Elements Of Murder

917 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: 7 principles of criminal law

Murder Assignment

Alvin is facing a murder charge under the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 11 which states that ‘any person who commits murder shall be guilty of an offence and shall be imprisoned for life’.

Conduct Elements (Actus Reus)

Voluntariness
Under the common law established in He Kaw The v The Queen , only voluntary conduct can give rise to criminal liability . In contemplating whether Alvin’s actions were voluntary, there are three considerations to be addressed; if the criminal act was accidental, caused by a reflex action or if the conduct was performed while the accused was in a state of impaired consciousness. Alvin has alleged that the initial incident of him stabbing his wife, Vanna, occurred due to him losing …show more content…

The Prosecution may argue that Alvin’s words “You are dead to me” made immediately prior to the stabbing, whilst the accused and the victim were engaged in a heated argument, along with the accused laughing after the stabbing, suggest that Alvin intended to kill Vanna. However, in Alvin’s statement to the police he has acknowledged that he intented to scare Vanna rather than stab her, and the witness statements that Alvin said the words “I’m sorry” whilst carrying her through the door, along with his assertion that he was seeking medical assistance for her, would support Alvin’s claims that he did not intent to kill Vanna and may encourage reasonable doubt that he held this intention.
If the prosecution us unable to prove Alvin intended to kill Vanna, the offence may still be made out if it can be shown that he intended to cause grevious bodily …show more content…

Applying Thabo Meli v R , there must have been a preconceived plan to murder Vanna. It is possible to argue that Alvin possessed the necessary Mens Rea when he stabbed Vanna in the neck, but not when he knocked her head on the wall, which was the substantial cause of death. However, it could also be argued that as the stabbing and the head knock were part of the same sequence of events, actus reus and mens rea should be found to have coincided, according to the unbinding, persuasive English case of R v Le Brun

Show More
Related

  • State V Marshall Case Study

    1625 Words  | 4 Pages

    Facts: Rex Marshall testified that the deceased came into his store intoxicated, and started whispering things to his wife. The defendant stated that he ordered the deceased out of the store immediately, however the deceased refused to leave and started acting in an aggressive manner; by slamming his hate down on the counter. He then reached for the hammer, the defendant states he had reason to believe the deceased was going to hit him with the hammer attempting to kill him. Once the deceased reached for the hammer the defendant shot him almost immediately.

    Read More

  • Elements Of Crime And The Murder Of Sarah May Ward

    1151 Words  | 3 Pages

    On June 7th 2008, Sarah May Ward was arrested for the murder of Eli Westlake after she ran him over in a motor vehicle in St. Leonards. Prior to the incident the offender had been driving the wrong way down Christine Lane which was a one way street. Whilst this was occurring she was intoxicated, under the influence of marijuana, valium, and ecstasy and was unlicensed to drive. The victim and his brother who were also intoxicated, where walking down the lane and where nearly hit by the offender. This prompted the victim to throw cheese balls at the car and make a few sarcastic remarks regarding her driving ability. After a brief confrontation between the two parties the victim and his brother turned away and proceeded to walk down Lithgow Street. The offender followed the victim into the street and drove into him while he was crossing a driveway.

    Read More

  • Ruth Ellis Case Study

    3427 Words  | 7 Pages

    Ellis’ case centres on some interesting words which were said by Ruth after committing her crime “When I put the gun in my bag I intended to find David and shoot him”. She was put to death for this because at the time the law dictated the premeditated murder as a capital offense and no leniency was allowed. Ellis was a victim of domestic abuse which led to the tragic miscarriage of her unborn child; this is what leads Ellis to retaliate and to shoot her lover. Derek Bentley Case Study: Secondly, I am going to present some background information on Derek Bentley’s case.

    Read More

  • Battered Woman Syndrome: The Case Of Donna Osborn

    1138 Words  | 3 Pages

    Your honor, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, thank you for your attention today. [Slide #2] I would like to assert that separation is not the end of a relationship. Divorce is not the end of a relationship. Even an arrest is not the end of a relationship. Only death is the end of a relationship. In the case of defendant Donna Osborn, her insistence that ‘“one way or another I’ll be free,”’ as told in the testimony of her friend Jack Mathews and repeated in many others’, indicates that despite the lack of planning, the defendant had the full intent to kill her husband, Clinton Osborn.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Murderers Are Among Us

    1799 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Murderers Are Among Us, directed by Wolfe Gang Staudte, is the first postwar film. The film takes place in Berlin right after the war. Susan Wallner, a young women who has returned from a concentration camp, goes to her old apartment to find Hans Mertens living there. Hans took up there after returning home from war and finding out his house was destroyed. Hans would not leave, even after Susan returned home. Later on in the film we find out Hans was a former surgeon but can no longer deal with human suffering because of his traumatic experience in war. We find out about this traumatic experience when Ferdinand Bruckner comes into the film. Bruckner, Hans’ former captain, was responsible for killing hundreds

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Murder At The Margin

    860 Words  | 2 Pages

    Murder at the Margin is a murder mystery involving various economic concepts. The story takes place in Cinnamon Bay Plantation on the Virgin Island of St. John. It is about Professor Henry Spearman, an economist from Harvard. Spearman organizes an investigation of his own using economic laws to solve the case.

