First Amendment Pros And Cons

1822 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The mental health crisis in African Americans

In recent news, Colin Kaepernick and other NFL players have experienced scrutiny by the government, media, and the public because they stand in solidarity against the oppression of people of color relating to police brutality against young black males. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) allows NFL players have the right to exercise their First Amendment freedom of speech, expression, and protest in support of people of color who are being oppressed even though the discrimination of Colin Kaepernick led to the league discard him. On the other hand, playing devil’s advocate, the First Amendment also supports the beliefs of their being a superior power catering to those of a superior race. Criticisms from Donald Trump and other Americans …show more content…

Agency is the capacity of individuals to act independently by making their own free choices based on the own will. However, NFL player’s First Amendment rights are being fringed upon because of the slander remarks of Donald Trump and his administration towards the players and kneel/sit during the national anthem. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin answers in an interview with ABC that president Donald Trump should communicate with the owners to implicate a rule that all players must stand during the national anthem to respect the people who have fought and died for our country. Steven Mnuchin portrays his point of view that NFL players can exercise their First Amendment, but off the field on their own time[4]. Harmoniously, Trump and Mnuchin agree the players can only have their First Amendment right off the field and should obey all rules and regulations placed by the NFL owners. The Source’s article, WashU Expert: NFL protests are free speech, but not protected by First Amendment, explains the legal aspect of why NFL players do not have constitutional rights in the league. Greg Margarian, professor of law at Washington University in St. Louis, explains: “The NFL players’ protests around the National Anthem remind us that the First Amendment applies, as a matter of law, only to government action. Employees of private companies do not have constitutional rights against their …show more content…

NFL is a form of modern day slavery. There are no black owners, but majority of the league is black. Prime, hyped psychical abilities are what recruiting scout’s search for. The place black people against each other, having no regards for their physical safety because players were taught to go for devastating blows on the other team. The enforcement of punishment against speaking out is may lead to the termination of one’s career as a professional athlete. The quarterbacks, leaders/face of the team, are predominately white. As discussed in class, black children were raised with the mentality the in order to get an into higher education and become successful in life is to play sports. Going to school and being educated are two different aspects of education that athletes have exposure to. Student-athletes have no authority over their lives because other people are running it for them. The white owners receive all the praise for the success of their team. The NFL combine is a modern day auction for black, athletic bodies. The value of their importance decreases when injured. Injustice started before the child is born. Having limited resources and support provided by their parent(s) reflects in the school system. People of color are placed at a low standard because of the stereotypes surrounding life as a person of color. Discriminations such as the

Show More
Related

  • Maurice Clarett's Case Summary

    529 Words  | 2 Pages

    For this assignment, we learned that Maurice Clarett filed a case against the NFL where he argued that the NFL’s three-year rule acted as an unreasonable restraint in violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act and the Clayton Act. On the other hand, the NFL argued that its three-year rule was covered from the antitrust laws by the nonstatutory labor exemption. First, the case was reviewed by the district court which concluded that the NFL's eligibility rules violated antitrust laws by requiring the player to wait at least three years before entering the NFL draft and that the eligibility criteria was not immune from those antitrust laws. The court favored Clarett making him eligible for the 2004 NFL Draft.

    Read More

  • Deontology In The NFL

    266 Words  | 1 Pages

    The NFL position in this article makes them look very greedy and indifferent about the overall health of their football players. One of the ethical perspectives that can be used to analyze the NFL's position in this article is deontology. Deontology is the perspective where rules is the defining factor for ethical decisions. From the deontology perspective it makes it seem that the NFL has decided not to follow the rules and even blurred the lines as to what potential injuries their players can get. They wanted their injured players to play without having to follow through the with proper procedure in verifying that the players are in conditions healthy enough to play. It looks as if the NFL cares only about bringing in money and not care about

    Read More

  • Colin Kaepernick And The Question Of Who Gets To Be Called A 'Patriot'

    1194 Words  | 3 Pages

    The issue of being unpatriotic during the National Anthem was raised by people when NFL quarterback, Colin Kaepernick decided to kneel during the national anthem before a preseason game. Later, Kaepernick addressed the media by saying this act was a stance against “police brutality on people of color”. By raising the

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast College Football Vs Nfl

    1111 Words  | 3 Pages

    In college there are hated rivals that can’t stand each other. This causes college fans to have lots of pride in their teams. College stadiums also have student sections, which take the atmosphere on game day to the next level. College players know how the fans feel. This inspires them to play their hardest, and leave everything on the field to represent their school. In the NFL, instead of playing for a team because you want to represent them, players will play for teams who offer them the longest and largest contracts. Players hold out from participating in training camp because they want a bigger contract, and some even sit out games. The NFL seems to be more like a business, and geared towards making money. NFL players holding out, and being focused on money angers fans. Not all players are like this, but fans feel that the ones like this are being

