In Praise Of Sweatshops
analytical Essay
1173 words
Sweatshops are an unfortunate part of our global economy. The workers are paid extremely low wages, receive little to no benefits (such as health insurance, sick leave, etc.), and more often than not work under difficult or dangerous conditions. The benefits of sweatshops (if any) is a hot-button issue in today’s society. Sweatshops do not treat their workers well (as mentioned above), yet at the same time, they bring jobs that help many people escape the horrors of extreme poverty. This issue begs the question: are sweatshops improving lives? Or are they another form of abuse?
In an article written by Alex Massie, titled "In Praise of Sweatshops"; he speaks about the many suggestions people have given on how to improve the situations in sweatshops. In his article, Alex writes, “Some even suggest that factories in Bangladesh and other developing countries be held to the same standards that apply to factories and working conditions in countries such as the United States or the United Kingdom. Intuitively, this seems an appealing argument. But it is, nevertheless, an inadequate one.” (Massie, “In Praise of Sweatshops”). In many developing countries; they lack the funds to implement change and improve standards,
…show more content…
In this essay, the author
- Opines that sweatshops are an unfortunate part of our global economy. they provide jobs that help many people escape the horrors of extreme poverty.
- Analyzes alex massie's article titled "in praise of sweatshops" about the suggestions people have given on how to improve the situations in sweatshop.
- Opines that it would be better if more buildings in bangladesh met existing, local, safety regulations than trying to hold them to the standards of more developed countries.
- Explains that sweatshops have positive outcomes, such as jobs, growing economy, and empowerment. many people in bangladesh are "toiling in the fields."
- Analyzes how bangladesh's economy is growing slowly each year, but the minimum wages paid to garment workers are still low by our standards. capitalization pays a heavy price for the bangladeshi.
- Analyzes how alex's article touches on something paul krugman suggested in which he suggests increased competition and higher wages actually drives standards up, not down.
- Analyzes how nicholas kristof describes life in a garbage dump in phnom penh, cambodia, in his article "where sweatshops are a dream".
- Analyzes how nicholas explains that the central challenge in the poorest countries is not that sweatshops exploit too many people, but that they don't exploit enough.
- Opines that sweatshops are improving the lives of people in developing countries by giving them jobs, stimulating their economy, raising them from the depths of extreme poverty, and providing them a safer alternative than wandering around in garbage dumps.
- Opines that sweatshops are a form of abuse and exploitation. companies in developed countries outsource their work to people working in them and pay them almost nothing.
- Concludes that sweatshops are improving the lives of people in developing countries, but they are also a form of abuse and exploitation.
Whether or not this is actually true is up for speculation. Delving more into the positives of sweatshops, the article talks about how westerners benefit from sweatshops. The article describes how not only do the big businesses benefit from sweatshops but how our own poor do as well. Many of our poor have to make tough decisions every day, and most if not all of them have very limited funds. For those with said limited funds, they must choose to manage their funds carefully. With clothing as another necessity, cheaply made clothes produced in sweatshops are a benefit to
Related
- analytical
- explanatory
- argumentative
- opinionated
- the trounle with sweatshopsanalytical essayThe controversial issue of sweatshops is one often over looked by The United States. In the Social Issues Encyclopedia, entry # 167, Matt Zwolinski tackles the issues of sweatshops. In this article Matt raises a question I have not been able to get out of my head since I have begun researching this topic, “ are companies who contract with sweatshops doing anything wrong?” this article goes on to argue that the people who work in the sweatshops willingly choose to work there, despite the poor environment. Many people in third world countries depend on the sweatshops to earn what they can to have any hopes of surviving. If the sweatshops were to shut down many people would lose their jobs, and therefore have no source of income. This may lead people to steal and prostitution as well. this article is suggesting that sweatshops will better the economy by giving people a better job than what they may have had. Due to this the companies contracting with sweatshops are not acting wrong in any way. This was a deductive article it had a lot of good examples to show how sweatshops are beneficial to third world countries. Radly Balko seemed to have the same view point as Matt Zwolinski. Many people believe the richer countries should not support the sweatshops Balko believes if people stopped buying products made in sweatshops the companies will have to shut down and relocate, firing all of the present workers. Rasing the fact that again the worker will have no source of income, the workers need the sweatshop to survive. Balko also uses the argument that the workers willingly work in the current environments.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how matt zwolinski tackles the issue of sweatshops in the social issues encyclopedia.
- Analyzes how the united students against sweatshops (usas) raises concerns about poor working conditions, low wages, long hours, and children in the factories.
- Agrees with the usas that sweatshops are a great source of income, but the companies investing in them need to improve the workers environment.
