Essay on the Defense of Walls in Mending Wall

562 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Theme of the poem mending wall

Opposing the Unthinking Defense of Walls in Mending Wall

The speaker in "Mending Wall" questions his neighbor's stolid assumption that "good fences make good neighbors." Perhaps, what he objects to is not so much the sentiment itself as the unwillingness or inability of the other to think for himself, to "go beyond his father's saying." Just so; we must try to get beyond the apophthegm-like opening line of "Mending Wall," testing carefully for gradations of tone as we proceed. Is it the proverb-like authority of "something there is . . . " that makes it so natural to equate "something" with the speaker? Once this equation has been made, the reader joins the speaker in sympathizing with this mysterious "something" and hence in opposing the neighbor's unthinking defense of walls.

Frost rings subtly drastic changes on the sound of a phrase like "good fences make good neighbors." By the time the poem ends, this line has acquired some of the pat stupidity of a slogan. Similar turns of the screw affect the opening line, when to it is added the darker phrase "that wants it down" and again when the speaker refuses to name the antiwall "something." "Elves" is the closest he gets, yet "It's not elves exactly, and I'd rather / He said it for himself." Elves may mean not willowy things out of Tolkien but darker forces of the wood, for the next image is one of darkness. The neighbor is viewed as subtly menacing, "an old-stone savage armed." Yet this man has been the one to defend boundaries. The apparently relaxed and leisurely pace of the poem has made us lower our own boundaries and forget who is on what side.

At any rate, although the speaker's ironic evasiveness undermines any confident interpretation, Poirier is surely right when he makes the following point:

. . . .it is not the neighbor . . . a man who can only dully repeat "good fences make good neighbors"-- . . .it is not he who initiates the fence-making. Rather it is the far more spirited, lively, and "mischievous" speaker of the poem. While admitting that they do not need the wall, it is he who each year "lets my neighbor know beyond the hill" that it is time to do the job anyway, and who will go out alone to fill the gaps made in the wall by hunters.

Show More
Related

  • Essay On The Death Penalty

    1306 Words  | 3 Pages

    The first established death penalty laws date as far back as the Eighteenth Century B.C. in the Code of King Hammaurabi of Babylon. The death penalty was also part of the Fourteenth Century B.C. 's Hittite Code; in the Seventh Century B.C. 's Draconian Code of Athens, which made death the only punishment for all crimes; and in the Fifth Century B.C. 's Roman law of the Twelve Tablets. Death sentences were carried out by such means as crucifixion, drowning, beating to death, burning alive, and impalement. In the Tenth Century A.D., hanging became the usual method of execution in Britain. In the following century, William the Conqueror would not allow persons to be hanged or otherwise executed for any crime, except in times of war. Some common

    Read More

  • Working Together in Robert Frost's Mending Wall

    867 Words  | 2 Pages

    The speaker believes, "Something there is that doesn't love a wall"(Stanford 1, 28). What sets this line apart from others? First there are only two phrases repeated in this piece of Robert Frost's work and we hear the speaker posing the first of them. Due to an otherwise lack of repetition, we can see that Robert Frost is trying to exemplify to the reader the different perspe...

    Read More

  • Robert Frost's Mending Wall

    523 Words  | 2 Pages

    The speaker questions many things in relation to the wall that is being rebuilt. For example, “Something there is that doesn’t love a wall”, is used to question what despises the wall’s presence. The speaker goes on to discuss the earth’s swells that make gaps in the wall, as well as the hunters, “not leaving a stone on a stone,” (l. 7) merely to please the yelping dogs with a rabbit. In line thirty, the speaker questions, “Why do they make good neighbors” because he believes that the wall is interfering with a possible relationship with his neighbor. Another key question asked is “What I was walling in or walling out,” to show that there is no difference when the wall is construct or not, both neighbor’s tasks a...

