Can Rome 's action towards Carthage be described as defensive imperialism?
Rome 's action towards Carthage throughout the Punic Wars cannot be considered defensive imperialism, due to the strong military culture, expansionist aims and profit based attitudes of Roman society. Rome demonstrated traditional imperialism by extending their power and influence through means of colonisation and military force. Rome 's objective in the Punic Wars was to strategically subordinate Carthage, to increase their level of influence and improve their position on the world stage. The economic and material gain of war during the 2nd and 3rd centuries BC, was a motivating incentive for warfare for the aristocracy. This eagerness was further propelled by the desire
…show more content…
Before 294 BC, Rome solely ruled Italy with no overseas possessions. Yet, within 100 years, Rome had possession of the majority of the Mediterranean. The Roman actions that led to this were purposeful and strategic, with a series of small victories equating to their territorial success. This ruled out the argument that their advantageous position was a case of coincidence, but instead a carefully structured timeline of events. Roman imperialism was the process of territorial expansion, not a response to the threat to their power. Many historians have supported the notion of defensive imperialism. Whist it was stated and appears that the decision to aid the Mamertines was based on Roman fear of Carthage expansion (Garland & Dillon, 2005). What Rome didn 't announce, was that Messana was a key city in the complete control of Sicily. This held aspects of defensiveness, but only due to the threat of Carthage to Romes plans of expansion, not to Rome 's power or society. Ameling (2011) has subsequently brought attention to the reality that a Carthaginian garrison in Messana of less than 1000 troops is not …show more content…
In the battle of Mylae, Rome showcased their initiative and offensive strategy in their use of the Raven, to transform the battle from naval to land in accordance with their strengths, gaining valuable advantage. Once Carthage was vulnerable due to military defeat, Rome opportunistically seized Sardinia, revealing their eagerness to expand the Roman empire and steal Carthage 's power. The ultimatum directed at Carthage to hand over Hannibal or face war, was a reflection of their opportunism and hegemony. In yielding, Carthage would have entailed the loss of the entire empire, as the majority of allies and Carthaginians control was bound to the Barcid family (Rosenstein, 2006). Rome recognised this, and took the opportunity to gain territory and oppress Carthage, as the odds of the Second Punic war were very much in Rome 's favour before the alliance of Hannibal and Phillip V of Macedon. This was an offensive move by Rome, as Carthage avoided breaking the treaty until absolutely necessary, to avoid provoking Rome into war. Unfortunately for Carthage, the mighty power was actively waiting for an excuse and immediately seized the warfare opportunity. After their victory of the 2nd Punic War, Rome showcased their attacking characteristics in continuing to enter wars and expand their territory
The Second Punic war, beginning in 218 BC, was the second major war between the Roman Empire and the Carthage. Around the same time, the Roman Empire deployed troops to the Northeastern peninsula of Spain to keep reinforcements, from the Carthaginian South, from getting to Hannibal’s armies in Italy to assist them. In A Histor...
A tribe known as the Catuvellauni, based out of Hertfordshire, appears to be the most powerful state in the southeastern Britain at the time of Caesar’s conquest. This is likely because their king Cassivellaunus killed the Trinovantian king, Imanuentius, in battle. If the Trinovantes were a strong power in southeastern Britain, as described by Caesar, it would likely take an even more powerful state to defeat them in battle. Additionally, the Catuvellauni were known to be the neighbors and “traditional enemies” of the Trinovantes (Dunnett 8, The Trinovantes). Again, if the Trinovantes were almost the most powerful tribe in southeastern Britain, it is unlikely that the Catuvellauni were not the most powerful state, since they had defeated the Trinovantes in battle. Lastly, Caesar describes the Catuvellauni as his “principal opponent” (Caesar 5.20). This description is important because during Roman conquest, Rome often sought to first eliminate the most powerful tribe in a region, regardless of whether this was through brute force or di...
It has been debated by varying scholars as to whether Caesar Augustus’ foreign policy to expand Rome’s empire had more to do with defensive imperialism as a response to encroaching threats, or rather, an aggressive, unprovoked move to claim hegemony over the known world. However, I would like to postulate in support of the former theory that in an attempt to restore and ensure long-lasting security to their empire, Augustus was forced to take proactive measures in order to preserve it. With territorial boundaries normally running along the rivers so as to provide a better defensive posture, he felt it necessary to expand the northern border to the river so as to secure their autonomy and position. Perhaps if he could establish a wide buffer of room along Roman lands, he could ensure the safety of the people, the cities, and most of all—the government.