795 wordsRead More - The Benefits Of Sweatshopsexplanatory essayThere are lots of sweatshops established in developing and less developed countries such as China and India. The main reason is the labor costs in those countries are much lower than developed countries. Due to the huge population in China and India, the wages will stay low in long term. Most of the workers are uneducated and unskilled, and they have to accept the low wages in order to pay for their daily necessities. The multinational companies like Apple Inc., IBM, H&M, Nike opened factories or outsourcing their products in China. These are unethical factories. A lot of people criticize the owners of these factories. However, all things are created by the demand. If sweatshops were useless, then they wouldn’t develop. Corporations want low
In this essay, the author
- Explains that there are sweatshops established in developing and less developed countries such as china and india because of the low labor costs in those countries. the multinational companies like apple, ibm, h&m, nike opened factories or outsourcing their products in china.
- Explains that all companies want to make profits, and they always control the costs of production as low as possible. in a capitalism country, interest is the most important thing.
- Explains that multinational companies set up sweatshops in china to get lower tax rates. nike put 7 billion us dollar in offshore bank amount in bermuda to avoid tax from us government.
- Explains that sweatshops create job opportunities in developing and less developed countries and reduce the unemployment rate.
- Explains that setting up a sweatshop benefits both companies and local consumers. the increase in profit due to low tax rate and low operating costs will also lead to the reduction in prices.
- Explains that sweatshops receive modern technology and management expertise from developed countries, which helps them improve their technology level through the process of production.
- Explains that sweatshops are used to produce variety components for technology and retail companies. they purchase raw materials, transportations, and installation services from local supply chains.
- Explains that sweatshops improve the balance of payment of a country.
- Opines that most people against sweatshops because it causes a huge gap between rich and poor.
- Explains that multinational companies will not update the technology if the companies or factories are out of the home country because they think that is useless.
- Explains that excessive use of natural resources by sweatshops in developing countries will destroy local environment. the factors of production include land, labor, capital, and enterprise.
- Opines that setting up sweatshops will damage reputation of companies. companies have to spend more money to fix negative images and bad reports from press.
- Explains that people can't get paid as high as developed countries and have bad working conditions. if all countries are in the same level, there would not be competitive market and gain any advantages through international trades.
1601 wordsRead More - Child Labor In Sweatshopsexplanatory essaySweatshops are factories where workers bear unhealthy and exploitive conditions, such as long hours, unventilated workspaces, low pay, or exposure to toxic resources. Sweatshops are not a perfect place of work for anyone; however possibilities are
In this essay, the author
- Opines that children are deprived of their childhood and are enforced to work. the international labor organization estimates that 250 million children between the ages of five and fourteen work in emerging countries.
- Explains that sweatshops are unsafe places of work for children, and that children are exposed to unhealthy conditions, such as long hours, unventilated workspaces, low pay, or toxic resources.
- Explains that sweatshops are packed, dirty, and rat-infested. they are located behind spikey wire fences that are supervised by guards carrying weapons and guests are prohibited.
- Explains that sweatshops negatively impact children's health, mental health and psychological well-being. child laborers work long hours and don't learn to cooperate with others.
- Quotes wanda embar, who advocates children's rights and causes against child labor in sweatshops.
- Explains that worldwide the number of people diseased by hiv has been gradually growing since 1990. major focuses of the infected victims are people living in the underdeveloped and inferior countries.
- Opines that sweatshops and child labor are censored production costs and raise their incomes, but the health and well-being of their employees is not what they are fascinated in.
- Explains that most businesses obtain advance warning of examinations, thus providing the impression that they are functioning according to the law. this status quo is precisely what pass on in a vietnamese nike factory in 1997.
- Opines that the sweatshop conditions are a breach of these announcements. they are capable of demonstrating that factories are operating in an immoral style.
1516 wordsRead More - Sweatshops Essayargumentative essayThe General Accountability Office defines a sweatshop as a “multiple labor law violator.” A sweatshop violates laws pertaining to benefits, working hours, and wages (“Toxic Uniforms”). To make more money, companies move their sweatshop factories to different locations and try to find the cheapest locations with the least regulations (“Sweatshops”). There are not as many sweatshop factories in the United States because the industries have been transferred overseas where the labor is cheaper and there are weaker regulations. In the United States, sweatshops are hidden from the public, with poor immigrant workers who are unable to speak out against the injustices (“Subsidizing Sweatshops”). Workers in sweatshops are forced to work overtime, earn below a living wage, do not earn benefits, and encounter verbal, physical and sexual abuse. Macy’s, JCPenney, Kohl’s, The
In this essay, the author
- Explains that a sweatshop violates laws pertaining to benefits, working hours, and wages. in the united states, they are hidden from the public, with poor immigrant workers who are unable to speak out against injustices.
- Explains that overtime is common in sweatshops and sometimes a necessity to meet goals. some workers are threatened with their job if they refuse 100-plus hours of monthly overtime or extended nights to 3 a.m.
