Group Think

1496 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Advantages and disadvantages of Groupthink

Group Think

This type of dysfunctional operation of an organization has many ways and opportunities for failure. The basic fundamentals of this process are the beginnings of failure as groups seek conformity and unity they sacrifice everything in order to maintain peace within the group. Many times this will take the individuals creative thoughts and ability to voice the creative edge thinking away. In many organizations this is a process that is continually used. It is perceived that management wants the organizations operation or process to run without any type of question or waves. Below are listed eight of the main symptoms of group think as detailed by Janis, I. L & Manns book “Decision making”

Symptoms of Groupthink are divided into three types in which they can manifest

themselves:

Type I: Overestimations of the group's power and morality

Type II: Closed-mindedness

Type III: Pressure toward uniformity

When broken down the three types of groupthink can be broken farther down to

eight ways groupthink causes failure.

1. Illusion of invulnerability: Members ignore obvious danger, take extreme risks, and are overly optimistic.

2. Collective Rationalization: Members discredit and explain away warnings contrary to group thinking.

3. Illusions of Morality: Members believe that their decisions are morally correct ignoring the ethical consequences of their decisions.

4. Excessive Stereotyping: The group constructs negative stereotypes of rivals outside the group.

5. Pressure for Conformity: Members’ pressure any in a group who expresses arguments against the groups’ stereotypes, illusions, or commitment, viewing such opposition and disloyalty.

6. Self-censorship: Members withhold their dissenting views and counter arguments.

7. Illusion of Unanimity: Members perceive falsely that everyone agrees with the group decision silence is seen as consent.

8. Mindguards: Some members appoint themselves to the role of protecting the group from adverse information that might threaten group compliance.

Personal styles are limited by the group with GROUP THINK. Most of the time the individual will not take the chance to buck the system or willing to take the chance of being discredited by the core group if they do not agree with the process and or direction that is being lead.

Decision styles are affe...

... middle of paper ...

...ve that the label of Groupthink can be used too loosely. I myself have experienced situations where a Group is too quick to label themselves as sufferers of Groupthink. Although I truly think that Groupthink is a severe problem that exists today, the Challenger being one of the most disastrous of those examples. I believe that we all need to be careful not to be too swift about the use of the Groupthink label. It can be just as negative to a group to label them as wronged in their process when no such error exists as to call them victims of Groupthink. Again the dilemma is that groups need to always be alert to the existence of Groupthink, they also need to not label themselves or other victims of Groupthink unfairly. Although there are many times that Groupthink leads to failure, there are few instances when it works for the food. This is a fine line to walk, but it is most definitely a line that needs to be walked time and time again.

Works Cited:

Jarvis, Chris. GROUPTHINK

Janis, Irving L. Victims Of Groupthink. Houghton Mifflin Company Boston, 1972

Janis, Irving L. Groupthink. Houghton Mifflin Company Boston, 1982

Griffin, Em. Groupthink. McGraw-Hill Inc., 1997

Show More
Related

  • Irving Janis's Concept Of Groupthink

    1419 Words  | 3 Pages

    The topic of this paper is Irving Janis’s concept of groupthink. There has been an increase in the utilization of groups or teams of people who come together in the decision-making process. There are many benefits to group decision-making with each member brings their own perspectives, beliefs, and ideas to the table. However, there are also negative dynamics such as groupthink that can hinder this process. Groupthink can lead to members believing that their opinions don’t hold as much weight as their peers, a group becoming overconfident in their knowledge of what is right, and the minimization of threats. Lack of thorough analysis of all available options or opportunities can have costly and long reaching negative consequences. Proactive

    Read More

  • Asch's Theory Of Conformity

    1176 Words  | 3 Pages

    Groupthink was coined by Janis and is defined as “a psychological phenomenon in which people strive for consensus within a group”(Cherry). So people will essentially forgo their beliefs to conform to the group to obtain harmony or if they don’t agree with a group idea they will simply keep quiet about it rather than challenge ideas. Janis classified eight different “symptoms” of groupthink. They are Illusions of invulnerability, which leads the members of the group to take part in risk-taking and become overly optimistic. Unquestioned beliefs, leads the members to ignore the possible aftermath that their decisions can make. Rationalizing, hinders members from recognizing warning signs and from reexamining their own beliefs. Stereotyping, leads the members of the group to criticize or write off any other group who may have differing opinions. Self-censorship, makes group members who may have differing opinions not disclose them to the group. "Mindguards",certain members of the group who are self-appointed censors that withhold information they find may disrupt group consensus. Illusions of unanimity, leads the members of the group to think that everyone believes the same things. Direct pressure, this is put on members to conform when they do end up expressing their own opinions or the rest of the group feels as if they are having differing opinions. Janis’s work was influential because it helped us examine the

