Difference Between Expansionism And Imperialism
argumentative Essay
1300 words
Zuhayr Alvi Mr. Tweed Honors US History II September 4, 2014 Growth of America There is a very fine line between expansionism and imperialism. Expansionism is defined as a policy to increase a country’s size by expanding its territory, while imperialism can be defined as a policy of extending a country 's power and influence through diplomacy or military force. Expansionism is a good thing; if it were not for expansionism, the United States of America would not be one of the biggest powers in the world as it is today. Imperialism however is immoral and unjust. Unfortunately a lot of the “super power countries” began to turn away from expansionism and towards imperialism. In a political cartoon by Thomas Nast in Harper’s Weekly newspaper, there …show more content…
In this essay, the author
- Explains that expansionism is a good thing, but imperialism is immoral and unjust.
- Explains that the idea of "manifest destiny" was coined by john o'sullivan which stated that americans had the god-given right to expand westwards.
- Analyzes how the united states of america looked stubborn and would risk innocent lives and the nation’s security just to obtain some land. senator albert j. beveridge's speech descripts the corrupt mindset of this nation.
- Explains that president roosevelt was against taking over smaller countries irrationally. the american anti-imperialist league called the united states "betrayers."
- Concludes that the united states expansionism of the late 1900s and early 2000s was a palpable extension of mutual and national values.
After the United States of America expanded all the way westward into what is now present day California, we still were greedy. We started looking towards taking over small islands and territories that we could easily dominate and control. In the Supreme Court decision, Downes v. Bidwell the ruling states that any territory that we acquire, we can govern and we can prescribe our culture on to them (Document H). This statement from the court case shows how the United States managed to acquire territories and force the people to accept the “American way.” In the early 1900’s the United States had one of the biggest navies in the world. It was known as the Great White Fleet because we were parading the ships around the world just showing off our firepower. Using these massive ships we were able to dominate and dictate any battles on the sea. This was show in Alfred T. Manhan’s Interest of America Sea Power. This source talks about how we should keep Hawaii and Haiti away from foreigners just so we can use their ports for our trade and shipping purposes (Document C). We used our navy to take control of both of these territories and thirst for land still was not satisfied. Throughout history the United States of America often
Related
- opinion
- explanatory
- analytical
- comparative
- Annexation: Tyranny That Should Not be Allowedopinion essayIn the late 1800’s to the early 1900’s, the idea of imperialism swept over the world (Lapsansky). Imperialism is the policy of extending a country's power and influence through diplomacy or military force. All of the major world powers, such as Britain and France, began forcibly annexing inferior nations into their empires. The United States, not wanting to be considered “less than” the other nations and not wanting to be left behind began implying the same policy to how they ran their country as well. The United States began bringing in small countries using force, such as Hawaii, the Philippines, and Cuba (Lapsansky). Even though our annexation would greatly upset the natives and lead many to rebel, the only concern of the United States was to bring in the countries and as much profit from them as possible. This is due to the idea of the “White Man’s Burden,” and “Anglo-Saxon Superiority.” Within these two ideas, it is believed that the English speaking countries of the world are superior to those of foreign tongue and skin tone and that it was up to us to reach out to these poor native people and h...
In this essay, the author
- Opines that forcible annexation of residential areas without voter permission should not be allowed in the united states.
- Explains that imperialism was the policy of extending a country's power and influence through diplomacy or military force. the united states brought in small countries using force, such as hawaii, the philippines, and cuba.
- Opines that annexation with the united states is not a wise move to make in expansion. the philippines was annexed with no consent and no mercy for the filipinos.
- Analyzes how the u.s. government's decision to annex the philippines caused harmful things to happen to them and negatively affected their national character.
- States that in the united states of america, 46 out of the fifty states have outlawed annexation, meaning that four states still allow this tyrannical act to continue.
- Explains that the uprising against annexation began in 2008 when lexington city officials unanimously voted in areas of western davidson county.
- Opines that forced annexation is a violation of people's rights, and that the united states constitution explicitly states that government should be run by the consent of the governed.
- Explains that owners wanted to sell alcohol, but officials say that wasn't a factor in decision.
- Opines that annexation in america is a reality that citizens of our country should not have to face.
1756 wordsRead More - 1890-1910 American Imperialismexplanatory essayImperialism is defined as a policy to dominant other countries and rule them. Then, these new colonies surrender their markets, industries, and resources to their invaders. “US imperialism, supported by US politicians, was intended to bring profits to US manufacturers (capitalists)…” (lecture4-p13). Although the period of 1890-1910 is usually known as “the age of the US imperialism”, the US imperialism is not limited to that era. Overseas imperialism began during 1890-1910 with the invasion of Hawaii, Cuba, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines, which was an attempt to expand the American’s territory to reach natural resources such as minerals, timber, oil, and land. These new territories could also provide corporations with cheap workers and military bases. There have been numerous other examples of the US imperialism. Starting from North America, the US government took over the Pacific Ocean and found its way into Asia. “A State Department list... shows 103 interventions in the affairs of other countries between 1798 and 1895” (Zinn-12), including Argentina, Uruguay, China, Angola, Nicaragua, and Japan to protect American’s interests in those countries. The same motivation was pursued in attacking Vietnam. According to Zinn, the main reason of the US intervention in WWII was to follow its imperial interests. “For those interests, in the thirties, an anti-Soviet
In this essay, the author
- Explains that history teaches us valuable lessons from the past, which can be used for the present time, yet our leaders often overlook these lessons and repeat previous mistakes.
