Comparing The Yellow Wallpaper And The Necklace, By Charlotte Perkins

753 Words2 Pages

In the nineteenth century men were responsible for their families’ social statuses, while the woman were stuck being the homemakers. In this era, social statuses were of the upmost importance and were determined based on income, professions, and family. These statuses were important because they gave the community a sense of order. In “The Yellow Wallpaper,” by Charlotte Perkins, the narrator is suffering from an unstable state of mind and diagnose with “temporary nervous depression,” but must conceal her true thoughts and emotions so that she would not be more restricted then she was. “The Necklace,” by Guy De Maupassant, Madame Losiel, is a middle class woman who strives to be rich which leads to her dismay. In both of these stories the families …show more content…

The story take a place in a secluded mansion the family rented during the renovation of their home, but served as a place for her to undergo her treatment with the least stimulation possible, from her nervous breakdown. Doctors had diagnosed her with nervous depression and told her she “was forbidden to work, “from anything that could cause her excitement. For the most part her husband controlled her every move during her depression. She not only was prohibited to write, an outlet to express herself, from the inability to openly speak with her husband but is also place in a room that discomfort her. As the story continues we see her mental-health worsen although her appearance showed improvement, when she imagines a woman in the pattern of the wallpaper of her room. The narrator becomes obsessive and spends most her time tired and staring at the wallpaper. Until a few day before they leave that home she goes insane and begins to tear the wallpaper which frightens her husband but allows the character to feel …show more content…

During this time there was a gender distinction of male dominance and we see how this affect the narrator during her depression. In “The Changing Role of Womanhood,” by Deborah Thomas she further show how marriage enforces the male dominance and control over a woman and how that places a woman at the mercy of their husband. We can further see this when the narrator is diagnose with hysteria but she does not questioned her diagnoses although she was doubts because “if a physician of high standing, and one’s own husband, assures friends and relatives that there is really nothing the matter with one but temporary nervous depression- a slight hysterical tendency- what is one to do?”(648) said the narrator. This show how a woman could not have an opinion because it would be considered nonsense and set aside. Men were able to engage in the community and “gain their identity …and made decisions that enhance their position in society” while woman where endeavored in the domestic life (The changing role of womanhood). This is a display of how woman where stuck in a role of passivity and submission, like as child, they were not able to make decision for themselves and had to stay home. Charlotte husband was a well-known physician and their family was well off; they were considered high class in the community. Although moving to a rental home was a place to stay during

Open Document