Compare And Contrast The Role Played By Politics And Power In This Case

1341 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Latest review of literature on performance appraisal

Complete #4 Questions
Q #1 In a narrative format, discuss the key facts and critical issues presented in the case. In this case Jim McGee manager of AstroTech Fuel Systems need to develop some power and learn to delegate work out to his staff. Normally, we all get our visits from corporate or some “big wig” in the company. This wasn’t a normal visit that Jim expects all the time. Roger Banter made a rare visit to see Jim pertaining to his work performance. Jim was surprised, his performance or his leadership style had failed him so badly that Mr. Banter threatened him to leave. Banter stated, I’ve discussed your situation with Corporate Headquarters and suggest you call your previous boss about the possibility of a transfer back to your old job back in Utah (Eisenbeis, Hanks & Sheehan, 2001). McGee thought he had been doing the best job every day for the company developing new products, increasing the department capability level. Jim as a boss or supervisor did not have any push towards his crew. The staff did …show more content…

Discuss how these play out in relation to Jim McGee, George Phalen, Ben short, and Dick Faraday. What power styles did each exhibit in the case? The political roles played in this case are very interesting. George Phalen, the division’s president seemed to be the person who had to show his strength and power towards the company. Throughout the case, Phalen was always correct and perfect, otherwise my way or the highway. From the onset, Phalen appeared to have become obsessed with Power (Eisenbeis, Hanks & Sheehan, 2001, p. 219). George exhibits two types of power; legitimate power because he has been with the organization for five years and no one will tell him what to do. The other power would be coercive power meaning he has the ability to force someone to act in a certain way based on fear of negative consequences if the action isn’t taken (Lester & Parnell, 2006, p.

Show More
Related

  • Organizational Cynicism Case Study

    1336 Words  | 3 Pages

    Do you think organization cynicism plays a role in this case? If so, how? If not, why not?

    Read More

  • Ross the Crazy Boss

    1214 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...f his position power to run Perot Systems drove employees hard to perform, at the expense of any consideration for the personal lives of his employees, or the long-term interests of clients. Perot stepped back from managing Perot Systems and put Meyerson in charge, but then showed little faith in Meyerson’s changes when they deviated from his vision for Perot Systems and seized power back before Meyerson’s changes could be given time to work.

    Read More

  • Ethics and Integrity in Guerrilla Government

    1120 Words  | 3 Pages

    The appointed regional directors, attempted to strong arm and change the culture of the EPA Seattle office evidenced by the abuse of authority, the blatant legal violations and the disregard for the seasoned employees that helped build the organization by threatening, demoting and firing competent

    Read More

  • Political Science Final Exam

    758 Words  | 2 Pages

    1. In your opinion, which ancient political practice, protective or developmental republicanism, has had the greatest impact on our liberal democratic practice?

    Read More

  • The Struggle of Power

    1326 Words  | 3 Pages

    Who holds the power? Which religion is stronger? In Bless Me Ultima, a coming of age story of a young boy, the protagonist struggles with the issue of which God should be followed, worshiped, and reverenced. The theme of power in religion is portrayed throughout Anaya’s book in various ways and means such as Ultima, Mrs. Marez, the sign of the cross, and Antonio himself.

    Read More

  • Robert Nardelli's Leadership Style Analysis

    444 Words  | 1 Pages

    the CEO at Home Depot, Robert Nardelli’s tenure was marked with heavy-handedness and inflexibility. Robert Nardelli’s leadership styles was autocratic. He utilized a command, control and conquer approach. He dictated policies and procedures, decided what goals were to be achieved, and directed and controlled all activities without any meaningful participation by the subordinates. He was in full control of the team, leaving low autonomy within the group. Before Nardelli came onboard, the managers of Home Depot had enjoyed independence under the laid-back entrepreneurship leadership style of Bernie Marcus. Almost immediately after Home Depot got Nardelli, he embarked on an aggressive plan to centralize control. He neglected the build relationships, inspired and aligned purpose, and create open communication with his team. He also disregarded the care of his shareholders. He was obsesses with goals, objectivity, and accomplishments within the boundaries of the values of the company. He

    Read More

  • Political Analysis of an Organization

    1883 Words  | 4 Pages

    The political analysis of an organization begins with the identification of the stakeholders “groups that have a shared ‘stake’ that is affected by what the organization is and how it carries out its activities (Ancona et al., 2005: M-2, 35)” The CEO of Dynacorp is ultimately responsible for the turnaround of the company and its success versus its competition. The front end of the company is divided into three geographic areas. Carl Greystone, Executive Vice President of US Customer Operations, manages the largest of the geographic areas (Dynacorp Revisited, 2005: M-2, 86-87). The geographic areas are divided further into regions; Ben Walker is a Vice President overseeing the Northeast Region and reports to Greystone (Dynacorp Revisited, 2005: M-2, 87).

