Compare And Contrast Two Footballers

689 Words2 Pages

The AL MVP race seems to have been whittled down to two major candidates, Aaron Judge of the New York Yankees and Jose Altuve of the Houston Astros. Both players have had fantastic seasons, and their respective stats bear that out. Here are the résumés:

Altuve: He leads the league in hits (203) and batting average (.350), has 32 stolen bases, a .415 on base percentage, 24 home runs and 81 RBI. He’s also an excellent defensive second baseman, whose WAR is 8.5.

Judge: He has broken the record for most home runs by a rookie in baseball history with an AL-leading 51 thus far, while also having 112 RBI, a .284 batting average, a .421 OBP and a 1.046 OPS. Although he leads the league in strikeouts with 205, he also leads the league in walks (125) …show more content…

Judge (6-foot-7) is one of the the biggest players in the league and Altuve (5-foot-6) is one of the smallest.

Although Altuve has power, he’s not intimidating. He’ll hurt you, but he won’t scare you. Judge is the most menacing figure in the game, as his stat cast home runs and exit velocity line drives are already legendary. Opposing pitchers know Judge is incredibly dangerous, which is why he draws so many walks, more than twice as many as Altuve (and Judge has 11 intentional walks to Altuve’s three).

Ask a baseball general manager which player he’d rather build his team around, and you’d probably get an even split across the board. Pick your poison; both players are still young and …show more content…

The Yankees probably aren’t a playoff team without Judge and his overall presence and power he delivered to their lineup all year.

Here’s another intangible in Judge’s favor: he came out of nowhere. It was very questionable in spring training if Judge would even make the Opening Day roster, much less carry the Yankees the way he has in 2017. Altuve, through no fault of his own, is a given. He’s going to be excellent every year. He’ll give the Astros 200 hits. He'll be dynamic, steal bases and play great defense. But, his consistency is what ultimately hurts him. His consistency is his curse.

This MVP race looks like a carbon copy of what happened in 2006. Derek Jeter had a great statistical year, eerily close to Altuve’s numbers in 2017, but it was what we all had grown accustomed to. Although Jeter’s year was better than his average excellence, it ultimately cost him the award. The Yankees would probably have still won without him. Justin Morneau squeaked by with the award that season because his power numbers made him slightly more valuable to the Central Division-winning Twins than Jeter was to the East Division-winning

Open Document