The first Punic war started like this...Tradition holds that Phoenician settlers from the Mediterranean port of Tyre founded the city-state of Carthage on the northern coast of Africa, around 814 B.C. By 265 B.C. Carthage was the wealthiest and most advanced city in the region, as well as its leading naval power. Though Carthage had clashed violently with several other powers in the region, its relations with Rome were historically friendly, and the cities had signed several treaties defining trading rights over the year . In 264 B.C., Rome decided to intervene in a dispute on the western coast of the island of Sicily involving an attack by soldiers from the city of Syracuse against the city of Messina. While Carthage supported Syracuse, Rome supported Messina, and the struggle soon exploded into a direct conflict between the two powers, with control of Sicily at stake. Over the course of nearly 20 years, Rome rebuilt its entire fleet in order to confront Carthage's powerful navy, scoring its first sea victory at Mylae in 260 B.C. and a major victory in the Battle of Ecnomus in 256 B.C. Though its invasion of North Africa that same year ended in defeat, Rome refused to give up, and in 241 B.C. the Roman fleet was able to win a decisive victory against the Carthaginians at sea, breaking their legendary naval superiority. At the end of the First Punic War, Sicily became Rome's first overseas province.
Imperialism is when a mother nation takes over another nation and become its colony for political, social, and economical reasons. Imperialism is a progressive force for both the oppressors (mother country) and the oppressed (colony), majorly occurring during the late 19th and early 20th century. It had more negative effects than positive effects due to its domination to other nations.
Since the beginning of time, man has waged war on his neighbors, his friends and his enemies. In many cases these wars were caused by power-hungry nations that were in the process of expanding their empire and ended up stepping on the toes of another superpower or ally of a superpower. In the case of the first Punic War between Rome and Carthage, Carthage was extending its empire and they stepped on Rome’s toes. During the course of this war the winner was unclear but at times victory seemed eminent for both sides until Rome finally won. The Romans had control in the first part of the war but this would not last. After the Romans first win they decided that they needed a victory over the city of Carthage but this would turn the tides in favor of the Carthaginians. For some 15 years after this defeat of Rome the tides went back and forth between the two but would eventually lead to the Romans victory. After the victory, Rome made some very harsh demands and Carthage filled those demands even though some of them were very extreme.
Throughout its early history Rome constantly came up new innovative ideas have the upper hand over its enemies. The Romans were a determined people that believed that ruling the world was their destiny and after the defeat of its’ greatest rival Carthage, they were now masters of the Mediterranean. Rome would never again be threatened until the empire’s fall hundreds of years later. The Romans would now begin to expand their empire past Italy, and with great success, come to rule the Western world.
The Roman Republic was an ancient territory known for its people, people that would fight for passion, unity, and for the prosperity of their country. Carthage, in historic times, was known for its great rulers, especially of the likes of Hannibal. Both of these countries had a mindset on expansion. Both were the worst of rivals. And during the time of the Punic Wars, Carthage was on the brink of becoming the equal to Rome. In fact, during much of the war, it can be argued that Carthage was already stronger than the likes of Rome. Both powers had their strengths. They both had their weaknesses. All in all, this led to Rome becoming a naval power, and eventually taking the best
The Romans had numerous incentives to go to war in 200 BCE, which included but were not limited to fear, pride, revenge, and economic growth. Rome was a fast-growing empire and its next step was to expand out of the Italian peninsula and become a Mediterranean power. Rome feared Phillip V, thinking that he was aligning with Egypt to begin another Macedonian War, and would attack Rome’s Aetolian allies. During the Sabine Wars, Rome voted to go to war not because the Sabines attacked them, but rather because they feared how powerful the Sabines were becoming. This fear of other powerful nations repeatedly drove Rome to war and was used to “justify” the war. However, Rome realized that wealthy states could be made to pay lucrative indemnities,
Rome became a powerful empire engulfing much of Europe, North Africa, and parts of Asia and what seemed like this great entity called the Romans were always in the search of more territory and land to conquer and assimilate into their ever growing vast empire. However, this was not always the case, before Rome became one of the greatest empires in all of history, Rome was a republic. They were government consisted of a Senate who much like our country today represented certain classes of the citizens of the Republic. During the growth and rise of the Roman republic conquering neighboring territories and competing for land grabs was not Romans primary objectives. Romans believed in the well being and wealth of Rome, and if that meant the total destruction of a potential adversary, then as history will show that is unfortunately to the detriment of the adversary what happened.
