64-66), author Jared Diamond claims that agriculture as opposed to popular belief, didn’t help civilization bloom, but instead proved detrimental to human lives ever since its introduction. He states that the progressives believe agriculture was adopted due to its efficiency and how it complimented our race. He contradicts this view with multiple studies and expert sources. According to his research, modern day humans are much worse off than their hunter gatherer counterparts due to a variety of lifestyle changes ranging from greatly deteriorated nutritional quality to increased sexual discrimination. He gathers the support from various archaeological research conducted on various remains found in Chile, Greece, Turkey, etc. Archaeologists can further point out the date at which this switch (from Gathering to agriculture) took place. He further establishes that Hunter gatherers may have chosen to change ways with the preconceived idea that the capability to feed more people and reducing the burden on mothers (hence allowing them to bear a child every 2 years instead of 4) would in turn drastically improve quality of life. He concludes the article by emphasizing on how it created disparities between the elite and the commoners and by defending his own kind for having discovered mankind’s biggest mistake and the motive behind
Several millennia ago, there were certain groups of humans (mainly in Eurasia) who believed that an agricultural lifestyle was more desirable and would increase chances of survival more so than the hunter-gatherer way of life that had been in existence for millions of years. With the rise of agriculture came the domestication of the ‘farm’ animals – for example, pigs and cows (dogs had been domesticated well before these other animals). Farmers and herders began to need more land for their crops and animals, as well as for their offspring who also became farmers and herders, and so they expanded their territories. This territorial expansion continuousl...
The choice to change to an agricultural society may have actually been the best choice available when considering the conditions that existed at the time of the dramatic change from a primarily hunter-gather society to an agricultural society, it may have been the ...
The Neolithic Agrarian Revolution was the world’s first historically verifiable revolution in agriculture, being established around the beginning of the 8000 B.C.E. The Neolithic Agrarian Revolution is described as a “revolution” to represent just how vital and significant that the degree of change that was brought into their lifestyles and how it affected the communities where new agricultural practices were progressively adopted, implemented, and refined. In this revolution many of the cultures began to rely on domesticated animals and cultivated crops more than they had in the past because they wanted to feel more secure in knowing they had a reliable source of food. Everywhere, this transition seems to be linked with a modification from the once typical, nomadic hunter-gatherer lifestyle to a more settled, agrarian based way of life. With the change in lifestyles, the beginning of the domestication of various plant and animal species was brought forward. However, no one can truly distinguish what conditions and circumstances are at fault to have caused the shift from hunting and gathering to sedentary agriculture. Some say that changes in the climate could have been significant factors; it is also plausible that increases in human population drove the changes in food production. Although, there are several competing theories as to the factors that caused this particular shift in society that explain their interpretation with more depth and logic, such as: the Oasis Theory, the Demographic Theories, and the Evolutionary/Intentionality Theories.
The Neolithic Agrarian Revolution was the world’s first historically confirmable revolution in agriculture. It was the progression of many human cultures from a lifestyle of hunting and gathering to one of agriculture and settlement, which was supported with a big increasing population. This agriculture involved the domestication of plants and animals, which developed around 9,500 B.C. During this age various types of plants and animals derived in different locations all over the world. It converted the small groups of hunters and gatherers into more intelligent agricultural people. Those groups then formed into sedentary societies that built towns and villages, while they also altered they natural environment around them by food-crop fertilization. Therefore, allowing them to have an abundance for their food production. Just these few developments have provided high population density settlements, complex labor diversification, trading economics, the development of portable art, architecture, culture, centralized administrations and political structures, hierarchical ideologies, and systems of knowledge.
Jared Diamond presents several arguments that agriculture was a mistake for humanity. One argument is that the life of hunter-gatherers is far more nutritious than that of sedentary people. Diamond argues that in comparison to sedentary peoples, hunter-gatherers are well fed, work less for their food, and can’t starve from a mass famine like the Irish. But Diamond’s argument is flawed because it fails to account for agricultural advances of the last two centuries that skyrocketed the production of food. For example, Vileisis writes “When tomatoes grown for fresh consumption flooded markets and prices dropped, canneries snapped up the ripe surplus…manufacturers could then sell their imperishable products… year-round” (Pg 218). The over-production
Furthermore, with the increase of population growth, experts agree that human sustainability was a product of agriculture improvements (Laland, 2014). Hunter-gatherer societies were generally composed of closely related groups of individuals, they relied on wild natural resources to sustain their niche. They depended on hunting, trapping, and projectiles to feed their family; the fundamental purpose of the niche was to sustain enough food for the family, not for others (Church & Bishop, 2015). Agricultural societies throughout the industrial revolution used these complex gathering strategies as a benchmark to develop advanced engineering techniques. From these techniques, Humans developed large social groups containing social organizations, requiring specialized roles within the niche (Ellis 2016). From craftsman to traders, the utilization of developed tools enabled humans to greatly modify and improve their ecological niche (Ellis, 2016). However, the human niche was not able to sustain the growing population of humans, resources within the niche were not readily available, hence the effort to change the biological niche to sustain human population (Isbell & Loreau, 2014). As a result, humans domesticated animals, cultivated fields, and developed methods such as irrigation to improve agricultural practices (Spengler, 2014). The harnessing of
Jared Diamond makes the argument that when humans decided 10,000 years ago to no longer be hunter-gatherers and made the decision to become sedentary and start domesticating their animals and crops, the result is that the human race has experienced a steady downfall. Diamond makes the point that “with agriculture came the gross social and sexual inequality, the disease and despotism that curse our existence,” (Diamond). While the present system certainly is far from being perfected, Diamond’s various complaints and solutions certainly would not be of much use in the present time either.
In the article “Worst Mistake in History of Human Race,” by Jared Diamond (1987), he discusses how the conversion a hunter- gatherer based society to an agricultural based one was a huge mistake. At first it was believed and is still believed by many that it has been one of the best decisions made by humans but he goes on to discuss how it is not and the disadvantages it has caused.
As small mobile aggregations of gatherers embraced an inactive lifestyle, they aced both horticulture and taming of animals. These small gatherings of people immediatel...