Comparing the Women in Fifth Business and The Great Gatsby

2006 Words9 Pages
Comparing the Women in Fifth Business and The Great Gatsby

Behind every great man lies a great women. In some cases the women herself may not always be good or ideal according to society. Nevertheless it seems to add character to

the man, and also influences his actions and maybe even his morals. In the novel The Great Gatsby, Nick Carraway's realization of the equality of man altered through his origin sets him up as a morally sound standard, until confronted by Jordan Baker. The "American Dream" will never be a failure if Jordan does not develop Nick into his final character. In the novel Fifth Business, Jung's theory suggests that the conscious part of Dunny's personality is brought out by Liesl. It is Liesl that allows Dunny to understand his function as "Fifth Business."

The development of Dunny's character in the novel begins when Dunny falls in love with Faustina. It is because of these female characters that both protagonists learn to accept the emotional side of their lives, which are provided by these women, who possess immoral values that allows Nick and Dunny to develop into the final stages of their characters, essentially making them the same. Nick's realization of the equality of man and morals change when he comes in contact with Jordan Baker. Jordan possesses certain qualities that only benefit her. She likes to bend the rules so that the positive result ends up in her favor. She has allowed herself to be wrapped in a blanket of dishonesty that Nick would not be able to live, until he realizes that he can.

It is undetermined whether or not Nick chooses to ignore Jordan's dishonesty or whether it goes by naturally, because, in the early stages of the novel he does not seem affected by it.

"No thanks,said Miss Baker to the four cocktails just from the pantry, I'm absolutely in training. Her host looked at her incredulously. You are!...How you get anything done is beyond me."(pg.. 27 ln16)

Now this was the first time Jordan and Nick came into contact with one another, and it is said that the first impressions are extremely important. However, for a strong moral person like Nick, his reaction is surprising when he simply states, "I enjoyed looking at her."(pg. 27 ln 23)This is a sign of his first stages of development, which will soon result into what the author intended.

The "American Dream" cannot be recognized as a fa...

... middle of paper ...

...The Great Gatsby both shape Dunny Ramsay and Nick Carraway into the same person. In the novel Fifth Business, the development of

Dunny's character begins when Dunny falls in love with Faustina. It is Liesl that allows

Dunny to understand his function as "Fifth Business." Jung's theory suggests that the conscious part of Dunny's personality is brought out by Liesl.

In the novel The Great Gatsby, the "American Dream" will never be a failure if Jordan does not develop Nick into his final character. Nick Carraway's realization of the equality of man altered through his origin sets him up as a morally sound standard, until confronted by Jordan Baker. Men and Women seem to be in constant battle for certain right but in the end, it is obvious that society has a real difficult time dealing with such issues. It is the job of society to understand this, and come to a realization about themselves.

"She lived by a light that arose from within; I could not comprehend it."

Fifth Business(pg. 52)

Bibliography

Davies, Robertson. Fifth Business Penguin Book 1996

Fitzgerald, F. Scott. The Great Gatsby The Bodley Head 1975

*Note: Jung Theories and themes taken from class notes

    More about Comparing the Women in Fifth Business and The Great Gatsby

      Open Document