preview

Considering All the Facts: Mistakes About Standardized Tests

Powerful Essays
Considering All the Facts: Mistakes About Standardized Tests

There has been a lot of talk about standards for schools. Politicians have made this issue a campaign debate. Now everyone has jumped on the “bandwagon” and wants accountability of students’ education (Shafer, 2002). When there is a problem in the education system, teachers are the first to be blamed. They are left with the responsibility of proving they are teaching what needs to be taught. States as well as the federal government use standardized testing to assess learning. They want someone to be held responsible for students’ learning. The problem lies when the teacher and student suffer from the results of standardized testing. “The pressure on educators and policymakers to demonstrate accountability in schools has driven some to use the test results inappropriately (Holloway, 2001).” Standardized tests are comparisons of one student to another not of how well a teacher teaches or a student learns. Standardized tests should not have such high-stakes in assessing learning because that is not their intended purpose.

In order to understand the purpose of these tests we must first examine what they are. According to W. James Popham(1999), “a standardized test is any examination that’s administered and scored in a predetermined, standard manner”. Norm-Referenced tests and Criterion Referenced tests are two types of tests used to evaluate students. Norm-referenced tests compare a student’s score with a “norm” group (same age or grade level), while Criterion Referenced tests are supposed to be an assessment of what is actually taught. Students are supposed to do better on the latter because it is assumed they are taught the material that they will be teste...

... middle of paper ...

... and misuse of standardized tests. Educational

Leadership, 59 (1), pp.77+. Retrieved April1, 2002 from WilsonSelect.

Monty, N. (Ed.). (2002). What’s wrong with standardized tests? Fair Test: The

National Center for Fair and Open Testing. Retrieved April 5, 2002from the World Wide Web http://www.fairtest.org/facts/whatwron.htm

Popham, W. J. (1999). Why standardized tests don’t measure educational quality.

Educational Leadership, 56 (6), pp1+. Retrieved on April 2, 2002 from the World Wide Web http://www.ascd.org/readingroom/edlead/9903/extpopham.html.

Sappenfield, M. (2001). How school testing affects mather elementary. Christian

Silence Monitor, 94 (16), pp.1. Retrieved on March 20, 2002 from Ebsco database.

Shafer, G. (2002). Tests that fail democracy. Humanist, 61 (3), pp. 6+. Retrieved on

March 14, 2002 from Ebsco database.
Get Access