- Explains that the us government relied on imperialism to control the international markets to benefit corporations.
- Explains that businessmen prefer to be allowed to run their own rules rather than being restricted by federal regulations and taxation.
- Explains that the us military is used to support both aspects of capitalism.
- Opines that the course has taught them to look for a critical history and analyze events.
1117 wordsRead More - Examples Of American Imperialismexplanatory essayThe United States has always been an empire, taking the land it desires by whatever means necessary. The colonization of the American mainland out from under the Native Americans is the first example of American imperialism. This practice of domination in conjunction with the ideals of manifest destiny helped to spur the expansion of the US in the late 19th century. The rationale for this period of expansion was much like that of colonization 300 years prior, relying loosely on the conquest of lands for political, economic, or religious reasons. This expansion had a price though, leading some to speak out against these expansionary practices (Bello)
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the us was falling behind in the world race to acquire territory. the focus on independence may have been what sparked us imperialism.
- Explains that manifest destiny was an initial tenant of the us, and a way that the people could feel comfortable owning these newfound lands.
- Explains that the debate over expanding the united states' influence was not new, it was the same debate that had been going on about colonization for hundreds of years, simply in a new setting.
- Explains that the american conquest had a slightly different flavor from other instances of imperialism.
1002 wordsRead More - the spanish american warexplanatory essayIn the late 1800’s and early 1900’s, Imperialism was a popular trend among the large, powerful countries. Imperialism is defined as “The policy of extending a nation's authority by territorial acquisition or by the establishment of economic and political hegemony over other nations” Imperialism cannot be said as either good or bad, but as a general rule; If you live in an annexed country, imperialism is not good, if your country annexes smaller ones to gain profit, land, and respect, then imperialism is good. The United States was not much of an imperialistic country until we won the Spanish-American war. As a result of this war, we annexed Guam, The Philippines, and Puerto Rico. This is the point at which the US becomes and imperialistic nation, and though it was a hard struggle to keep these annexed countries under control and eventually gave them all back to their rightful owners. The importance of taking these countries is that we then could have coal stations around the world to fuel our navy, and we got respect from other countries around the war. This respect and intimidation helped the allied powers defeat the central powers during World War II. Ever since the US became the most powerful nation after the Spanish-American war, we have retained the title.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the spanish-american war secured the us as the most powerful country in the world. the us gained land, gained respect, and taught a lesson to one of its enemies.
- Describes imperialism as extending a nation's authority by territorial acquisition or establishment of economic and political hegemony over other nations.
- Explains that the spanish-american war was good for the us because of the relatively small losses. 332 americans were killed, 1642 were injured, and 2957 died from disease.
- Explains that the us declared war on spain on april 25th, 1898, when cuba was under intense oppression from spain, which prompted spain to group the cubans into small villages where they were forced to live.
- Opines that the country does what the people want. if they want to go to war, it doesn't matter if their anger is fueled by yellow journalists who greatly blow out the facts.
748 wordsRead More - Imperialist View Of Imperialismanalytical essayImperialism has been around since the dawn of time. It is the “grass is always greener on the other side” mentality -- what one has, another wants. By definition, imperialism is a principle of action that extends a country's power and hold by use of militant and/or diplomatic forces. In 1760, arguably the biggest trend of imperialism across the globe started, appropriately named The Age of Imperialism. This trend lasted for many years, even well into the 20th century. The industrialized nations, which are mainly perceived to be of Europe back then, began to take over other countries and even continents. They colonized, conquered, and dominated both socially and economically. This
In this essay, the author
- Explains that imperialism is the "grass is always greener on the other side" mentality that extends a country's power and hold by using militant and/or diplomatic forces.
- Analyzes how the imperial powers of europe took land and resources from places such as africa and asia, and in return, believed they were giving them civilization.
- Analyzes how the imperialized nations stripped the natives of their land, culture, and religion, while enslaving them to their beliefs.
- Explains that the age of imperialism was and still is a debated topic. the imperialists saw it as beneficial for themselves, while the dominated people only saw how they were being oppressed by these powers.
