An Analysis Of Jane Gay's Bad Feminist By Roxane Gay

1224 Words3 Pages

In Roxane Gay’s book Bad Feminist (2014), she writes an essay, “What We Hunger For”, about the difference between strength and surviving, and the importance of strong female characters. She argues that surviving something doesn’t mean you are strong; life throws unendurable circumstances as people all of the time, and people manage to overcome them and survive, but that doesn’t make them strong. Gay uses Katniss in The Hunger Games trilogy as an example of a relatable, strong female character. Gay describes her as a “heroine with issues” (p. 146). Also in the essay, Gay refers to Meghan Cox Gurdon’s article in the Wall Street Journal about how Young Adult fiction is too dark for its intended audience. Gay argues against it, stating that …show more content…

The first is if strength and survival the same. In other words, does surviving something mean that you are strong. The second questions whether or not Young Adult fiction is too dark for its young readers, or if those readers need to be exposed to the dark circumstances life may hold. Roxane Gay compares Katniss in The Hunger Games to herself in a personal story to show the difference between surviving something and being strong. She also use them to argue against Meghan Cox Gurdon’s thesis that young readers should not be subjected to the darkness and pain that Young Adult fiction usually offers. In “What We Hunger For”, Roxane uses two texts and one personal story to make her arguments. Although at first they don’t seem like they fit together, Roxane Gay pieces them together to form and support her thesis. The first is The Hunger Games trilogy, which follows Katniss Everdeen as she is forced into unendurable situations, and yet, finds a way to overcome them and becomes even stronger because of it. Gay (2014) mentions how the intensity of the traumas that the characters went through struck her, and how dark and brutal the story was. But she also states that the trilogy “offers the tempered hope that everyone who survives something unendurable hungers for” (p.

Open Document