Denial of John Walker Lindh's Constitutional Rights

Best Essays
The Bill of Rights was ratified and in full effect in 1791. It spelled out rights and freedoms which protected citizens from the government and gave them, most especially; protections under the law against criminal accusations made against them. In 2001, John Walker Lindh (known to some as the “American Taliban”) became an accused man; he was an American citizen and alleged anti-American terrorist. Lindh was denied a number of rights vital to make his proper, fair, and full defense. Lindh’s constitutional rights should have been upheld despite the charges against him and any possible intelligence towards the war on terror he may have had; for there is a slippery-slope to denying someone these constitutional rights.

The glitch in Lindh’s case, for all American citizens, is that if the story were to play out right; any one of them could be without their constitutional protections. To the founders of the United States Constitution felt that government most certainly has the right to accuse you, me, or anyone else; but also that, under the law, we should have constitutional rights providing us with a fair trial and defense against such accusations.

Due process and Habeas Corpus are two of the very important pillars upon which American democracy and freedoms are based. Without these rights there is no system to fight against the tyranny of the government; and it is such tyranny that the founders of the constitution fought vehemently against. While these ideas of due process of law and habeas corpus were not new to the founders and the foundation of these freedoms can be found in a much older historical document called the Magna Carta, they found them to be of the utmost importance. In 39th clause of the Magna Carta, King John d...

... middle of paper ...

...g that probably only warranted a few years due to a mistake made in childlike innocence, or he should have been more severely punished if he was actually guilty. By denying Lindh his legal and constitutional rights the government did no one justice.

Works Cited

Andrews, John. "US Torture of John Walker Lindh Exposed as Frame-up Continues." World Socialist Web Site. 25 June 2002. Web. 20 Oct. 2011.

Coffin v. United States. Supreme Court. 4 Mar. 1895. Print.

Davis, G. R. C. Magna Carta. London: British Library, 1996. Print.

Mayer, Jane. "LOST IN THE JIHAD." The New Yorker 10 Mar. 2003: p.50. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 20 Oct. 2011.

Welte, Jim. "John Walker Lindh's Father Persists With Legal Fight - San Anselmo-Fairfax, CA Patch." San Anselmo-Fairfax, CA Patch - News, Sports, Events, Businesses & Deals. Patch Network, 16 Feb. 2011. Web. 20 Oct. 2011.
Get Access