Freud Vs Horney

1103 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Comparison between Sigmund Freud and Karen Horney

Karen Horney (1885-1952) and Sigmund Freud had a multitude of contrasting and opposing opinions on obsession-compulsion neurosis, psychoanalysis, and inner conflicts. As Freud focused on neurosis as an instinctual drive or object relationship drive that was determined biologically, Someone with the obsession disorder, or obsessional-compulsion disorder, they are caught in a neurotic caught in a neurotic bind where they are unknowing on how how to maintain health. Horney believed that obsessional-compulsion neurosis was based on feelings and attitudes that were determined by culture in the mid 1900’s (The Neurotic Personality of Our Time, 20). Karen Horney based her theory off what she grew up around knowing and feeling. Horney’s theory is based off and related to her own personal life and experiences and how she was able to overcome those barriers (….…). Unlike Freud, according to what Horney believed, neurosis is how people have authority over their interpersonal issues and cope with them on an everyday basis (……). Along with this, in opposition to Freud, Horney addresses the idea of personalities in conjunction with …show more content…

Horney stated that obsession-compulsion disorder symptoms arose when individuals began feeling isolated, afraid, helpless, or hostile (……). Pollak states that while obsessive-compulsive neurosis is a relatively rare phenomenon, obsessive-compulsive personality (anal structure) is not (1979). On the other hand, parsimony develops from the continuation of the infantile tendency to retain feces, both because of the erotic pleasure that accompanies retention and because of the fear of losing the overvalued product (Pollak, 1979). Pollak defines the term obsessive-compulsive disorder as it appears to be the preferred term insofar as no etiologic assumptions are implied by

Show More
Related

  • Aurora's Theory Of Personality Development

    1294 Words  | 3 Pages

    To draw a parallel of obsessional neurosis with religion, established disconcerting similarities between compulsive acts and religious practices that, in his view, aimed essentially the same thing: remove the guilt by a ritualistic compensatory restoration. Both the religious obsessive as in the main formula would be similar to what happens psych- scroll in a dream - through which the trivial details of the ritual activity become more important, since they are forcibly expelled the truly meaningful content. Regarding this analogy, Freud concludes that we can conceive of obsessional neurosis as a pathological match against religious formation, featuring obsessional neurosis as an individual religiosity and religion as a universal obsessional neurosis.

    Read More

  • Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder: Nature vs Nurture

    926 Words  | 2 Pages

    Human’s hereditary dispositions and ever-changing eventful life can influence the development of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder. The debate between nature and nurture captivates countless amounts of people who take a side and hold steadfast to their opinion. No agreement will ever be reached until one side can definitively prove the other one wrong beyond a reasonable doubt.

    Read More

  • Obsessive Compulsive Checking

    2580 Words  | 6 Pages

    Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) can be defined as having repetitive, unwanted, urges and thoughts that raise the need for excessive amounts of time or energy spent on the unwanted urges. OCD typically involved ritualistic like tendencies that result in two types of characteristics, obsessions and compulsions. Obsession can be characterized by the actions and thoughts that intrude one’s mind. As well as the uncontrollable and irrational impulses one must face with OCD. Compulsions can be defined as the act of doing excessive things related to behaviors. People feel the need to act on these compulsions for the sole purposes of releasing the anxiety they feel by the compulsive and reoccurring thoughts. In essence,...

    Read More

  • Biological and Psychoanalytic Perspectives in Psychology

    1625 Words  | 4 Pages

    The psychoanalytic perspective grew out of subsequent psychoanalytic theories (1901, 1924, and 1940) following decades of interactions with clients with the use of an innovative procedure developed by Sigmund Freud that required lengthy verbal interactions with patients during which Freud probed deep into their lives. In a nutshell, the psychoanalytic perspective looked to explain personality, motivation, and psychological disorders by focussing on the influence of early childhood experiences, on unconscious motives and conflicts, and on the methods people use to cope with their sexual and aggressive urges. The Biological perspective on the other hand looks at the physiological bases of behaviour in humans and animals. It proposes that an organism’s functioning can be described in terms of the bodily structures and biochemical processes that cause behaviour. This paper attempts to examine the similarities and differences between the psychoanalytic perspective and the biological perspective with the key focus on the core assumptions and features of these perspectives as well as their individual strengths and weaknesses.