The fate of the island of Sicily hangs in balance. The Romans hunger for power and land, while Carthage wants the same. Both are powerful and rich traders and planned to stay that way. They were both the most powerful forces in the Mediterranean. Romans held military glory in the highest regard, and made military service a required part of political advancement. Carthage also held military glory highly but their military mainly consisted of mercenary soldiers rather than citizen soldiers
Even before the war started, Hannibal knew what he was going to do. Since Carthage had no navy, there was no hope of going directly from Carthage to Italy over the Mediterranean Sea. Hannibal thought up a dangerous but ingenious plan. In order to get to Italy over land, Hannibal and his army would have to travel from Carthage-controlled Spain across the Alps and into the heart of the enemy. Hannibal left in the cold winter of 218 B.C. with 50,000 infantry, 9,000 cavalry, and 37 war elephants. While crossing the Alps, “Hannibal’s force suffered greatly from the elements and the hostility of the local tribesmen” (Beshara, 3). By the time they reached Italy, after only fourteen days, over 9,000 men had perished along with most of the elephants, but this number was soon replenished after 14,000 northern Gaul rebels joined Hannibal’s army. This group of 60,000 men proved superior to the Roman forces, and after at least three recorded major victories, the Roman senate was exasperated. An army of 80,000 Roman soldiers was sent to stop Hannibal’s army of now 50,000 once and for all. In July of 216 B.C., the Romans engaged the Carthaginians in “the neighborhood of Cannae on the Italian east coast” (Lendering, 2). Greatly outnumbered, Hannibal realized that he would have to win by strategy, and that is exactly what he did. As the two lines met, Hannibal’s cavalry gained the flanks and, moving up the sides, attacked the rear of the Roman line.
Rome claimed to protect Saguntum, which was on the wrong side of the Ebro River according to the Carthaginians, leading Hannibal to attack. Rome didn’t come rescue their allie and Carthage destroyed Saguntum, also a cause of the Second Punic War. While Rome sent one consul to Sicily and the other consul to invade Iberia, Hannibal crossed the Alps taking Rome by surprise. For the first time Rome realized this war wouldn’t be easy.
In early centuries, Romans claimed their warfare was mostly defensive and they were protecting themselves against their enemies. Through their wars, Romans gained new territories, yet Romans claimed territorial expansion was not their main goal. Rome has been accused for using defensive aggression. Romans, out of fear of an attack from rivals at their borders, would preemptively attack enemies. After their enemies were defeated, Romans would seize the enemy territory (Parker 2014). Eventually, after centuries of battles and expansions Romans conquered Greece. During 246 BC Romans began to take over Greece. Initially, Romans in Italy were conquering parts of the Mediterranean. Romans began with Sicily, an island near Italy. By 275 BC, Romans were fighting Carthaginians in alliance with Greeks. Greeks allied Carthaginians out of fear of Roman power expansion. Romans were angry at Greece for such an alliance and after winning against Carthaginians, began to take over Greece as well (Carr 2012).
Ancient Rome, the period between the 8th and 1st centuries B.C. in which Rome grew from a little colony to an emerging empire. "Roman imperialism introduced extremes of wealth and poverty that honed social and economic conflict within the Roman state ." The enormous army and their countless loots, as well as their captured slaves, produced many changes along the countryside such as small farms becoming large plantations, and peasants left without lands decided to journey to Rome and other cities. "Immense wealth inflamed the ambitions of Roman nobles who struggled for personal domination rather than collective rule ." This dominant emergence of power and rule thus led to the conquering and control of other societies. The following paragraphs will be divided in order to partition the overall structure of the Roman Empire and the ethics and justifications of their colonial methods.