Comparing the Assimilation into American Culture of the Irish and the Native American

418 Words1 Page
bulb-icon

Recommended: Diversity and american culture essay

Comparing the Assimilation into American Culture of the Irish and the Native American

Many people would agree that the Irish have been successful in assimilating into American culture and the Native American has been unsuccessful. There have been many boundaries that both groups have encountered but they are more of a hardship for the Native American. These include Racial and Cultural boundaries, Personal boundaries, Sociological boundaries, Political and Economic boundaries, and Geographical boundaries.

Racial and Cultural boundaries are probably the hardest obstacle that Native Americans have encountered. These are the physical differences. The Irish are a group of people that speak English. Since English is the national language of the United States and most people in America speak English, this was an obstacle that the Irish did not have to overcome. The Native Americans, however, did not speak English, so before they could function as a full member of society and get a good job they first had to learn how to speak English. The Irish are also for the most part a Catholic group. The Native Americans were not, this was another hardship for them. Most of the Irish customs were similar to those already being practiced in the United States. Native Americans had customs that were very different.

Another boundary that was harder for the Native Americans than the Irish was personal boundaries. Native Americans had less education then the Irish did, they also did not know English and that was another hardship they faced. Both Native Americans and the Irish started out working in blue collar jobs, but the Irish eventually made there way out and into the white collar world. Native Americans still hold blue collar jobs.

Sociological boundaries were another set of boundaries that both groups had to face. There were not many Native Americans left due to wars between individual tribes, the trail of tears and other similar walks to reservations, and to disease. So there were not many Native Americans left to assimilate into American culture.

Show More
Related

  • English Colonists vs Native Americans: Property Rights in the New World

    962 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although the English and Native Americans were both every different in how they viewed the land, there were some similarities between the two cultures. First of all, both agreed to the terms of a monarchy- the idea that a monarch that ruled over the land was more a symbolic figure of a whole people rather than a rich and wealthy land owner. Even though the English called their monarch a King, and the Indians’ a Sachem, the ideas behind the two were virtually the same. Secondly, if hunters were in pursuit of game, both cultures agreed to the fact that they could cross otherwise strict borders in attainment of the game. This shows that even though both were fairly precise in drawing village borders, food superseded otherwise legal boundaries. Lastly, the English and the Native Americans both were little different in their sense of how land could be bought or sold. Now, this does not mean that they thought viewed property the same or that they us...

    Read More

  • Apush Dbq Irish Relations Case Study

    659 Words  | 2 Pages

    They also felt culturally different. The Americans were well removed from their English ancestors and felt like they were being ruled by an unworthy ruler that had no right to tell them what to do. The Irish felt the same way, but did it without a massive war

    Read More

  • Our Hearts Fell to the Ground Exam

    1094 Words  | 3 Pages

    ... many setbacks and problems for the Natives, including poverty, alcoholism, and underperformance in education. With better acceptance of the Native culture, and aid from America as a whole, the Native American idea of freedom to self govern, roam freely, and preserve the Native culture can greater be aligned with that of American Freedom.

    Read More

  • Three Reasons College Still Matters By Andrew Delbanco

    821 Words  | 2 Pages

    Based on Three Reasons College Still Matters, there are three main reasons why a college education is so important. From an economical standpoint, an education is most of the time needed to earn enough money to live comfortably. Attending and completing college provides a possibility for future economic stability. Within a highly competitive workforce a college degree can put a foot in the door to a job of a person’s choice. Statistics show that people who obtain a bachelor’s degree or higher get paid more than those who do not obtain one. Many question the worth of a college degree because of how expensive it is, though some say that the money spent is an investment on a person’s future. One can say that the worth of a college education is within the eye of the beholder. Many q...

