Justice And Entitlement Analysis

299 Words1 Page
bulb-icon

Recommended: Wealth inequality essay

Do you think that people who are wealthy deserve their wealth, if it was acquired because they had advantages that other people did not have? Why or why not?
Wealthy people do deserve to be wealthy even if their money was acquired through advantages that other people did not have. In “Justice and Entitlement” by Robert Nozick, people are entitled to their belongings, or in this case their wealth, if it was secured according to the principle of justice. If a wealthy person received their wealth through transfer, the benefactor must have obtained this money through the principle of justice. Even though only a tiny fraction of the population becomes wealthy, people deserve their wealth, as long as it was acquired fairly, or in accordance to

Show More
Related

  • Analysis Of Class In America By Gregory Mantsios

    1572 Words  | 4 Pages

    All individuals have different paths and life goals. It is true that individuals may start out with more advantages than others, but it should not be used as a limitation to others. Mantsios lists several realities discussing the different levels of opportunity for Americans. In these realities, he describes that wealth and our economic status is important in order to reach success. In one of his realities, Mantsios discussed the privileges within inheritance laws stating: “…Americans do not have an equal opportunity to succeed, […]. Inheritance laws provide built-in privileges to the offspring of the wealthy and add to the likelihood of their economic success while handicapping the chances for everyone else” (392). It appears as if he only believes success comes out of extreme wealth, and if someone is not, they’re disadvantaged and will ultimately be less successful than others. Mantsios talks only in extremes; he discusses the very rich, the very poor and how each affects each other, while simultaneously arguing that there is little to no chance for those in the middle or lower class to grow and become successful. In contrast, Jay-Z discusses how he did not let the obstacles he faced, or his economic status limit him. He is quoted saying, “don’t let [society] diminish your accomplishment or dim your shine” (Packer 361). Here, he is taking a much more positive approach, stating that individuals should not limit their success based on their social class. Class should not be a tool used to limit individuals and their success. To say that an individual born into the upper class will just coast through life without hardship is untrue. In the same respect, to say that an individual born into lower or middle class will have no chance at success, is just as untrue. We all face different levels of hardship in life, therefore condemning an individual because they have a leg up or down in

    Read More

  • The Rise of Consumption Equality by Andy Kessler

    1991 Words  | 4 Pages

    My first source, “The Rise of Consumption Equality” by Andy Kessler, published in The Wall Street Journal, discusses how the different social classes are becoming more alike and more different from each other. At the beginning of the article, Kessler’s talks about how wealth used to be popular, but now it is hard to be wealthy without being guilt-tripped by the lower classes. Kessler then moves on to say that most often the rich work themselves to death to make their fortune, and with the rise in new technology and equality, they only get to enjoy the same things as the middle class. He questions the fairness in that in the next sentence. In the following paragraphs of the article Kessler describes many of the dif...

    Read More

  • Barbara W. Tuchman's 'Persumption Of Consumption'

    1094 Words  | 3 Pages

    Not all people can be rich. According to the article “The Treadmill of Consumption”, Robert says that “Life is a game. Money is how we keep score”. That is what some people think about real life, and that is wrong, because real life isn’t a game. It is a world where you need to work and earn your money to buy things you need. Not everyone can have a big house and many cars. Everyone is different and have different jobs and salaries. Somebody is born rich, and they easily get money from their parents, but others work hard to get the place where they are now and the money that they are earning. People never know who works hard and get it easy, but in any way they want to be like them. Moreover, people forget what they have, and they just want more. In the article “All That Glitters Is Not Gold”, it says that everyone should be equal. It is true that being equal would be an easy solution for people. Most of the people earn enough money to live good and simple lives, but that is not enough for them. They look at rich people and forget about themselves. Maybe, the money that they have is plenty for them, and they don’t need to be

    Read More

  • The Ethical Complexities of Lying for Protection

    701 Words  | 2 Pages

    This is very true, people everywhere in the world benefit from having money and those who have money and privileges are able to

    Read More

  • The Growth of Wealth Inequality

    1112 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the United States, the gap between the rich and the poor has been substantially increasing over the years. This growth between the rich and poor illustrates the wealth inequality between the social classes in our nation. Although it is impractical to precisely measure the morality of wealth inequality, we can use philosophical thought to determine what makes a political and economic system just. By analyzing the theories of political philosophers, Robert Nozick and John Rawls, it is clear that wealth inequality is morally justified, as long as equal opportunity and concern for justice among a society is provided under certain conditions.

    Read More

  • Wealth in America

    899 Words  | 2 Pages

    But, even rich people have their limitations. A rich person can fly first class but he cannot own a private jet. He can acquire season tickets to a ballgame but he cannot buy a sports team. A rich family can own two houses but they cannot maintain homes around the world. Then can hire a live-in maid, yet they can't afford a squad of house-servants.

