Comparison Between Westerns And Science Fiction

1597 Words4 Pages

Shayna Meshizahav
HIST 3435
05/18/2014

Historically, popular culture has been seen to evolve along with the era in which it is generated. The analysis of the predominantly popular genre within a given generation can serve, therefore, as a window into that particular generation’s prevailing way of thought. One thing that greatly affects that way of thought is the recent history immediately preceding that time.
Westerns and science fiction are two genres employed by popular culture that are, in that order, chronologically consecutive in history in terms of their popularity. When analyzed, they show themselves to be also extremely similar to one another, both thematically and structurally. Yet the shift in desirability from the dominant trend of western works to those of science fiction did occur, and I would argue is still occurring today. The reason for that shift in spite of the many similarities of the two genres, along with the factor of the added differences over time, may therefore be a convenient tool in revealing where exactly the ideologies of these respective generations diverge.
The most apparent thematic parallel between westerns and science fiction is their shared consistent adherence to the ideas of imperialism, racism, and genocide. Within those broader themes, there are more specific tropes that recur across the two genres. And within those tropes, there are recurring formulaic characters and situations specific to each genre, but with clear counterparts in the other. A generalized typical western work would likely contain the following elements, whether as part of the backdrop or as the main focus: the procession of the white colonizing protagonist to the Western frontier, with usually negative encounters with Na...

... middle of paper ...

...s. The inevitable genocide occurs.
I would argue that the switch from westerns to this particular brand of science fiction, which can be referred to as colonial science fiction, does not yet have particular importance, at least in terms of the underlying philosophy stimulating their creation. The setting and specific identity of the classic characters have changed, but the main narrative has not. Within imperialist literature, the story of the Western hero and the dangerous natives has finally become somewhat overused; the frontier has been tamed and taken, and new frontiers were needed in order to breathe new life into the colonial ideology. With an increasing lack of unexplored places on the globe to exploit, the setting was transferred to outer space. It is only in later emerging works that an ideological shift took place, from colonialism to post-colonialism.

Open Document