    Read More

  • Black Athletes in Society

    2265 Words  | 5 Pages

    This article proposes the idea of what would happen if Black people really embraced the sports world and made that their priority instead of education, “He provides the example of percentages of Black males competing in the NBA (77%), NFL (65%), MLB (15%), and MLS (16%) in comparison to the fact that fewer than 2% of doctors, lawyers, architects, college professors, or business executives are Black males,”. Dr. Robinson brings up the sta…..

    Read More

  • The NFL Lockout

    1013 Words  | 3 Pages

    Business deals happen every day; Contracts expire, renew, and are negotiated without the public knowing for many large corporations and even sporting leagues. However, some contract changes cannot escape the media’s attention. The National Football League (NFL) is facing an expiration of its Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) (NFL Lockout Now One Month Old). Currently, the agreement has expired and NFL team owners have selfishly chosen to “lock” the players out. The term lockout means that the players are essentially not allowed to participate in any team activities or duties until the owner’s rescind this lockout. While many believe this is simply a battle between team owners and a player union, it can only appear to most as a selfish act of the NFL owners trying to rich, greedy men in expensive suits, and the only people they are hurting, are the fans of football.

    Read More

  • Black Athletes' Graduation Rates Weak

    1852 Words  | 4 Pages

    Major collegiate athletics programs are able to generate millions of dollars for their institutions, but are not able to show any evidence of successfully graduating their black male athletes that contribute to their success in generating those millions of dollars. These universities in turn, are failing these student athletes whom were promised that they would nurture them intellectually as well as athletically. A four year report published by the University of Pennsylvania's Graduate School of Education presents statistics that shows that the six major sports conferences in the NCAA (ACC, Big Ten, Big East, Big 12, SEC, Pac 12) have weak graduation rates for male African American Student athletes. Jessica Anderson of the associated press wrote an article titled, Black Athletes' Graduation Rates Weak where she used evidence from the University of Pennsylvania’s study as well as information from The Center for the Study of Race and Equity in Education to present findings that showed that only about, “50.2 percent of African-American male student-athletes graduated within six years and that 96.1 percent of the schools graduated African-American male student-athletes at rates lower than student-athletes overall” (Anderson). Yet, the evidence that African American male student athletes are struggling to graduate as compared to their white counterparts does not simply stop there. In fact, Shaun Harper the executive director of the Center for the Study of Race and Equity in Education at the University of Pennsylvania reports that, “50.2 percent of black male athletes graduate within six years from colleges compared with 67 percent of athletes over all, 73 percent of undergraduates, and 56 percent of black undergraduate men” (Harper)....

    Read More

  • The NCAA and College Athlete

    983 Words  | 2 Pages

    The players have become employees of the NCAA as much as students -- employees with no compensation, which not only violates common decency but perhaps even the law.

    Read More

  • Football Coaches, Where is the Diversity?

    1083 Words  | 3 Pages

    IV. Review of the Rooney Rule Robert Gulliver, the NFL’s executive vice president of human resources, released this statement last year concerning the Rooney Rule: “While there has been full compliance with the interview requirements of the Rooney Rule and we wish the new head coaches and general managers much success, the hiring results this year have been unexpected and reflect a disappointing lack of diversity. The Rooney Rule has been a valuable tool in expanding diversity and inclusion in hiring practices, but there is more work to do, especially around increasing and strengthening the pipeline of diverse candidates for head coach and senior football executive positions.

    Read More

  • National Anthem Kneeling

    595 Words  | 2 Pages

    After calling all athletes who kneeled during the National Anthem cruel names, not only did more kneelers appear, but the standing teammates linked arms showing unity. Their reason may not’ve been only to protest on racial injustice, but to rebel against Donald Trump and show that this is their right. Various people, including President Trump, think that every athlete who has kneeled should be fired because they should not be able to protest in such a disrespectful way. It’s not only fans who find this protest wrong, but even some players do, including Drew Brees. Brees says he agrees with the context of the protest, but not the actions of it stating, "[I]t's an oxymoron that you're sitting down, disrespecting that flag that has given you the freedom to speak

