Helga's Problem With Commitment in Nella Larsen's Quicksand

1371 Words3 Pages

Helga's Problem With Commitment in Nella Larsen's Quicksand

In Nella Larsen's Quicksand, Helga Crane passively opts out of situations; her actions are consistently reactionary. Helga’s anxiety is the figurative “quicksand” in which she sinks throughout the novel: Helga is too afraid to commit to a decision and thus flees geographically, failing to realize she can not find happiness through avoiding decisions.

Naxos is the first place Helga leaves to flee from commitments. Her engagement to James Vayle makes Helga feel both “shame” and “power,” so she expects to feel “relief” upon canceling the plans (1533). Only once she has left Naxos does Helga realize that “she couldn't have married him...Certainly she had never loved him,” (1543) confirming her earlier speculation. In contrast to her desire to escape the institution of marriage, Helga waivers in deciding to leave Naxos: after Dr. Anderson responds to her announcement, Helga felt “an insistent need to be a part of [his plans] spr[i]ng in her...[w]ith compunction tweaking at her heart for even having entertained the notion of deserting him” (1540). Her reaction could be motivated by aspirations of educating and improving the students of Naxos, but is more likely evoked by the “mystifying yearning” (1540) she experiences while listening to Dr. Anderson. Therefore Helga does not abscond her job, as she had resolved to stay (1541), but the exploration of her feelings; later, Helga even denotes her impulse to leave “illogical” (1541). In any case, Helga can not bear the future she sees for herself at Naxos, as she thinks, “To remain seemed too hard” (1534).

Helga ironically speaks positively of Chicago in noting the “freedom” (1544) it provides her. Since she lacks bot...

... middle of paper ...

...ndon her children (1609); she has trapped herself by anxiously fleeing from free choices, making only reactionary decisions. Larsen describes Helga's reflection: “She had ruined her life[, m]ade it impossible ever again to do the things that she wanted” (1608) by making an inauthentic choice and compromising herself and her happiness.

Larsen notes how Helga is “unused to happiness,” (1542) and how she wonders, “What, exactly...was happiness” (1535). The only hit of Helga’s happiness is her love for Dr. Anderson, and her only true reaction is her consequent disappointment over destroying her potential happiness with him: Helga ultimately realizes “how passionate, how deeply she must have loved him,” (1605) making her inaction tragic.

Work Cited

Larsen, Nella. Quicksand and Passing. 1929. Ed. Deborah E. McDowell. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1986.

Open Document