983 wordsRead More - Compare And Contrast Imperialism And Evilsanalytical essayImperialism was not a proper, nor legitimate policy for the U.S. The United States lived the majority of its lifetime as a benevolent nation. Implementing imperialism would be the opposite of the basis the nation progressed with. It would destroy the foundation of justice and righteousness that the land possessed. In "Imperialism - Its Dangers and Wrongs," published in 1898 by Samuel Gompers, he argued, "It is worse than folly, aye, it is a crime, to lull ourselves into the fancy that we shall escape the duties which we owe to our people by becoming a nation of conquerors, disregarding the lessons of nearly a century and a quarter of our national existence as an independent, progressive, humane and peace-loving nation." As Gompers explained,
In this essay, the author
- Argues that imperialism was not a proper, nor legitimate policy for the united states.
167 wordsRead More - Expansionism, Isolationism And Exceptionalism Analysisanalytical essayEach individual maintains within his own psyche an idea of who he is, an idea of his essential character which psychologists refer to as his ‘self-concept’. Actions he takes in life which are in line with this ideal of the self serve to further reinforce it, while those actions which fall outside the scope of this model provoke an uncomfortable tension in the mind between what impulse or necessity has caused him to do and this ideal of who he is on a fundamental level. In much the same way that Liberalism conceptualizes the nation as a collective of individuals, people, perhaps particularly Americans, have a strong and guiding notion of who they are collectively
In this essay, the author
- Explains that each individual maintains within his psyche an idea of who he is, which psychologists refer to as his ‘self-concept’, while actions outside the scope of this model provoke an uncomfortable tension in the mind between what impulse or necessity has caused him to do.
- Explains that america's founding fathers asserted that it would be the first nation where the ideals of the enlightenment could fully flower without the constraints of decaying and decadent institutions.
- Explains that americans were not savages, but civilized, a product of this glorious new exercise in nation-building, and their beliefs were ultimately for the benefit of all.
- Opines that the conflict between england and france is definitive for the united states, as without them the country would likely never have come into being.
- Analyzes the common threads that run through all these incidents that doubtlessly strongly influenced the first iteration of american foreign policy.
- Analyzes how the conflict between napoleon and england motivated napoleon to sell french territory to the united states under the guise of the louisiana purchase.
- Analyzes how america's 'isolationism' is a reaction to the two super powers' self-destructive battles against each other motivated largely by hubris and blind antipathy.
- Analyzes how the mexican-american war echoed american values in the recent iraqi war. an independent kurdish nation may fit well with american ideals, but our realist agenda depends on turkey.
1816 wordsRead More - American Manifest Destinyexplanatory essayAt the end of the nineteenth century, the popular idea for Americans was that American had a manifest destiny to expand their territory. That combined with the industrialist's desire for a new market for their goods. This was called the new imperialism. When it came to the expansion of the Pacific business leader really hoped to extend America commercial bounds across the Pacific to exploit Asian markets. The United States even got some land out of the Spanish American War or the War of 1898. The popular beliefs of the oversea expansions were overall positive for the most part until around after the Spanish American War. They had that popular idea of Manifest destiny to expand the territory, business leaders wanting to extend their commercial
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the popular belief of the oversea expansions was positive until around after the spanish american war.
- Explains that america went from isolationism to controlling regions in the western hemisphere and the pacific and asia region.
349 wordsRead More - Examples Of American Imperialismcomparative essayIn conclusion imperialism is a vehicle of advancement. This promotion is brought to countries that aren't strong enough to defend them selves. Imperialism advances a countries politics, society and economic value into a powerful money making country. The U.S. might not be actively engaged in an imperialistic type policy, but there are some subtle examples of U.S. policy that do push the envelope. Alfred Mahan, William Seward, Henry Cadot Lodge, Theodore Roosevelt, Josiah Strong, William McKinley were very supportive in the American Imperialism. They have conquered so many states and countries to expand the US. Imperialism has been practiced by many countries for a long time now, and will continue to be used by countries that seek to gain power
In this essay, the author
- Concludes that imperialism is a vehicle of advancement for countries that aren't strong enough to defend themselves. some subtle examples of u.s. policy push the envelope.
141 wordsRead More - Essay On Spanish American Imperialismexplanatory essayBeginning in the 1900’s, United States was altered by global imperialism. Imperialism is a policy that extends a country's power by using military force, and this technique is used around the globe affecting Africa and the Europeans.Throughout history, imperialism and colonization has constantly occurred because every country wants to have the most power and influence. This so called Imperialism spiced the economy because of the industrialization and trade, it created a desire for natural resources, and sparked superiority and racism. Majority of the countries wanted to industrialize and colonize other territories to become stronger.
In this essay, the author
- Explains global imperialism, which extends a country's power by using military force, affecting africa and the europeans. imperialism spiced the economy because of industrialization and trade.
- Explains that imperialism led to a boost in global economy because countries were striving for wealth and stability.
- Explains that imperialism created superiority which was known as social darwin. it was a transparent reason to justify murder and oppression by societies and the world.
- Explains that imperialism changed the world in many aspects, including industrialization and creating a stable market. it also created superiority over african americans and countries striving for raw materials.
447 wordsRead More