Differences Between Everything Must Go And Everything Must Go

1062 Words3 Pages

An alcoholic, a “yard sale”, nosy neighbors, marital troubles, desperation, and a record player; all of these are components of the short story “Why Don’t You Dance?”, and the movie based off of it, Everything Must Go. The short story “Why Don’t You Dance?” written by Raymond Carver, focuses on an alcoholic man with possible marital troubles having a “yard sale” on his front lawn, and his experience dancing and drinking with strangers who want to purchase his belongings. The movie Everything Must Go directed by Dan Rush focuses on the same main character, ex-salesman Nick Halsey, with emphasis on his marital troubles and relationships with his neighbors, sponsor, and mentee. The movie Everything Must Go abandons the use of audience imagination …show more content…

Nick Halsey, the main character, loses his job due to reasons associated with his alcoholism and returns home to find that his wife has kicked him out and thrown all of his belongings on the front lawn (Everything Must Go 0:00:00-00:07:11). With his accounts frozen and no money, he becomes content to sit on his lawn and drink all day until his cop friend, a boy from down the street, and a new neighbor inspire and push him to have a yard sale and start over. The director of this movie chose to add more characters, backstory, resolution, emotions, and obstacles for the characters to overcome in order to elongate the story to become a film enhance audience enjoyment. The climax and subsequent resolution of this film happens when Nick finally decides to give up his “sit-in” on his lawn, and sell all of his belonging in a yard sale with the boy from down the street (Everything Must Go 1:07:16-1:14:30). In this scene, Nick encounters many different types of people wishing to buy his stuff, however in “Why Don’t You Dance?”, the main character only encounters two individuals who mistake his predicament as a yard sale. Dan Rush, the director, most likely choose to build the story to eventually lead to the yard sale as a turning point for Nick, where he finally decides …show more content…

Authors of short stories, like Carter, have the freedom to write as much or as little as they want, in any manner they please. The genre of short stories is so vast and diverse that authors are allowed to write in different styles, lengths, and descriptiveness. However, the general public has specific expectations of films that producers, directors, writers, and actors must fulfill in order to create a successful film. In order for the audience to enjoy the film, Dan Rush couldn’t limit it to the ideas presented in Carver’s short story, he had to expand the details of the plot and provide more information to the audience. By providing more information and detail, this makes the film a more enjoyable and immersing experience for the audience.
The movie Everything Must Go and the short story “Why Don’t You Dance?” are very similar in their basic plotline, theme, and ideas, but the movie expands upon these concepts in order to create a more thorough captivating plot that audiences would enjoy. This might be due to the more demanding medium that the film is produced in. Compared to Everything Must Go, “Why Don’t You Dance?” allows the audience to imagine the aspects of this story not specifically laid out. The film is a result of one person’s imagination and interpretation of that short story, how do you imagine the man with the “yard

Open Document