    Read More

  • Corrupt Power

    870 Words  | 2 Pages

    People in high power, such as government officials, have a power to control whatever and whoever they want. In Time Out of Joint, by Philip Dick, Dick demonstrates this power, in which the United States government creates a world and brainwashes hundreds of people into preserving a town to seem like it is in 1959, in order to gain military advantage. In the novel, the government takes advantage of the illusions Ragle Gumm is experiencing and Dick demonstrates how by using organized narrative structure and strong characterization with the help of third person omniscient point of view to keep the reader in the dark about what is actually real.

    Read More

  • power and politics

    2045 Words  | 5 Pages

    It is not about “what you do”, “it is about who you are and who you know”. As employees, we have all heard sayings like this before when it comes to the business world. The “power and politic” mindset is a direct result of the type of tug of war experienced for millions of years; from prehistoric times through modern day. Ever since Ugha smashed Mugha in the head with a club back in prehistoric times, politics have been around in the workplace. Politics are a subliminal fight for survival and it actually happens in personal lives as much as it does in our work lives. Politics can go hand in hand with power, just as night follows the day. Many of the political situations that occur within a corporation are a result of growth and change. However, part of the task of becoming a viable asset to a corporation is to look beyond the surface and find out where the company is heading as a result of these changes. In this way, employees can position themselves to be a positive part of the growth and change.

    Read More

  • Political Theory

    597 Words  | 2 Pages

    Throughout Federalist 10, James Madison argues that we must allow people to separate into groups according to their needs and beliefs regarding the political system of our country. These factions will protect interests and create an elevated government comprised of the most knowledgeable and educated men to protect the citizenry. His arguments reflect his status as a wealthy and educated landowner that must protect himself in the face of the common people. I will argue that Madison’s argument is flawed, which he alludes to in his writing, because he neglects to acknowledge that people are self-interested and therefore, morally corrupt. This self-interest will be the downfall of Madison’s government as private interests take root and the will of the people is ignored in all places but elections.

    Read More

  • Essay On Power Tends To Corrupt And Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutely

    542 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men,” quoting historian Lord Acton. Before reading the quote, I never noticed the relationship between power and corruption in the real world. I thought of power as a form of recognition for hard work, that in turn is a positive outcome. After putting some thought into it, I realized my mistake

    Read More

  • Power & Authority

    410 Words  | 1 Pages

    Although they are very closely related, power and authority are two different concepts. Power is needed in order to establish authority, yet it is also completely distinct from authority (Week 9 Study Notes).

    Read More

  • Analysis Essay: The Abuse Of Power

    519 Words  | 2 Pages

    Power is the ability to control or influence others, especially socially or politically. We often hear of the horror stories, in which corrupt dictators with too much power kill innocent citizens, eliminate all competition, and hurt others for personal gain. Power itself is not necessarily the bad thing here; it comes as an instinctive need to humans, rooted in the primal purpose of survival (Anchor text). The abuse of power leads to corruption. Power is an unstable force that can have positive or negative outcomes, depending on why it was sought and the attitude of those on the receiving end of the control.

    Read More

  • Corruption & Destruction by Power

    633 Words  | 2 Pages

    Authority in a society is a necessary evil which when unfettered, results in the abuse of power. Power has long been considered a corrupting and a disrupting force in function and in influence. Underlying motives and greed fuel those who seek to gain and or abuse this power. The Crucible examines this twisted force as it corrupts societies’ clergy, blinds its justices, and empowers those who seek to abuse it. Arthur Miller shows how power can be a corrupting influence and how it can blind the judgment of authoritative figures.

    Read More

  • Dichotomy between Politics and Public Administration

    1353 Words  | 3 Pages

    Politics-Administration Dichotomy essentially has a two part meaning; there are two functions of government for this idea, as the name implies politics, and administration. The argument about the dichotomy between politics and public administration has been around for several years with no overall consensus on why they should be distinct from one another. Looking critically at both sides of the idea, there are ways to demonstrate an accurate presentation of the administrative agencies working and there are also ways they have proved to be inaccurate. There are just as many downfalls to a politicized bureaucracy. There will be more benefits to the politics-administration dichotomy view with the concept put in place by Woodrow Wilson. He simply promotes a clear distinction between politics and administration and supports the idea that they are interdependent of one another, and they require one another for the appropriate balance between democracy and efficiency. The idea of Wilson’s concept will allow agencies to gain the most efficiency through interdependence of politics-administration.

    Read More

More about Compare And Contrast The Role Played By Politics And Power In This Case

Open Document