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Mark Twain 'A Train Towards Obsolescence'

    1532 Words  | 4 Pages

    Mark Twain would not love what science and technology has lead us to in today’s day and age. Born over a century before the first computer was created, Mark Twain believed in the sense that there was no such thing as a new idea. He believed in a theory that as human beings we use what has already been created, use what he describes as a “mental kaleidoscope in order to create new ideas, inventions, and innovations. This mental kaleidoscope is simply given a turn, and new combinations are created using thoughts that have previously been constructed. Even though new ideas are not created, deep thought is necessary in order to turn the mental kaleidoscope. Today, with smart phones and computers in the hands and homes of people all across the world, our capacity for deep thought is diminishing. Along the same lines, as discussed in the Nicholas Carr book, The Shallows, people are thought to becoming less intelligent. The thought in the book is that even though we are still getting smarter, or at the very least our IQ scores are improving. This somewhat constant uptick since World War II is known as the Flynn Effect. The book goes on to explain that this advance is not us as a society getting smarter and having more knowledge than our ancestors, but simply a change in the way we think. In today’s society we are programmed to think more scientifically than any previous generation. This paradigm shift in the way we think and look at the world should not be considered an advancement for our society. In the end, we are only hurting ourselves by diminishing our ability for deep thought. The inability for deep thought in the relatively near future should be looked at similarly to global warming. Currently we have the ability to do something about technology taking over our lives. Something must be done in the next century or we risk

    Read More

  • The Achievement Habit: The Achievement Habit By Bernard Roth

    801 Words  | 2 Pages

    His boss didn’t mind it as much as his other employees who took the time to be there on time. He knew deep down that traffic was not at fault for him being late , he was making himself late. Before work he would check his phone and respond to emails. He would leave late which meant he would arrive late. Roth was over feeling guilty so he changed and made it a point to leave early. No more last minute calls or emails , he would do them early so that they would not have to be last minute.When he changed his outlook on the meetings and how being late affected him , he changed. Everyone can connect to this because we have all used the excuse that traffic made us late. Let’s be real , we left late. We needed something to blame and that was traffic. Traffic is a “goooood” reason , he explains in chapter two that he did a study with a design group at Stanford. The class knew of he felt about reasons and if they would try and give one he would say “ that’s a goooood reason” , it would embarrass the student and would make them not want to have reasons anymore. He made the students try and not use them and the end result was that they would feel more insightful. “ Letting go of the need for reasons to justify your behavior is useful in every part of the design of thinking process” ( p. 42) How to students can relate and learn from Roth teaching is crucial to thinking reasons are

    Read More

  • The Story of an Hour: Sixty Minutes of Freedom

    657 Words  | 2 Pages

    The emotions that Mrs. Mallard showed as she stood still symbolizes that she indeed loved her husband. As quoted, “And yet she loved him sometimes. Often she did not” (Choplin, 16), which exhibits emotional apathy or indifference. It is what every woman is supposed to do to the man she wishes to marry. Love has to play an important part of a marriage, but some beg to differ. In today’s society people marry for money, citizenship, companionship and a host of other things. In comparison, it relates to Mrs. Mallard reasoning for the joy of her freedom. In earlier centuries, marriage was sacred, genuine, and had meaning. Mr. & Mrs. Mallard, however, showed their love in a more symbolic approach such as language. A quotes from “The Story of an Hour”, proves that Mr. Mallard did love his wife through many expressions and facial

    Read More

  • Kate Chopin's The Story of an Hour

    795 Words  | 2 Pages

    She is now told her husband died so she runs to her bedroom to be left alone. While her sister and family friend are downstairs feeling sorry for her and thinking she is destroyed, Mrs. Mallard comes upon an unsuspected feeling that she is now “free.” Since this story was written in 1894, which was a very tough ti...

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Benjamin Franklin Remarks Concerning The Savages Of Native America

    1044 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Native Americans were more than willing to help out a stranger, whereas the English were more concerned about how much money the stranger had before helping them out. The Native Americans wouldn 't talk when other people were, and they wouldn 't answer the white 's proposal on the same day to show respect that they were actually considering it. In addition, Native Americans allowed everyone to talk in court, whereas the English yelled over each other and wouldn 't accept that they might be wrong. Many of these habits are still evident in today 's world, and it is probably the reason why the Americans were able to take over the Native

