Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Financial fraud case study
Financial fraud case study
Financial fraud case study
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Financial fraud case study
Fraud Identification and Classification Identifying fraud and understanding the difference between fraud and errors or omissions is an important aspect of business management. Evaluate the case of an employee of Company XYZ who is traveling for business in a city where the employee has extended family. In the evenings, the employee invites his family to dinner and charges the entire cost of the meal to his company credit card. He then subsequently files an expense report for these meals. The meals were not overly extravagant expenditures and thus are “lost” in the overall expense report. The employee considers this to be insignificant. Does this inclusion of these meals constitute fraud? This is where it becomes important for a manager …show more content…
The main and often differentiating part of fraud versus error is the intentionality of the act. An error is not caused intentionally and can include a discrepancy in a dollar figure or an incorrect application of an accounting policy (Investopedia, 2015). Fraud is an intentional misrepresentation or a deliberate deception to secure a gain (Wikipedia, 2015). It is important to make this distinction for the organization and to differentiate fraud that happens on behalf of the organization or against an organization. When fraud occurs against an organization, it is taking place within an organization. Different types of fraud occur within an organization. The below table illustrates the types of organizational fraud.
Table 1
Types of Organizational Fraud Example of Fraud
Employee embezzlement Most common type and occurs when an employee takes company assets either by stealing cash, inventory, supplies or other assets.
Management fraud Most expensive type of fraud and occurs when management manipulates the financial statements in order to make the company appear more successful.
Investment scan This type of fraud seeks to get investors to
Vendor fraud Vendors provide fewer goods than agreed or lower quality than acceptable.
Customer fraud Customers either pay too little or do not pay at all.
Miscellaneous fraud Applies to anyone who takes advantage of the company in an effort to deceive
I believe that asset misappropriation by accounts payable fraud is occurring at Wayland Manufacturing Company due to a lack of proper internal controls. Making the company’s Chief Accountant responsible for additional day-to-day functions provides him with opportunity to commit by creating fictitious vendors with his information and then creating fictitious invoices. Newbaker can then conceal his fraud by approving the invoices for payment. Employees working at an organization for more than five years are more likely to commit fraud. Therefore, Newbaker’s six-year history with the company has made him trustworthy and very knowledgeable, which could indicate involvement in asset misappropriation. The high employee turnover could represent a past fraudster leaving before getting caught or employees refusing to continue with the asset misappropriation. In addition, the varying monthly accounts payable transactions ranging from the lowest being April 2014 and
By deliberately falsification of their financial statements, by Martin Grass, Brown and Bergonzi. Among other things like:
Regardless of when financial statement fraud first occurred and the development of technology, it will be infinite. People may believe that as technology becomes more advanced, there will be less opportunity to commit fraud and it is easier to catch, but as technology evolves, so do the fraudulent schemes while weaving in the old ones but with a twist. There are always going to be individuals that feel that they will never be the one to get caught and believe that they are invincible to all. There remains a population that lives by means of entitlement, and therefore, minimizing their actions and rationalize them once given an opportunity and the perceived need equaling greed. As fraud evolves, individuals learn by other's mistakes and develop more complex schemes to provide confusion. According to the Wisconsin Law Journal (2012), “financial statement fraud is an ugly fraud with methods that are complex and often not understood by the average consumer or investor, and its results often aren’t tangible to the average person.” Therefore, by making a complex financial statement fraud, the gain is enormous with the amount of investigation overwhelming to determine a portion of the
These problems and the company’s failure to address them led to the creation of an unethical work environment that further exacerbated the extent of the financial fraud.
Ulinski, Michael. "AN ANALYSIS OF SMALL COMPANY FRAUDS AND." American Society of Behavioral Society. Dept of Business, Pace University. 05 Feb. 2008.