    Read More

  • Racism in Sports and the African American College Athlete

    642 Words  | 2 Pages

    The role of college athletics in the American home is known to all. The traditional football games on Thanksgiving and New Year's Day. March Madness for NCAA men's basketball as well as the year's end Rose bowl for college football leaves fans glued to their televisions for hours. Millions of Americans stare at ESPN or absorb themselves in the most recent issue of Sports Illustrated just to catch the latest news on their favorite teams' recruits, recent games, and statistics. Often just viewed as a past time to most it is easy to lose sight of why these athletes are on the field , court, etc. to begin with. Believe it or not, it's for their education. These young adults ranging anywhere from seventeen to twenty-three years of age are all members of the NCAA (National Collegiate Athletic Association). As such these students must initially meet the requirements to get accepted into their chosen university, participate in their sport, and ultimately graduate from their selected institution. It is often forgotten that these members are students first and athletes second. Delving deeper into this very controversial matter are the race and gender issues that come into play. The most affected minority group affected by these stipulations and is the African American. While struggling through the ongoing prejudice and discrimination that still exists today, African American athletes are still expected to follow the same guidelines as every other student that participates in college athletics. By investigating the trends from the past years of African American athletes beginning with their entrance into college throughout their athletic and academic careers and then a...

    Read More

  • Gregg Easterbrook The King Of Sports Summary

    549 Words  | 2 Pages

    For the avid sports maniac as well as the casual sports viewer, Gregg Easterbrook’s “The King of Sports: Football’s Impact on America” is a must-read. Easterbrook gives detailed insight to many of the critical issues plaguing American football both on the professional and college level. The “non-profit” mongul know as the NFL is exposed and is clearly described for the reader. This is a great book not just for the wealth information, but also, an attempt to highlight the flaws in our country's most prized form of entertainment.

    Read More

  • Racism In Friday Night Lights By H. G. Bissinger

    1232 Words  | 3 Pages

    Months before, a white football fan in a dusty little town watched #35 as he sprinted down the field; the fan did not really see some black kid, they saw a Mojo running back. Just like so many other fans, they cheer for the black and white jersey, not particularly caring about the color of the body it’s on. The fans saw #35 as the future of their much-exalted football team; the color of his skin seemed irrelevant. As long as he wore the jersey and performed every week like he should, they celebrated him as the Great Black Hope of the 1988 season. Now, injury has taken him from the game that he devoted his life to, and he is no longer #35. Instead, he is just another useless black kid who will never amount to anything in the rigid society that

    Read More

  • The Historiography of Race and Discrimination in Baseball and Sports

    3242 Words  | 7 Pages

    Historical and sociological research has shown, through much evidence collection and analysis of primary documents that the American sporting industry can give an accurate reflection, to a certain extent, of racial struggles and discrimination into the larger context of American society. To understand this stance, a deep look into aspects of sport beyond simply playing the game must be a primary focus. Since the integration of baseball, followed shortly after by American football, why are the numbers of African American owners, coaches and managers so very low? What accounts for the absence of African American candidates from seeking front office and managerial roles? Is a conscious decision made by established members of each organization or is this matter a deeper reflection on society? Why does a certain image and persona exist amongst many African American athletes? Sports historians often take a look at sports and make a comparison to society. Beginning in the early 1980’s, historians began looking at the integration of baseball and how it preceded the civil rights movement. The common conclusion was that integration in baseball and other sports was indeed a reflection on American society. As African Americans began to play in sports, a short time later, Jim Crow laws and segregation formally came to an end in the south. Does racism and discrimination end with the elimination of Jim Crow and the onset of the civil rights movement and other instances of race awareness and equality? According to many modern sports historians and sociologists, they do not. This paper will focus on the writings of selected historians and sociologists who examine th...

    Read More

  • Racism In Sports Essay

    1193 Words  | 3 Pages

    The scholars expounds that Black athletes were commodities on the playing field to help win games and bring in revenue to their respected schools. However, the schools were just as eager and willing to leave their Black players behind and dishonoring the player as a part of the team. Therefore, not compromising the team’s winning and bring in profits for the school. Sadly, Black athletes at predominately White institutions (PWIs) who believed that they were bettering the live of themselves and their families members by going to college and playing collegiate sports to increase their post secondary careers. However, these athletes were only “show ponies” for their schools. Unfortunately, Black athletes had allegiance to their school; however, the school turned their backs on the athletes to protect the profit and notoriety of the school and the programs. Money and respect from White fans and spectators were more important to the PWIs than standing up for the respect of their Black players. Racial bigotry in sports was rampant and it was only going to get worse.

    Read More

More about First Amendment Pros And Cons

Open Document