Comparing Masked Marvel's Last Toehold And The Discus Thr

679 Words2 Pages

Often times, writers can get caught up in a certain writing style that makes all of their following work begin to blend in with the previous one. If they fail to give attention to including both similar, and familiar, characteristics, along with differing, and diversifying, details, the distinction between each piece and the interest of their readers will be lost. Richard Selzer's “The Masked Marvel’s Last Toehold” and “The Discus Thrower” have clear similarities and differences, such as the point of view used in both pieces or differing timelines, but also contain characteristics that are both shared and distinct with themselves, which includes the condition the patient is in. Possibly the most obvious characteristic both narratives share is the first person point of view experienced through the doctor. This gives the reader an inside view of how a medical professional reacts to the tragedy laid out before them, and in both situations allows the audience to the join the doctor …show more content…

In “The Discus Thrower,” the story follows a very chronological order, moving from day-to-day, and keeps itself in Room 542. In contrast, half of “The Masked Marvel’s Last Toehold” jumps back forty years to play out a flashback of the doctor in his youth. These differing timelines serve their purpose in Selzer’s stories, but greatly changes the effect that the ending has on the reader. To explain further, the first narrative only plays out the last few days of Room 542’s life, whereas the audience gets to relive the Masked Marvel’s glory days through the doctor’s flashbacks in the second. That added memory allows the audience to create a personal connection with the Masked Marvel, thus leaving a greater emotional impact from the amputation of his last leg than the death of the patient in Room 542 does, since the reader does not have a chance to create the same

Open Document