    Read More

  • Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)

    992 Words  | 2 Pages

    Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is a type of anxiety disorder that can be best characterized by the recurrent or disturbing thoughts that are labeled as obsessions. Sometime these obsessions can take on the form of intrusive images or the unwanted impulses. The compulsions can come from the repetitive or ritualized behaviors that a person feels driven to perform on a daily basis. The majority of people with the diagnosis of OCD can have both obsessions and compulsions, but most of the times about 20% have obsessions alone while 10% may have the compulsions alone (Goodman M.D., 2013) . Common types that have been illustrated in individual’s diagnoses with OCD can be characterized with concerns of contamination, safety or harm to themselves, unwanted acts of aggression, the unacceptable sexual or religious thoughts, and the need for symmetry or exactness. While some of the most common compulsion can be characterized as excessive cleaning, checking, ordering, and arranging rituals or the counting and repeating routines activities that are done sometimes on a daily basis multiple times in a day.

    Read More

  • Freud and Hansel and Gretel

    1624 Words  | 4 Pages

    2) Hansel - Hansel is a 14 year old Caucasian male and his ethnicity is German. He has had no formal education, but learned what he could from his father and mother while they were both alive. He is very skinny and has an average health at the beginning of the story. His social status is fairly low as a person within the forest; this is because he is poor, has a lack of resources and was not born as a female witch. Hansel on a daily basis attempts to help his father gather food, although he is not very good at it. When Hansel has free time he enjoys exploring in the forest.

    Read More

  • Freud and Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

    2600 Words  | 6 Pages

    Freud developed his theory from interactions with his neurotic patients and his own psychological experiences. He classifies an obsessional neurotic is classified as one who if “aware of impulses in [himself] which appear very strange,” is “led to actions, the performance of which, give him no enjoyment, but which it is quite impossible for [him] to omit” (Freud Abstracts 2). In Frankenstein’s ...

    Read More

  • Compulsive Disorder: An Analysis Of Melvin Udall In As Good As It Gets

    1808 Words  | 4 Pages

    Obsessive-compulsive disorder has been classified as a type of anxiety disorder under DSM-5, in which there is a presence of obsessions, compulsions or both. Obsessions are defined as “intrusive and mostly nonsensical thoughts, images, or urges that the individual tries to resist or eliminate,” while compulsion are the thought or actions that accompany these obsessions to try to suppress and provide relief. (TEXTBOOK) The obsessions are categorized into four major types, and each is linked with a certain pattern of compulsive behaviors.

    Read More

  • The Ego and the Id

    1504 Words  | 4 Pages

    Over the years, people have wondered what goes on in a person's mind that guides them to meet their needs. Sigmund Freud developed a system of personality that boldly attempts to explain the course of personality and what was it origins. Freud theory assumes that one's personality is shaped and some powerful inner forces motivate one's behavior. According to Freud, personality differences commence from the different ways in which people deal with their underlying drives. By picturing a continuing battle between antagonistic parts of personality, Freud was able to develop three systems that make up the total personality. The three systems of personality are the id, ego, and the superego. If the three systems work together in harmony and unite together to form one complete organization, it enables one to create a positive transaction with the environment. If the systems are fighting with each other, one is said to be dissatisfied with himself or the world. By examining the ego, the id, and the superego, one should see how these three systems of personality play an important role in the development of one's personality. In doing so one should understand what conscious and unconscious, and the functions of the id, ego, and superego.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Freud's Psychoosexual Stages