    Read More

  • The Groupthink Hypothesis

    791 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 1972, Irving Janis presented a set of hypothesis that he extracted from observing small groups performing problem solving tasks; he collectively referred to these hypotheses as groupthink¹. He defined groupthink as “a quick and easy way to refer to a mode of thinking that people engage in when they are deeply involved in a cohesive in-group, when the members’ striving for unanimity override their motivation to realistically appraise alternative courses of action²” A successful group brings varied ideas, collective knowledge, and focus on the task at hand. The importance of groups is to accomplish tasks that individuals can not do on their own. The Bay of Pigs, Watergate, and the Challenger disaster are all forms of failure within a group. Specifically, you can see the effect of groupthink of Americans before September 11, 2001. The thought of harm to the United States was unfathomable, but only after the attacks did they realize they were not invincible. When a solid, highly cohesive group is only concerned with maintaining agreement, they fail to see their alternatives and any other available options. When a group experiences groupthink, they may feel uninterested about a task, don't feel like they will be successful, and the group members do not challenge ideas. Stress is also a factor in the failure of groupthink. An effective group needs to have clear goals, trust, accountability, support, and training. Some indicators that groupthink may be happening are; making unethical decisions, they think they are never wrong, close-minded about situations, and ignore important information. Many things can be done to prevent groupthink from happening. One way is to make each person in the group a “critical evaluator”. The leader must ...

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Euthanasia

    1512 Words  | 4 Pages

    Physician assisted suicide is commonly known as Statutory euthanasia. It is when a terminally ill patient requests a physician to prescribe them a lethal pill, which they can choose to take at any time they feel it is right to hasten their death.. Statutory euthanasia is legal in three states: Oregon, Washington, and Vermont. The terminally ill are the only ones who should

    Read More

  • Conformity

    1489 Words  | 3 Pages

    “Conformity is a form of social influence that involves a change in behavior or belief so that one can fit in with a certain group” (McLeod). Such a change is a response to imagined (which involves the pressure of expectations or social norms) or real (which involves the presence of others) group pressure. Another definition of conformity can be “yielding to group pressures”. Group pressure can take many forms, for example persuasion, teasing, bullying, criticism etc. Conformity is also referred to as group pressure or majority influence. The term conformity is mostly used to show an agreement to the position of the majority, and this is brought about by either by the desire to be liked or to fit in, or just to match a social role. The aim of this paper is to argue that conformity is among people because they always live in groups-work groups, family, political, religious and social groups. At the same instance, they are adjusted to obey authority. A conformist mentality makes it easy for people to be influenced by others.

    Read More

  • Gender Inequality Essay

    1432 Words  | 3 Pages

    In this essay, I will be discussing the statement “Gender Inequalities exist and removing them is fundamental to development”. I will focus on how continents compare in their overall rankings taking in consideration health & survival, education, economic participation and political empowerment, with including a case study for an LEDC and MEDC country.

    Read More

  • Family Systems Theory

    944 Words  | 2 Pages

    According to Richard Charles (2001) “the effectiveness of family systems theory rests not much on empirical research but on clinical reports of positive treatment outcomes, the personal benefits experienced by the families that underwent this kind of treatment, and the elegance of Bowen’s theory” (p. 279). Bowen’s family systems theory views the family as an emotional unit and is a theory of human behavior. Systems thinking are used to describe the complex interactions in the unit. However, the client’s ability to differentiate himself/herself from the family of origin is the basis for Bowen’s family systems theory. In addition, the primary focus for growth within the emotional system is differentiation of self. Differentiation of self will be explored as well as how it relates to a church congregation.

    Read More

  • The Longest Yard Analysis

    1304 Words  | 3 Pages

    Females are not restricted in pay or what job they can do. Today 's culture women are viewed as capable assets to our modern society. Hilary Clinton is the first female to be in the primary election. That is a major accomplishment for women and our culture as a whole to recognize that women can hold the position of The President of the United States of America. In the 2005 film, The Longest Yard, Adam Sandler starred as Paul Crewe. Courtney Cox plays Crewe 's girlfriend, Lena. Like the original film, the first scene Crewe and his girlfriend Lena get into a fight. In the remake, the altercation ends with Paul Crewe locking Lena in her walk in closet. If director Peter Segal decided to go in the same direction as the original film the movie might have not been as acceptable. If Paul Crewe (Adam Sandler) would have beat up his girlfriend he could have had a challenge being portrayed as the hero of the movie. In today 's culture it is greatly frowned upon to strike a woman, not to mention illegal. It was probably not accepted in the 1970s, but director Robert Aldrich must of thought it would not jeopardize Paul Crewe (Burt Reynolds) portraying a hero. The woman of the past stood up for themselves and all women in the