    Read More

  • Watson's Theory Of Wound Care

    845 Words  | 2 Pages

    Working in a wound care setting and seeing the stress that it brings to an individual’s life is can be a challenging situation. Many people do not have a good understanding of how the human body works and how one disease process affects another. Highly educated people often have no idea how a little sore on a foot ultimately can causes loss of toes,feet and unfortunately limbs.

    Read More

  • Analysis of Mending Wall by Robert Frost

    398 Words  | 1 Pages

    this reflects that nature itself does not like separation. The "something" refers to the intangible sense of social interaction. Furthermore "that sends the frozen-ground-swell under it" refers to Frost or to the author. Although the narrator does not want the wall, ironically, the mending of the wall brings the neighbors together and literally builds their friendship. An additional irony of the poem is that the only time these two neighbors see each other is when they both mend the wall.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Intermittent Fasting

    1627 Words  | 4 Pages

    The system of this dieting method varies from person to person ranging from 16 to 32 hours. If an individual is fasting for 16 hours, he/she can do it everyday since it still provides a time frame during which one can eat. On the contrary, on the more extreme side, if one is fasting for 32 hours, he/she should do it only once a week. The best option however, is if one fasts for 24 hours. This can be done as rarely as twice a week to as frequently as everyday; this is because, one can still eat everyday. If one stops eating at 7 pm, he/she can eat again at 7 pm the following day. During this

    Read More

  • Characteristics Of Dystopian Society

    1237 Words  | 3 Pages

    Dystopian Societies follow a repeated trend in which Information, independent thought, and freedom are restricted. Citizens live in a dehumanized state and are perceived to be under constant surveillance. Severe punishments are enforced when the boundaries of group norms are tested. Throughout Amaryllis, the authorities enforce strict restrictions against the out of control population growth affecting the society. “Thirty- five years ago, my mother ripped out her own implants…She got pregnant… and broke up her household…they were scattered over the region…”.The consequence faced by Marie’s mother highlight the harsh penalties faced by citizens for pushing the boundaries for something that is considered a human right in the current society. Authorities also impose regulations on the amount of produce each family can utilise as it is “the only way to keep the population under control”. The citizens of the underground mining society created by Mastroianni in Jordon’s Waterhammer follow similar disciplinary rules. This is evident in the following eyewitness account by Jordon. “…heard the controller say, Loader Solomon is in violation of quota as required by ordinance 62.1.3. They pressed a particle gun to Solomon’s temple. Solomon dropped dead to the floor.” Just like Marie’s mother, Jordon’s friend Solomon faces deadly consequences for exceeding quota showing the reader the level of strictness of the society. As well as this, the citizen that do abide by the rules, are forced to live in harsh conditions which include “ hearing controls from within the brain” and “sleeping in a closely monitored sarcophagus”. Although strict restrictions are enforced to “keep the society in order”, the citizens face inhuman conditions regardless of whether they break the law or abide by it. This is a major characteristic which has been focused upon in

    Read More

  • Alchemy -the Predecessor Of Modern Chemistry

    659 Words  | 2 Pages

    Because other metals were thought to be less perfect than gold, it was reasonable to believe that nature created gold out of other metals found deep within the earth and that a skilled artisan could duplicate this process. It was said that once someone was able to change, or transmute a "base" chemical into the perfect metal, gold, they would have achieved eternal life and salvation. In this way, alchemy turned into not only a scientific quest, but a spiritual quest as well. Although the purposes and techniques were often times ritualistic and fanciful, alchemy was in many ways the predecessor of modern science, especially the science of chemistry.The birthplace of alchemy was ancient Egypt, where, in Alexandria, it began to flourish during the Hellenistic period. Also at that time, a school of alchemy was developing in China.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Robert Frost's Mending Wall