    Read More

  • The Distribution of Wealth

    877 Words  | 2 Pages

    Everyone has his or her own ideas of how wealth should be distributed properly. Some people believe wealth should be left to family, left for public services, or become the property of others. Others believe that people should not have excess wealth, resulting in non-existent class distinctions. An alternative view is that wealth is not distributed; instead, the wealthy continue to grow wealthier while those in poverty can not escape it and fall further into a life of poverty. The beliefs discussed above come from three different writers. Those writers include Andrew Carnegie, Karl Marx, and Robert B. Reich. These writers all have different opinions on how wealth should be distributed properly.

    Read More

  • Income Inequality

    939 Words  | 2 Pages

    ... Although it may not seem fair that there are rich people blowing money on impractical and meaningless things while living in poverty, it’s a reality that the United States has experienced for centuries. Works Cited Desilver, Drew. A. “U. S. Income Inequality, On The Rise.” Pew Research Center.

    Read More

  • Economic Injustice

    1784 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...nly distributed, and no traces of economic justice even exist. People living in poverty need some kind of hope, some sign that their government has not forgotten them. The truth is, there are plenty of people who do care, and there are many efforts to help. The discrepancies are simply too big to go unnoticed, and a change is inevitable. As for right now, the trend continues. The rich get super-richer, the poor get poorer

    Read More

  • Wealth And Wealth

    1062 Words  | 3 Pages

    Wealth is a diverse topic amongst many people, it’s talked about widely and there is a lot of books, journals, and statistics - that I will use in my paper - but were written based on what other people have found to be true. These sources I have chosen to use talk about the factors, struggles, and lifestyle lived based on being wealthy or not.

    Read More

  • Wealth Vs Wealth

    1512 Words  | 4 Pages

    Who does not wish to be rich? The first thing that might come to mind when thinking about having a lot of money is owning luxurious cars, living in a prodigious residency, having expensive items to wear, or anything of that nature. A rich person has the ability to buy anything to please his or her desires, and he or she can visit any place at any time without having to think about it twice. Many people perceive that happiness comes within how much money they have. People confuse being wealthy with being happy. Wealth does not necessarily bring happiness; however, it is obvious that it can help to bring happiness for some and sorrow for others.

    Read More

  • The Dream And The Inequality Of The American Dream

    814 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although the claim that I make that only the wealthy have opportunity has recently started to gain recognition, there are still those people who believe that the inequality of the United States actually benefits us. The opposite claim, as it were, is that the gap in income levels does not necessarily prevent the lower and middle classes from achieving the American Dream and that the supremely rich are a necessary fixation in the United States because they employ so many people. Therefore, the stability of the economy requires this inequality. In an essay written by Brandon King, who believes that the American Dream is still fully obtainable by all classes, he says, “.We should keep in mind the ways in which large businesses and financial insti-tutions enable many others to attain economic stability and security.”

    Read More

  • Why The Poor Are Getting Richer And The Rich Poorer Essay

    1045 Words  | 3 Pages

    There are many rich and poor people in the world today, in our own country and in others. We have classified by how much they can afford and they are put into a class system. It’s hard for everyone in a country to be equal in the sense of how much money they make. Adriana Delgado says, “The vast differences between the rich and the poor, the powerful and the powerless, will be the catalyst for the best intentions to be rewarded with ungratefulness and contempt, creating resentment and mistrust between the classes.” there is always going to be problems between the rich and poor, because one sometimes is held higher than the

    Read More

  • Wealth Inequality Essay

    1024 Words  | 3 Pages

    One of the reasons why wealth inequality in America exists is the inherited wealth. Most of the wealthy people had their parents or a family member who were rich and when their relatives died they receive properties or money as heritage. Successful rich people taught their children the proper manage of money because they will heritage their business. Wealthy people pass their heritage to their relatives or they made donation to social organizations. Another reason is the career path of the person. Some of the wealthy people came from middle class and they start making their fortune based in their career, work and effort. This people often choose a major related with business and work as CEO of big enterprises. In today society, this people are part of the top 1% who posses almost the half of the wealth of the country. Wealth people can be someone who made self

    Read More

  • Poverty Analysis Essay

    749 Words  | 2 Pages

    With that being said, the wealthy also provide benefits to the poor. First, Gans (2012) stated that the wealthy contribute to antipoverty and unemployment programs. Not to mention, food stamps, and Medicaid. The wealthy also assist in funding clinics, shelters and other assisted facilities. In addition, the members of society said to be well off financially contribute to programs designed to help people get out of poverty and the social situations that accompany poverty.

    Read More

More about Justice And Entitlement Analysis

Open Document