    Read More

  • Understanding Emotional Maturity: Bowen's Differentiation of Self

    720 Words  | 2 Pages

    When considering the development of emotional maturity or the concept of differentiation of self from a psychological perspective, the pioneer systems family theorist Dr. Murray Bowen remains of the most referenced sources. Bowen, starting in early 1974, was one of the first to advance the concept of differentiation of self, as one where ‘The emotional maturity of the individual to interact with others, his or her level of cognition, individuality, self, ego, independence and ability to detach from the emotional problems of others” can be measured, generally on a scale of 1 to 100 with 100 being the most desirable result. Bowen considered the struggle of differentiation to be a lifelong pursuit, and would later extend its application from

    Read More

  • Groupthink

    975 Words  | 2 Pages

    There are eight symptoms of groupthink. The first symptom is when all or most of the group view themselves as invincible which causes them to make decisions that may be risky. The group has an enormous amount of confidence and authority in their decisions as well as in themselves. They see themselves collectively better in all ways than any other group and they believe the event will go well not because of what it is, but because they are involved. The second symptom is the belief of the group that they are moral and upstanding, which leads the group to ignore the ethical or moral consequences of the decisions. The group engages in a total overestimation of its morality. There is never any question that the group is not doing the right thing, they just act. The disregarding of information or warnings that may lead to changes in past policy is the third symptom. Even if there is considerable evidence against their standpoint, they see no problems with their plan. Stereotyping of enemy leaders or others as weak or stupid is the fourth symptom. This symptom leads to close-mindedness to other individuals and their opinions. The fifth symptom is the self-censorship of an individual causing him to overlook his doubts. A group member basically keeps his mouth shut so the group can continue in harmony. Symptom number six refers to the illusion of unanimity; going along with the majority, and the assumption that silence signifies consent. Sometimes a group member who questions the rightness of the goals is pressured by others into concurring or agreeing, this is symptom number seven. The last symptom is the members that set themselves up as a buffer to protect the group from adverse information that may destroy their shared contentment regarding the group’s ...

    Read More

  • The Psychology behind Social Pressure

    1121 Words  | 3 Pages

    To what extent do those around us affect the way we think; they we perceive a situation; or they way we form our prerogatives? There are many different trains of thought, some of which are adopted, others of which are taken into account based on experience and periods of introspection, but there is one that lies with it, a fundamental difference in comparison to others: the group mind. To which it involves several individuals, a group mind is in essence, a collective following to a set of beliefs and/or practices, usually brought together through forms of social pressure and preconceived notions of moral obligation. Furthermore, these groups are often characterized by the absence of individualism and a sense of obliviousness towards how their unspoken rules influences their view of the world as a whole. Moreover, group minds also involve social pressures, often enticing some to forsake their opinions to fit the given status quo of the group. Indeed, humans are social creatures that want to feel as if their participation in a group has value, but without the awareness of how social pressures affect their ability to make decisions and how one can overcome such pressure, they are nothing more but mental toxins, or in other words, group minds.

    Read More

  • Solomon Asch Conformity Experiments (1951)

    1532 Words  | 4 Pages

    Participants were not under any explicit demand to conform, as they received no physical or verbal coercion to do so. The specific hypothesis centered on the idea, “if group pressure can play influence and effect individuals perception, decision and attitudes”. The independent variable will be “Procedure”, and the dependent variable is the “level of conformity did change”.

    Read More

  • Yankee Doodle Analysis

    2211 Words  | 5 Pages

    It was also the first commercially successful song that was written by a woman. The song is about a Native American girl who is singing about her warrior while she travels down the Juniata river. Marion Dix Sullivan is known as the first American woman to write a successful song and her songs are referred to in Mark Twain’s autobiography. Marion also wrote many more songs but none were able to reached the popularity that “The Blue Juniata” hit. African American music was also becoming popular around this time along with more women music artists, proof that times were

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Family Social System

    1406 Words  | 3 Pages

    O'Hara, D., & Meteyard, J. (2011), points out Bowen’s theory also had 8 concepts to assist in understanding where an individual is emotionally in the family

    Read More

  • Physical Security Case Study

    1226 Words  | 3 Pages

    Physical security cannot be wholly successful without the human factor element and the active support of these user groups. For example, when the aim is to protect a critical facility from attack or to provide access control for an office building it is necessary to engage people on the proper use of any security systems that are in place, for instance security alarms. If the alarm goes off and employees have no idea what it signifies

    Read More

More about Group Think

Open Document