    1410 Words  | 3 Pages

    The wall is a simple stone structure, but the narrator feels as if it creates two separate worlds between the men. It’s unnatural, something that even nature doesn’t love, as it “ sends the frozen-ground-swell under it / And spills the upper boulders in the sun” (ll 2-3): that is to say, when the ground freezes in cold weather, the stone divider begins to fall apart, as if nature never wanted it there to begin with. The neighbor, on the other hand, adores the wall, and repeatedly tells the narrator, “good fences make good neighbors” (l 27). It’s a statement the narrator has learned to despise. Why must they put any border between one another? The only purpose it serves is to make the narrator feel more isolated from his neighbor, who is more than happy to keep others out. No matter how much the narrator pleads to be rid of the barrier between them, the neighbor simply claims, “good fences make good

    Read More

  • The Hidden Meaning of Robert Frost's Mending Wall

    435 Words  | 1 Pages

    "Mending Wall" is a poem written by the poet Robert Frost. The poem describes two neighbors who repair a fence between their estates. It is, however, obvious that this situation is a metaphor for the relationship between two people. The wall is the manifestation of the emotional barricade that separates them. In this situation the "I" voice wants to tear down this barricade while his "neighbor" wants to keep it.

    Read More

  • Poem Analysis: Mend Walls by Robert Frost

    1066 Words  | 3 Pages

    My first reading of the poem has left me with many unanswered questions. The beginning lines were very confusing. I couldn’t quite tell if what Frost was saying was meant to be literal or not. Much of the first half is unclear to me. But by the second half I think I see more of the story. I do like the language Frost uses to describe the seasons and how they lead to the main character asking for the wall to be taken down. At this point I think that the story is about two men owning two plots of land and one wants to keep a wall up dividing them and closing them off from each other while the other wants to open the gap. I still don’t see much of the true meaning behind the story. But at the end of the story the main character says the neighbor repeats that his father said by saying, “good fences make good neighbors”. The second reading of the poem is slightly easier. I think I am beginning to understand some the metaphors that Frost is using. In line ten Frost s...

    Read More

  • The World Trade Organization: The Evolution Of The World Trade Organization

    1343 Words  | 3 Pages

    Today, the WTO membership numbers 146 which comprises of approximately 97 per cent of the worlds’ trade (www.WTO.org). The evolution of GATT to the WTO was a significant step towards liberalising markets and ushered in a new era of free trade. Although the WTO is still a relatively young international institution, its origins are rooted in the Bretton Woods conference following the end of World War II. The WTO has evolved to cover areas such as trade in goods and services as well as Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) and continues to provide the key disciplines affecting international trade.

    Read More

  • Walls Placed on Relationships in Mending Wall by Robert Frost

    846 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the poem "Mending Wall," Robert Frost utilizes the literary devices of imagery, meter, and symbolism to demonstrate the rational and irrational boundaries or metaphoric "walls" humans place on their relationships with others. The precise images, such as the depiction of the mending-time ritual and the dynamic description of his "old-stone savage armed" neighbor, serve to enhance our enjoyment as well as our understanding of the poem (40). The poem is written in blank verse (iambic pentameter); the form that most closely resembles everyday English. Frost deliberately employs this direct, conversational, and easy to understand style of meter which appears simple on the surface. Although symbolism is used throughout, the three most significant symbols are: the wall, his neighbor, and Frost himself as the speaker. Analyzing each of these devices as well as how they harmonize with one another is necessary in order to appreciate what Frost was revealing about human behavior.

    Read More

  • Alchemy

    858 Words  | 2 Pages

    concerning the chemistry of gold and silver to be burned in order to stop such

    Read More

  • Impacts of WTO on Trading Countries

    1293 Words  | 3 Pages

    International trading has had its delays and road blocks, which has created a number of problems for countries around the world. Countries, fighting with one another to get the better deal, create tariffs and taxes to maximize their profit. This fighting leads to bad relationships with competing countries, and the little producing countries get the short end of this stick. Regulations and organizations have been established to help everyone get the best deal, such as the World Trade Organization (WTO), but not everyone wants help, especially from an organization that seems to help only the big countries and those they want to trade with. This paper will be discussing international trading with emphasis on national sovereignty, the World Trade Organization, and how the WTO impacts trading countries.

    Read More

More about Essay on the Defense of Walls in Mending Wall

Open Document