    Read More

  • Jack Mccoy's Argument Of Death Penalty

    448 Words  | 1 Pages

    Jack McCoy also reminded the jurors that this hideous crime was plan, not just a reaction. The jurors must not only decide the fate of the defendant, but they need to also remember how Mr. Ngai live was taken away from him; it wasn’t just slipping away, it was beaten out of

    Read More

  • Making A Murderer Essay

    639 Words  | 2 Pages

    The sentencing of underage criminals has remained a logistical and moral issue in the world for a very long time. The issue is brought to our perspective in the documentary Making a Murderer and the audio podcast Serial. When trying to overcome this issue, we ask ourselves, “When should juveniles receive life sentences?” or “Should young inmates be housed with adults?” or “Was the Supreme Court right to make it illegal to sentence a minor to death?”. There are multiple answers to these questions, and it’s necessary to either take a moral or logical approach to the problem.

    Read More

  • Actus Reus of Murder

    453 Words  | 1 Pages

    Actus Reus of Murder When a man of sound memory over the age of discretion unlawfully kills

    Read More

  • The Bodies Are Talking: Will Society Listen?

    3892 Words  | 8 Pages

    That night, many witnesses reported having seen a man changing the tire of his van and waving any possible help away angrily while others reported seeing a woman wandering around the side of the dangerous highway. More witnesses reported that Kenneth and his wife were having many violent disputes at their home that usually resulted in Kenneth pursuing an angry Yvonne around the block. The most compelling evidence against Mathison, however, is purely scientific. Detective Paul Ferreira first noticed that the extensive blood stains inside the Mathison van. After hearing Mathison’s original account, he summoned the assistance of famed forensic expert Dr. Henry Lee to analyze what he thought was inconsistent evidence. Blood stains on the paneling and the spare tire in the cargo area reveal low-velocity blood stains meaning that the blood probably dripped from Yvonne’s head onto the floor. The stains found on the roof and steering wheel were contact transfer patterns probably caused by Mathison’s bloody hands. Blood stains on the driver’s side of the van were contact-dripping patterns which indicate that Mathison touched the inside of the van multiple times before and after moving his wife’s body. The final groups of blood stains on the instrument panel of the van were medium-velocity stains which show investigators that Mathison probably struck his wife at least once in the front seat causing the blood to fly from her open head wound. The enormous amounts of blood inside the van lead prosecutor Kurt Spohn to investigate the Mathison case as a murder instead of a misdemeanor traffic violation.

    Read More

  • The Differences Between Types of Homicides

    796 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Whether a killer acted with the deliberation and premeditation required for first degree murder can only be determined on a case by case basis. The need for deliberation and premeditation does not mean that the perpetrator must contemplate at length or plan far ahead of the murder.”

    Read More

  • Leanne Sarah Holland Murder Case

    491 Words  | 1 Pages

    Injuries inflicted on Leanne’s body suggested that whoever caused her injuries intended to cause death or grievous bodily harm.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Res Gestae: Law Of Evidence

    803 Words  | 2 Pages

    Held: Evidence would have been admissible as part of the res gestae because not only was there a close association in place and time between the statement and the shooting, but also the way in which the statement came to be made, in a call for the police and the tone of voice used showed intrinsically that the statement was being forced from the wife by an overwhelming pressure of contemporary events. 9 Res Gestae, Topic 3, Law of Evidence. Prepared by Ikram Abdul Sattar, 10. R v. Andrews [1987] 1 All ER 513 where the appellant and another man knocked on the door of the victim’s flat and when the victim opened it, the appellant stabbed him in the chest and stomach with a knife and the two men then robbed the flat.

    Read More

  • Direct Intention vs Oblique Intention

    1925 Words  | 4 Pages

    To be criminally liable of any crime in the UK, a jury has to prove beyond reasonable doubt, that the defendant committed the Actus Reus and the Mens Rea. The Actus Reus is the physical element of the crime; it is Latin for ‘guilty act’. The defendant’s act must be voluntary, for criminal liability to be proven. The Mens Rea is Latin for guilty mind; it is the most difficult to prove of the two. To be pronounced guilty of a crime, the Mens Rea requires that the defendant planned, his or her actions before enacting them. There are two types of Mens Rea; direct intention and oblique intention. Direct intention ‘corresponds with everyday definition of intention, and applies where the accused actually wants the result that occurs, and sets out to achieve it’ (Elliot & Quinn, 2010: 59). Oblique intention is when the ‘accused did not desire a particular result but in acting he or she did realise that it might occur’ (Elliot & Quinn, 2010: 60). I will illustrate, by using relevant case law, the difference between direct intention and oblique intention.

    Read More

  • Attempted Murder and Criminal Acts

    1039 Words  | 3 Pages

    Attempted murder, involved the voluntary act of Jack pointing a gun and firing it (act) at Bert that resulted in (causation) death of Pratt (social harm), which proves the elements of actus reus. ...

    Read More

More about Elements Of Murder

Open Document