Tryon, G. & Kleiner, B. H. (1997). How to investigate alleged employee theft properly. Managerial Auditing Journal, 12(1), 19. Retrieved May 15, 2005, from ABI-Inform Online
My appropriate way that I would do during my audit process was that I would ask questions to Toby and his accountants to provide concrete evidence of each item that include in the miscellaneous expense. My team members and I must test the selected items or all the elements from the miscellaneous account by reviewing all the supporting documents such as receipts and invoices. Moreover, the audit team has to conduct the procedure to interview Toby and his staff to clarify all the suspicious about their financial statement reporting amounts. Even Betty and her team had questioned Toby and his employee several times about their miscellaneous expense, they have just realized heavily on Toby’s answers since they trusted him for having a long client relationship, and this was the reason that makes them decided not to investigate further. In my opinion, it is crucial for Betty and her team to investigate further about her client’s miscellaneous expense because it could help them to discover more inappropriate actions that Toby had done to his company’s financial statements. As a result, I think that because Betty did not practice an appropriate professional judgment as well as professional skepticism; she and her audit team have missed red flag in Toby’s fraud
The term “fraud” is commonly used to describe the use of deception to deprive, disadvantage or cause loss to another person or party. This can include theft, the misuse of funds or other resources, or more complicated crimes such as false accounting and the supply of false information. This case study of Mountain State Sporting Goods is an excellent example of individuals acting on the opportunity to financial benefit by committing what they thought was harmless adjustments, but in reality was fraud. In this case study there are is just so much wrong with this company and how it operates. We noticed multiple areas of concern before even seeing the financial statements and my concerns were confirmed upon further investigation.
A deception is a form of a lie. Scams are similar to deception in the way that each are lies and are used to achieve the same goal. They are used to gain something about an individual whether it is trust, money information of some kind or simply
1) Under-ringing of sales and the tearing up order tickets are two longtime scams in the food and beverage industry. An employee serves a customer in the restaurant, and the customer pays the check at the meal's end, but instead of putting the money and ticket in the register, the employee tears up the order ticket and pockets the cash. The restaurant owner has no record of that order or money tendered. Or an employee sold something for $17.50," and rang in $7.50 The employee put the $17.50 in the register and at the end of the night, would pocket the extra $10.00. Since the cash in the register drawer would match the transactions listed on the register tape, the theft would not be known. ...
Taking a look at Donald Cressey’s hypotheses which is now known as the fraud triangle depicts the certain criteria for the mind frame of the fraudster. The fraud triangle is a theory that consists of perceived pressures, perceived opportunity, and rationalization. It gives us the different pressures placed on individuals that would make them consider “cooking the books.” It also demonstrates where the possible opportunity lies so that we may take precautions to eliminate the opportunity. Last, it demonstrates how a fraudster rationalizes with themselves to make committing the fraud okay. Donald Cressey believes all three elements must be present for fraud to occur. Upper management is usually the focus of financial statement fraud because financial statements are done at the management level. So in this case financial statement fraud was committed by the CEO Gregory Podlucky
The Hollate Manufacturing case provided by Anti-Fraud Collaboration has well illustrated how several common issues in an organization contributed to the fraud’s occurrence. These issues can be categorized into two major groups: ethical culture (internal aspect) and internal control system (external aspect). By taking effective actions to enhance these two aspects, an organization can protect itself against the largest frauds, which result in financial and reputational damage.
ABSTRACT: The quantity of accounting fraud cases keeps on rising. Fraud is a consistent thing that will reliably be around, and in a bigger number of routes than just a single. An extensive apportionment of organizations out there fighting fraud, either from within the organization, or from outside the organization. Knowing how to manage this is essential for an organization to be productive over an extended period of time. The investigation regarding the matter of accounting fraud will utilize sources from the web and the DeVry School Library.
The Tyco accounting scandal is an ideal illustration of how individuals who hold key positions in an organization are able to manipulate accounting practices and financial reports for personal gain. The few key individuals involved in the Tyco Scandal (CEO Kozlowski and CFO Swartz), used a number of clever and unique tactics in order to accomplish what they did; including spring loading, manipulating their ‘key-employee loan’ program, and multiple ‘hush money’ payouts.
For those who do not know what fraud is, it’s basically deception by showing people what they want to see. In business it’s the same concept, but in a larger scale by means of manipulating figures that will be shown to shareholders and investors. Before Sarbanes Oxley Act there was “Enron Corporation”, a fortune 500 company that managed to falsify their statements claiming revenues over 101 billion in a span of 15 years. In order for us to understand how this corporation managed to deceive the public for so long, the documentary or movie “Smartest Guys in the Room” goes into depth by providing viewers with first-hand information from people that worked close with or for “Enron”.