    Read More

  • Most Overrated Product: The Bachelor's Degree By Marty Nemko

    1166 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the article “America’s Most Overrated Product: The Bachelor’s Degree” by Marty Nemko, the author argues several different views on why higher education may be very overestimated. For starters, the author shares his opinion more than anything else due to him being a career counselor. The purpose of this essay is to explain to the readers that most people start off with the idea of living the American Dream. Which is practically going to college to have a better life and career. But over the time the idea of working very hard for a Bachelor’s degree has become very dimmed. Furthermore, for some people, when they think of the American Dream they think of hope for bettering themselves and also helping their families. Unlike the author, Nemko feels that even the thought of trying to pursue to get a bachelor’s degree is overrated. The audience of this passage would most likely be teenagers going into college and parents. Nemko states that “Colleges are quick to argue that a college education is more

    Read More

  • Black Elk Speaks

    1275 Words  | 3 Pages

    biggest issues that the people have to deal with and solve. Many cultures, Indian culture is one of the examples, were affected by the persecution of the people who were though to be “superior” to others. Indian culture was persecuted by whites, which wanted to wipe off the Indian civilization from the face of the world. The Native Americans wanted the same as anyone would, peace and freedom for their people. The Native Americans did not consider “white way of living righteous” for them, they were spiritual and had a different outlook on life, and did not want interference from outside world.

    Read More

  • America 's Most Overrated Product : The Bachelor 's Degree

    1136 Words  | 3 Pages

    For those who wish to have children in the future, imagine putting ten dollars a week aside from now until they turned eighteen. That money would hardly accumulate up to even a portion of the costs for just a single year of higher education. In the article, “America’s Most Overrated Product: The Bachelor’s Degree”, an essay from the Chronicle of Higher Education in 2008, author Marty Nemko discusses all aspects that should be considered before pursuing a serious interest in educational institutions. Being a current student at a four-year institution it concerns me for not only myself but also fellow peers if we are making the right decision. The costs of higher education are increasing drastically along with the amount of Americans in debt from student loans. The value of a bachelor degree is declining and students are faced with the question, do the benefits of a collegiate education out weigh the costs?

    Read More

  • America's Most Overrated Product By Marty Nemko: The Critique Of Education

    890 Words  | 2 Pages

    Introduction: In the essay America’s Most Overrated Product: The Bachelor’s Degree by Marty Nemko argues that attending college does not benefit most students. Many of us grow up believing that going to college is the best option to get good jobs, even if we did not do so well in college. In this essay, we explore statistics presented by Nemko to get a better idea if college is worth the time and money spent on the benefits of having a diploma.

    Read More

  • America 's Most A Product : The Bachelor 's Degree

    1072 Words  | 3 Pages

    Education is one of the most important factors to any person’s success in their lifetime, but is higher education really worth it? The answer is found in the article “America’s Most Overrated Product: The Bachelor’s Degree.” Written by Marty Nemko who was most likely inspired to write this because of his experience as a career counselor. In this article Nemko addresses the parents of potential college students to inform them the truth about college’s being money hungry businesses. He brings fourth multiple examples of why bachelor degrees are overrated and how colleges are not being held to a high enough standard. Additionally, he argues that going to college isn’t even necessary for success, and that many of the skills needed to succeed in the workplace are already in the successful students not just taught at some college. The text as a whole reveals the ugly truth that colleges are more focused on making money than actually helping their students succeed and because of this fact parents should take action to protect their students from being harmed in the process.

    Read More

  • Differences And Similarities Between The Williamites And The Jacobites

    1348 Words  | 3 Pages

    Both groups were forced to leave their homeland due to political conflict. My family fled after the Jacobites were defeated by the Williamites, while Cuban Americans fled the dictatorship of Castro and economic conditions in Cuba. Some later Irish immigrants were unfavored just as some Cuban immigrants were seen as undesirable. The majority of Cuban Americans were localized to Florida, while my family spread from Virginia to Kentucky to Kansas. Cuban Americans formed enclaves to survive, while my family consolidated themselves into the larger society. Cubans were associated with stereotypes such as: too successful and too ambitious. Stereotypes for Irish include: argumentative drunks, and swindlers. After settling in America, both groups experienced better education, job availability, and rise in socio-economic class over

    Read More

More about Comparing the Assimilation into American Culture of the Irish and the Native American

Open Document