- Explains that most sweatshop employees earn a salary that is so low that they cannot afford basic necessities. in 2000, more than 11,000 sewing factories violated minimum wage, overtime, and health and safety laws.
- Explains that workers at the alianza fashion sweatshop are paid $1.05 per hour and are required to continue working without pay until goals are met.
- Explains that it is difficult for a sweatshop worker to afford benefits or retirement. sweatshops do not pay for sick days, so most employees work while they are sick, not to lose pay.
- Explains that pregnant women are denied paid maternity leave in sweatshops because it slows them down and requires days off.
- Explains that employees at sweatshops are not treated properly, experiencing verbal, physical, and sexual abuse. the management uses insulting language to refer to their workers.
- Opines that sweatshop factories are not safe for workers, as they suffer from neck, shoulder, and back pains because they stay in a fixed position for more than thirteen hours.
- Explains that auditors aren't able to inspect factory conditions at all times. investigating sweatshops can be difficult and dangerous with the risk of harassment, telephone bugging, and intercepted email.
- Explains that sweatshop workers do not have the right to form unions or have freedom of speech. guatemala is under a dictatorship that leaves workers marginalized with no labor rights.
- Explains the principle of catholic social teaching: life and dignity of the human person. work should contribute to people's dignity.
- Argues that governments should encourage the development of better businesses and stop subsidizing sweatshops with taxpayer dollars.
- Recommends that gap and old navy executive meet with the director of the institute for global labor and human rights to launch a plan of factory improvements.
2282 wordsRead More - Sweat Shops are an Economic Stepping Stoneanalytical essaySweatshops: A Bad Thing or an Economic Stepping-Stone? Many people in our society today are constantly asking, "Why do sweatshops exist?" The answer to this question is that companies like Nike and Wal-Mart use sweatshops to produce their goods for a much cheaper rate, to reduce the cost of their products. The problem with sweatshops is that the workers are subject to hard work in often times poor conditions for minimal pay.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that companies like nike and wal-mart use sweatshops to produce their goods for a much cheaper rate, to reduce the cost of their products.
- Analyzes how nicholas d. kristof and sheryl wudunn sum up the misunderstanding of sweatshops by most of the modern world.
- Explains that linda lim, a professor at the university of michigan business school, visited vietnam and indonesia to obtain first-hand research on the impact of foreign-owned export factories on local economies.
- Explains that many people protest against sweatshops and their practices because of the terrible atrocities against women and children. the extreme cases are promoted and used to rally support for the anti-sweatshop movement.
- Explains that while the wages in many sweatshops seem unimaginably low, consider this point. kristof and wudunn describe the average breakfast of a chinese worker.
- Explains that sweatshops are helping the overall economy of asia by providing jobs and income for many workers, but they also help the individual people of the region.
- Explains that the modern world forgets that there are always going to be places in the world that are not as successful as others are. this disparity is based on the amount of schooling and education that one receives.
- Opines that sweatshops are essential to the survival of the delicate balance that is the world economy.
1215 wordsRead More - Third World Sweatshopsopinionated essay...e their product. Sweatshops are found usually all over the world and need to make a better decision as in more labor laws, fair wages, and safety standards to better the workers' conditions. It should benefit the mutually experiences by both the employers and the employees. Most important is the need to be educated about their rights and including local labor laws.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that there should be labor laws or an obligation of respecting workers to provide decent working conditions, fair wages, and safety standards.
- Opines that migrant workers should be educated on the importance of working conditions at the bottom of the supply chain.
- Argues that huge american companies such as gap or adidas should provide fair living wages for employees.
- Opines that the garment, restaurant, and meat-processing industries have the most widespread problems, committing multiple violations of labor laws and safety regulations.
- Opines that education is out because they have to work to help provide for their family, and children are more likely to be hired as they work for less money.
- Concludes that taking away sweatshops takes away an option for the poorest workers of the world but in spite of international and domestic human rights agreements, many countries fail to help or protect the rights of their own workers.
- Cites lora jo foo, yale law journal, vol. 103, no. 8, symposium: the informal economy.
- Describes philip j. landrigan and jane b. mccammon's public health reports.
1409 wordsRead More - Sweatshops Essayopinionated essaySweatshops are considered to be a thing in the past, but the truth is they are more common than people would think. Many companies use sweatshops as a way to produce more products for little money. To some companies, their labels have become more of a priority than the workers who made it all possible.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that sweatshops are more common than people would think. many companies use them as a way to produce more products for little money.
- Explains that people are being trafficked into italy to work in factories for very little pay and hard working conditions. the little money earned is spent paying off bills of coming into the country.
- Explains that the pay and work hours are bad and the jobs are dangerous. one man lost two fingers in a machine and went back to work in excruciating pain to pay off the medical bill.