    829 Words  | 2 Pages

    Inherently representing the conflict between the id, which is the natural impulse of ridding bodily waste, and the “ego and superego, which represent the practical and societal pressures to control the bodily functions.” (Stevenson, 2000) According to Freud’s Psychosexual Theory, there are two types of personalities that can branch, “anal-retentive personality” or “anal-expulsive personality.” Anal-retentive personality” in which a parent is strict with toilet disciplining would make a child inherently obsessively organized, neat, disciplined, methodical, systematic and more passive-aggressive. On the other hand, “anal-expulsive” which is when a parent is too lenient in toilet disciplining would lead to an unorganized, thoughtless, inconsiderate, and rebellious, bold personality. This stage lasts until three years old in which the next stage takes over. (McLeod,

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud Versus Albert Ellis

    981 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...s, feelings, and thoughts. However, Freud does this by resurfacing the unconscious to consciousness. While, Ellis’ theory focuses on what the client thinks rather than what they do. He believes that irrational thinking leads to irrational behaviour while Freud believes that childhood experiences have an affect on behaviour.

    Read More

  • Freud vs. Rogers on Human Nature

    813 Words  | 2 Pages

    Famous psychological theorists Sigmund Freud and Carl Rogers were both the greatest researchers in our modern time. They both made a lot of advancement in psychological fields, clinical evidence and expertise. They both developed a theory of 'hidden' personality’, in which the psychologists theorized that people have a ‘hidden' personality within them, one which they are not aware of. This concept indicated that the human nature and the role play in rationale behind the human motivation. Sigmund Freud and Carl Rogers do have same common in their theories. They were both influenced by working within their patients and shared the familiarity through the many years of clinical performance. Based on their experimental studies, Sigmund Freud believed that the human nature is inherently aggressive, and Carl Rogers sustained that the people are innately are good. Indeed, Sigmund Freud and Carl Rogers have diverse opinions and different assumptions on the personality of a human. During the contemporary scientific research, I prefer to agree with Roger’s theory over the Freudian model because it is more in tune with findings of my experiences.

    Read More

  • A Comparison Between Freud and Erikson

    1947 Words  | 4 Pages

    Developmental psychology is an area of research dedicated to the understanding of child-development. Throughout history many theories have been used to attempt to explain the complex process. Two of those theorists, Freud and Erikson, were instrumental in creating a foundation for child-psychology to build on. From a Freudian perspective, human development is centered on psychosexual theory. Psychosexual theory indicates that maturation of the sex drives underlies stages of personality development. Alternatively, Erikson is considered a neo-freudian scholar who developed psychosocial theory. In Erikson models there are eight major conflicts that occur during the course of an individual’s life.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Freud And Karen Horney

    1381 Words  | 3 Pages

    There have been many theorist in psychology such as Erik Erickson, Gordon Allport, and Raymond Cattell, among others. They have all made significant contributions to psychology and understanding human behavior. However, two theorist have distinguished themselves over the rest of them. Sigmund Freud is known as the father of psychoanalysis. He developed numerous theories to facilitate the understanding of the different stages humans go through. As well as Freud, Karen Horney also created her own theories. Her theories were relatively similar to Freud’s, however, they also have their differences. It is essential to have general knowledge of their background and to understand both of their theories before we begin contrasting them.

    Read More

  • Freud vs Piaget

    1027 Words  | 3 Pages

    When comparing the work of Sigmund Freud and Jean Piaget two things come to mind, they both had a lasting and profound impact on the field of psychology and both received a great amount of criticism regarding their theories. Freud is considered the founder of psychoanalysis, which is based on childhood development and psychosexual stages. Piaget was the top developmentalist of the 1960s and 1970s. His theory of cognitive development was as well studied as Freud's theory of psychosexual development was a generation before. While they both had many criticisms of their work, both Freud and Piaget influenced their respective fields of psychology so much that today their thoughts and concepts are still studied and referenced everyday. Freud’s theories have revolutionized how we think. The impact Piaget has had on developmental psychology has guided social norms of human development and education. This essay will compare and contrast the theories of Freud and Piaget.

    Read More

More about Freud Vs Horney

Open Document