Disagreement in the United States over the Effects of the New Deal

859 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: American history essay: new deal

Disagreement in the United States over the Effects of the New Deal

In 1932 the newly elected President Franklin Roosevelt, democratic

leader, promised the American people a New Deal. However, by 1937

people could not agree whether the New Deal was a success or not. All

of the sources in the booklet show this. They do not agree because of

the following reasons; The New Deal itself had varied successes and no

natural end. Historians, eyewitnesses and politicians all have

different motives for assessing the effects of the New Deal. In

addition, it is impossible to compare the New Deal to any other

policies, as Roosevelt's policy was so different to Hoovers.

The following sources are all positive about the New Deal, source A

was written by Roosevelt himself, therefore it is very positive about

the New Deal, it was written when he was first introducing to New Deal

to the American people. It has quotes such as "I pledge to you. I

pledge my self to a New Deal for the American people." He describes

the depression as the enemy, and he will fight, and win the war

against it. " Win the crusade to restore America". Sources B and F are

similar as they are both positive about the New Deal because they

focus first part of it. An American historian writing in 1945 wrote

Source B. he talks about all the good points of the New Deal he talks

about how the beginning of the new deal was successful. "The

restoration of self confidence". Source F is a cartoon of Roosevelt

tossing out all the rubbish that Hoover left behind such as

"prosperity is just around the corner" and "car in every garage". In

the background is Hoover walking off looking at a train timetable,

this is ironic, as he is not driving a car after his promise to have a

car in every garage in America. Source H is positive about the new

deal from a personal point of view. It was written by a family who

have obviously have been positively effected by the New Deal.

Show More
Related

  • John D. Rockefeller as a Robber Baron

    3611 Words  | 8 Pages

    Biles, Roger. A. "A New Deal for the American People" Taking Sides Clashing Views on Controversial Issues in American History. eds. -. Larry Madaras et al.

    Read More

  • The New Deal Dbq Essay

    1467 Words  | 3 Pages

    Franklin D. Roosevelt once asserted “I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people,” in belief for a change, for a better nation, and for guidance to those who have lost all faith in humanity. During the Great Depression, The United States faced many different scenarios in which it caused people to doubt and question the “American Dream.” The Great depression began in 1929 and ended in 1939. In these ten years, people went through unemployment, poverty, banks failed and people lost hope. President Herbert Hoover thought it wasn’t his responsibility to try and fix such issues in the nation. He felt it was just something that everyone was facing and it will be over soon enough. However, years passed and nothing seemed to

    Read More

  • The New Deal Dbq Essay

    1044 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Great Depression, beginning in the last few months of 1929, impacted the vast majority of people nationwide and worldwide. With millions of Americans unemployed and many in danger of losing their homes, they could no longer support their families. Children, if they were lucky, wore torn up ragged clothing to school and those who were not lucky remained without clothes. The food supply was scarce, and bread was the most that families could afford. Households would receive very limited rations of food, or small amounts of money to buy food. This led to the starvation of families, including children. African-americans faced tougher challenges than most during the Depression due to discrimination. The classes hit hardest were middle-class

    Read More

  • New Deal impact on society

    1623 Words  | 4 Pages

    People continue to argue whether the New Deal is radical or conservative today using many programs and outcomes as their support. The government imposed new radical programs influencing American society with changes in political and social reform. Conservatives at the time felt threatened by government interference feeling the changes led them toward a socialist style of government. Today, historians view the New Deal as more conservative, completely opposite of what conservatives felt at the time. With programs challenging economic, social, and political standards, the New Deal imposed both radical and conservative ideals into the American society causing Franklin D. Roosevelt to leave his lasting stamp and legacy on all presidents and generations to come.

    Read More

  • Two Different Interpretations Of The New Deal

    959 Words  | 2 Pages

    Source E gives a very strong opinion and argument against the New Deal. It describes how "men lost there confidense in themselves" because Roosevelt gave them soup. It says how "welfare kills a man's initiative". This is all evidense to support Interpretation II. The man who wrote source E was a self-made business-man, who was, no-doubt, a republican.

    Read More

  • Assessment of the Success of the New Deal

    1112 Words  | 3 Pages

    Assessment of the Success of the New Deal FDR introduced the New Deal to help the people most affected by the depression of October 1929. The Wall Street Crash of October 24th 1929 in America signalled the start of the depression in which America would fall into serious economic depression. The depression started because some people lost confidence in the fact that their share prices would continue to rise forever, they sold their shares which started a mass panic in which many shares were sold. The rate at which people were selling their shares was so quick that the teleprinters could not keep up, therefore share prices continued to fall making them worthless. Also causing many people to lose their jobs as the owners of factories could not afford to pay the workers wages.