- Opines that it is worth putting people through this to pay thousands of dollars for a designer handbag.
- Explains that top fashion designers use sweatshops for cheap labor, and the nike swoosh is being sewn on their garments. nike has about 1,000 factories around the world, many in china and taiwan.
- Opines that nike employees are being abused by their supervisors, such as slapped, kicked, spilt on, etc. there are also allegations of sexual abuse by bosses in some nike factories.
- Compares how gerda weismann kline was imprisoned in and forced to work in many-3-labor camps during the holocaust.
- Opines that the us is no better in labor conditions than any other country.
- Explains that some companies have made strides in abolishing sweatshops in their business. fruit of the loom is the fourth college-logo apparel company to sign the bangladesh safety accord.
747 wordsRead More - Essayanalytical essayNo Sweat talks about the low wages in the sweat factories in all the developing countries. It gives an example of sweat factory’s workers in Uzbekistan. Where children work only for 48 cents wages per day (Garyfalakis, par. 2). Author shows that the wages that the sweat shop workers receive in the developing countries that are “not enough for basic survival needs” (Garyfalakis, par. 2). Sweat shop workers have to live with that small amount of wages which is hard to survive. Author shows the real story about sweatshop workers where she proves that, the wages that workers receive is not enough for basic survival.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how no sweat and low wages, strong backs focuses on low wages and positive impact of factories. garyfalakis brings out workers life and sweat factories working condition in the developing countries.
- Analyzes how no sweat talks about the low wages in the sweat factories in all the developing countries.
- Analyzes how low wages, strong backs proves that factory workers in u.s. receive less wages for their hard work.
- Analyzes how garyfalakis (2013, par. 5 & 6) gives an example about bangladeshi women who are getting benefited by working in the factories.
- Analyzes how meagher provides the example of "julio" who is a factory worker and does not have proper document or english knowledge to work in the u.s.
- Analyzes how no sweat talks about factory workers, but focuses on educating consumers who buy their products. if consumers boycott all sweat factory products by knowing about sweat shop conditions, it will harm big companies like gap.
- Analyzes how low wages, strong backs focuses on factory workers' physical and emotional state and the impact of work in their life.
- Analyzes how both essays show the similarity of working in a factory with poor wages and some advantages, but one of them raise awareness among its consumers about the products.
850 wordsRead More - Persuasive Essay Against Sweatshopsanalytical essayWhat are sweatshops? The Miriam-Webster dictionary defines sweatshops as: A shop or factory in which employees work for long hours at low wages and under unhealthy conditions. These factories are mainly located in Third-World countries, although there are still a few in the United States. Many popular, name brand companies like Nike, use sweatshops around the world. Today there is much controversy about sweatshops and whether they should be banned and closed. In reality, the conditions of these factories are terrible. The employees are paid very little, even after working long, hard hours. The supervisors of these shops are often cruel, malicious, and brutal. Sadly, these factories are often the only source of income for Third-World workers. As bad as these sweatshops might be, they have pulled many countries and individuals out of poverty. So, are sweatshops beneficial?
In this essay, the author
- Opines that sweatshops are the only source of income for many people around the world. bibek debroy said he wished the protestors would think with their brains rather than their hearts.
- Analyzes how sweatshops improve the lives of poor people and how the protests against them could cause the people to be worse off if they were closed.
- Concludes that sweatshops are factories where many people must work to survive even if the pay is low and the conditions are horrific. they are beneficial and promote human flourishing.
- Defines sweatshops as a shop or factory in which employees work for long hours at low wages and under unhealthy conditions.
1174 wordsRead More - Sweatshop Case Studyexplanatory essayOver the past century, sweatshop has been a big discussion in our society. This project is a comprehensive research regarding sweatshops and how it had a substantial impact on stakeholders. Sweatshops are defined to be work factories in low-cost countries in which the employees work for long hours with low wages and dangerous working conditions (Dictionary). The Norwegian newspaper “Aftenposten” even referred it to as “deadly fashion”. Looking at this, workers suffer in order for businesses to obtain profits. Sweatshops have been argued to be a part of an evolution of underdeveloped countries but the discussion regarding sweatshop is still increasing at a rapid pace and it is a ethical question of morality. First, we will discuss the ethical
In this essay, the author
- Explains that sweatshops are work factories in low-cost countries where workers work for long hours with low wages and dangerous working conditions.
- Describes sweatshops as businesses that violate wage, child labor, safety or health laws designed to protect employees from exploitation.
- Explains the widespread disregard for workers' health at the factory, and the ethical issue of child labor in sweatshops.
- Explains that sweatshops are unethical and home-based production is the lowest rank of worker, with no rights, and the worst pay.
959 wordsRead More