preview

Compare Antigone And Civil Disobedience

Better Essays
The truth on political thought is rooted primarily from the rules of the law. Western European image of justice and order can agree that the importance of natural equality gives the law something to adhere to. Thus creates this inconsistency, that civil disobedience is not justified because of society’s accentuation on law and order. The understanding of law and civil disobedience illustrates itself in both readings of Sophocles ' Antigone and Plato 's Apology which suggests that they give both similar views with the existing idea of different higher authority in mind. Because of the unresolved feud between the law and civil disobedience it is prevailed adequately in Sophocles ' Antigone and Plato 's Apology. Antigone personifies that the will…show more content…
Antigone understands that honor and responsibility to one’s family have equal distribution in her defense. She clarifies that she doesn’t fear the condemning she is unfortunately sentenced to, but the penalties from the divine, if she does not act on the evil doings that besieges her poor life. She emphasizes on the notion, "But if I left that corpse, my mother 's son, dead and unburied I 'd have cause to grieve as now I grieve not" (Sophocles 123). It is obvious that Antigone is willing to do whatever it takes to make sure that her divine duty is fulfilled even if it leads to her own death.to Antigone death prevailed to be a far more attractive option. Because of this Antigone understands the idea of the law and civil disobedience and what it can do to her if she does not adhere to it, but she has to make a conscious decisions based on the merit that divine law supersedes that of civil disobedience, and burying her brother is the right thing to…show more content…
Antigone believes and upholds her beliefs in the gods and disobey the state law. While Socrates believes in divine law and civil disobedience, and by disobeying the order of the state would in fact disobey the gods. Socrates believes that solely because of him being raised by the state, civil disobedience would secure his path to goodness and to the Gods. Which subsequently allows us to see that the law must be obeyed from both ends of the story. Because of the law being so essential it allows us to have the assumption that any violation of the law whether divine or civil must hold consequences. Because of the contradiction between the two it is up to the individual to choose which law to adhere to, and to accept whatever consequences are to come with it. Socrates and Antigone chose to obey the law that illustrated an image of higher authority and because of this, it resulted with their demise. Which eventually lead to their acceptance of the consequences their actions lead to, thus allowed the rules of both divine and civil law to be upheld, despite their lack of obedience towards the
Get Access