    Read More

  • The New Deal Dbq

    766 Words  | 2 Pages

    The New Deal was a set of acts that effectively gave Americans a new sense of hope after the Great Depression. The New Deal advocated for women’s rights, worked towards ending discrimination in the workplace, offered various jobs to African Americans, and employed millions through new relief programs. Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR), made it his duty to ensure that something was being done. This helped restore the public's confidence and showed that relief was possible. The New Deal helped serve American’s interest, specifically helping women, african american, and the unemployed and proved to them that something was being done to help them.

    Read More

  • Gatsby's Dream and Daisy's Conflicts in The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

    1167 Words  | 3 Pages

    (68). The use of the symbolic automobile can be seen as a demonstration of how a...

    Read More

  • Immigration in the United States

    1133 Words  | 3 Pages

    Pear, Robert. "White House Report Lauds Immigrants’ Positive Effects." The New York Times. The New York Times, 20 June 2007. Web. 28 Feb. 2012. .

    Read More

  • Would You Buy a Car That Looked Like This

    1096 Words  | 3 Pages

    Andrew Simms, a policy director and head of the Climate Change Program for the New Economics Foundation in England, presents his argument about the impact SUV’s have on our roadways, and the air we breathe. “Would You Buy a Car That Looked like This? “. The title alone gives great insight on what the article is going to be about, (vehicles). “They clog the streets and litter the pages of weekend colour *supplements. Sport utility vehicles or SUV’s have become badges of middle class aspiration” (Simms 542). Simms opening statement not only gives his opinion on how SUV’s are the new trend, but he also paints a picture of what we see every day driving down our roadways. Simms also compares the tobacco industry’s gap between image and reality to that of SUV’s; stating that the cause and consequences of climate change resemble smoking and cancer. Simms comparison between SUV’s and cigarettes shows how dangerous he believes SUV’s are.

    Read More

  • Movie: Tucker - Preston Tucker

    587 Words  | 2 Pages

    afford. When he wanted to start to produce the car he faces a lot of barriers,

    Read More

  • The New Deal

    1578 Words  | 4 Pages

    Do you know what it’s like to live in a cardboard home, starve, and raise a family in poverty? Unfortunately, most Americans in the 1930s went through this on a day-to-day basis. In 1929 the stock market crashed. Many people lost their life savings; they invested everything they owned in a failing stock market. The country was falling, everyone needed strong leadership and help from the government.

    Read More

  • The Pros and Cons of Roosevelt's New Deal

    1214 Words  | 3 Pages

    The era of the Great Depression was by far the worst shape the United States had ever been in, both economically and physically. Franklin Roosevelt was elected in 1932 and began to bring relief with his New Deal. In his first 100 days as President, sixteen pieces of legislation were passed by Congress, the most to be passed in a short amount of time. Roosevelt was re-elected twice, and quickly gained the trust of the American people. Many of the New Deal policies helped the United States economy greatly, but some did not. One particularly contradictory act was the Agricultural Adjustment Act, which was later declared unconstitutional by Congress. Many things also stayed very consistent in the New Deal. For example, the Civilian Conservation Corps, and Social Security, since Americans were looking for any help they could get, these acts weren't seen as a detrimental at first. Overall, Roosevelt's New Deal was a success, but it also hit its stumbling points.

    Read More

  • The New Deal

    1629 Words  | 4 Pages

    The New Deal period has generally - but not unanimously - been seen as a turning point in American politics, with the states relinquishing much of their autonomy, the President acquiring new authority and importance, and the role of government in citizens' lives increasing. The extent to which this was planned by the architect of the New Deal, Franklin D. Roosevelt, has been greatly contested, however. Yet, while it is instructive to note the limitations of Roosevelt's leadership, there is not much sense in the claims that the New Deal was haphazard, a jumble of expedient and populist schemes, or as W. Williams has put it, "undirected". FDR had a clear overarching vision of what he wanted to do to America, and was prepared to drive through the structural changes required to achieve this vision.

    Read More

  • The New Deal Reforms

    1052 Words  | 3 Pages

    The United States faced the worst economic downfall in history during the Great Depression. A domino effect devastated every aspect of the economy, unemployment rate was at an all time high, banks were declaring bankruptcy and the frustration of the general public led to the highest suicide rates America has ever encountered. In the 1930’s Franklin D Roosevelt introduced the New Deal reforms, which aimed to “reconcile democracy, individual liberty and economic planning” (Liberty 863). The New Deal reforms were effective in the short term but faced criticism as it transformed the role of government and shaped the lives of American citizens.

    Read More

More about Disagreement in the United States over the Effects of the New Deal

Open Document