit crimes once they have completed their prison sentence and are back in the free world. It is also thought to be unjust that a seventeen year old receives a more lenient sentence to an eighteen year old, even if the latter is only a few months older. Those who oppose this point believe that a crime is a crime, no matter the age of the offender. Also consider the fact that juveniles need to be imprisoned in order to make the necessary changes to their life, forcing them to realise their errors that lead to their punishment.
Education, community outlets, and alternatives to formal prison are all suggestions for getting our juvenile offenders out of a predestined life of failure. The threat of prison to a young person rarely means anything significant because they lack the maturity to understand the reality of prison, until it is too late. Removing these children from the environment that gave rise to their criminal activity is a key concept, but placing them into an even worse environment is not a logical solution. Finding out what creates a young juvenile delinquent, and then changing some of those factors is a better way to handle the growing epidemic in this country. To get to the issue at hand, children need to feel loved, needed, and appreciated; a small step to changing what can become the life of a juvenile
Racial differences can cause several big crimes by the adolescents as adolescents become aggressive and they want to take revenge from the society for the unequal treatment that the society shows to them. Drug use is also a very common cause of juvenile delinquency. Those juveniles who use drugs usually get involved in criminal activities as most of their friends belong to criminal class. Teenage boys and girls go through several social problems when they are not well socialized human beings. Some teens are very harsh and rude to talk and they cannot control their anger or aggression as it is in their nature.
Nowadays, the topic of the Juvenile law system is a very controversial as well as difficult discussion to have. For every court case, trial, and scenario, there are many different circumstances that may affect the outcome. Due to the seriousness of their crimes or even their past offenses, juvenile criminals can sometimes be tried as adults. Personally, in the beginning of this assignment, I could see both sides of the argument. There are many reasons why children under the age of 18 should be tried as children, however, there are more proficient reasons as to why we should do away with juvenile court.
Juvenile Justice: Failure or Not? The United States, a country who has prisons filled with juvenile delinquents. Many of the offenders are arrested for status offenses, but there are also offenders who are incarcerated for serious crimes. Are these offenders getting the treatment needed to succeed after their release? Are the punishments in the juvenile detention centers creating more problems?
Prisons serve two main functions; separation and rehabilitation. Criminals cannot be allowed to walk around with everyone else without being punished; they must be separated from society. The thought of going to prison helps deter most people from crime. Rehabilitation is the main goal of prison; making a bad person into a good person by the time they are released. These seem like cut and dry functions, but as of late some believe that prisons in the United States have failed in their attempts to separate and rehabilitate.
Placing them in prison with adults will hinder their treatment because it is not appropriate to their age or legal status. If we take their age and the fact that we need to promote their rehabilitation children should be commit but focusing on positive measures like education and not so much punishment. Children tried as adults are treated as adults rather than by their age, then given adult sentences, life without parole is mandatory where you are twelve or fifty-five when the crime is committed. Sentencing them at the age of twelve will show there is nothing that can be done to help the child once they become a member of society. It will banish the child and not give them an expression that is places with peers, hard work and time could promote a positive change in the child.
Will publicizing juvenile crime deter other juveniles from committing crimes? Is there an answer to this growing problem? When a juvenile does an adult crime, they do need to be punished for the crime they have done, however they do not belong in an adult prison. They should be sent to a place were there are other juveniles and when they reach an adult age of 18 then they can be sent to an adult prison. Bibliography: Works cited About.com.
What Happened to Juvenile Justice? There is a great deal of controversy over the trying and sentencing of juvenile offenders today. Many will argue that because the severity of Juvenile crimes has risen, the severity of its consequences should rise; however, no matter how serious the crime is, juvenile offenders tried as adults receive far worse than they deserve. The majority of Juveniles tried as adults are hardly given any form of human rights. Adult jails are not the environment children should have to experience, especially those sentenced for misdemeanors and nonviolent crimes.
These decisions made by the judge or jury in the preliminary hearing affect the rest of the suspects life. The opposing argument to the issue of juveniles being tried as adults remains that the minor is too young and immature to understand the consequences of what he or she did wrong. Juveniles need to be punished according to the severity of the crime in which they committed. Ultimately, juveniles should stand trial as adults. The opposition believes that holding court cases where juveniles remain tried as adults undoubtedly violates the rights of the juvenile.