Compare And Contrast Lamb To The Slaughter And The Lottery
argumentative Essay
984 words
"Lamb to the Slaughter," by Roald Dahl, was published in September, 1953. and "The Lottery," by Shirley Jackson, was published June, 1948. Although these stories are very different, they both share one common theme. That theme would be violence. In "Lamb to the Slaughter," Mary Maloney kills her husband over the fear of him leaving her. Then she feeds the evidence to the police. In "The Lottery," the entire town participates every year to see who will get stoned to death. A difference in these short stories is the fact that in "Lamb to the Slaughter," she knows that killing her husband is wrong, but she still does it; while in "The Lottery," the whole town believes that it is alright to kill someone like this every year. Although, in both stories, …show more content…
In this essay, the author
- Compares the themes of "lamb to the slaughter" and "the lottery." in both stories, the violence is horrible if it gets them in trouble or gets themselves killed.
- Explains that in "the lottery," everyone in the town participates. everyone picks a piece of paper out of the small, beaten up, black box.
- Compares "lamb to the slaughter" and "the lottery" in that children are brainwashed into believing that what they are doing to others is ok.
- Analyzes how in "the lottery," no one gets in trouble for killing others. in "lamb to the slaughter," mrs. maloney was not found guilty of the crime, but thought of it as ok.
- Compares how in "the lottery" no one feels guilt or sadness, or much of anything, towards the person they are murdering.
- Analyzes how mary maloney in "lamb to the slaughter" would have reacted if she were caught with murder.
- Concludes that both "the lottery" and "lamb to the slaughter" contain people who do what they want with no consequences that anyone will have to pay for in the future.
Children are even picking up stones to go after and kill the chosen person. "Bobby Martin had already stuffed his pockets full of stones, and the other boys soon followed his example, selecting the smoothest and roundest stones" (Jackson 1). The children are taught at a young age to participate in the tradition of the lottery and they are brainwashed early on into this. People in this town have done this tradition for so long that they do not know that it is wrong. They think that the people who stop the tradition of the lottery are the crazy ones. "That over in the north village they're talking of giving up the lottery." Old Man Warner snorted. "Pack of crazy fools," he said. "Listening to the young folks, nothing's good enough for them" (Jackson 4). These people have been brain washed into believing that what they are doing to their fellow community members is ok. Meanwhile, in "Lamb to the Slaughter;" this story is story starts off with Mary Maloney's husband telling her that he is leaving her. She is in total shock and is extremely confused about how this could have happened. Mary Maloney goes down to the freezer to get a leg of lamb. She sneaks up behind her husband and hits him over the head with the lamb leg, effectively killing him. "She might as well have hit him with a steel bar" (Dahl 2). This is a very extreme way of killing someone; just like in "The Lottery" how there is an extreme method used to kill …show more content…
Mrs. Hutchinson speaks out when Bill Hutchinson is chosen only because he is a family member. If he were not, she wouldn't have cared if he lived or died. When she, herself, is chosen, she gets upset about it and now it is suddenly not fair. "Tessie Hutchinson was in the center of a cleared space by now, and she held her hands out desperately as the villagers moved in on her. "It isn't fair," she said" (Dahl 7). This is most likely how Mary Maloney in "Lamb to the Slaughter" would have reacted if she were caught with murder. She only laughed because she got away with her crime. "And in the other room, Mary Maloney began to laugh" (Jackson 4). She would have been just like Tessie Hutchinson saying "It's not fair" when they haul Mrs. Maloney off to
Let Our AI Magic Supercharge Your Grades!
Related
- analytical
- opinion
- argumentative
- comparative
- Similarities Between The Lottery And The Rocking Horse Winneranalytical essayThe titles of both short stories do have some similarities even though they show contrasting aspects of the same theme. Jackson’s title “The Lottery” gives reference to a game of chance with a positive outcome and invokes images of winners of fabulous prizes. It is also compared to other happy events when Jackson writes, “The lottery was conducted—as were the
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how shirley jackson and d.h. lawrence's "the lottery" show contrasting aspects of the same theme, sacrifice.
- Compares the titles of jackson's "the lottery" and lawrence' "rocking-horse winner."
- Analyzes how lawrence expresses the willingness of sacrifice in "the lottery" when he writes of how distraught paul is when his mother doesn't know leading up to the derby.
- Analyzes how jackson's "the rocking-horse winner" depicts the ultimate sacrifice in an entirely different light.
- Compares the short stories by shirley jackson and d.h. lawrence, "the lottery" and "rocking-horse winner." both authors view the idea of sacrifice in each story differently.
703 wordsRead More - Dangers Of Humanity In Shirley Jackson's The Lotteryanalytical essayThe Lottery, a gothic short story written by Shirley Jackson, illustrates a fantasy about a small and isolated community that takes part in a sacrificial ritual that can only be described as vile and barbaric. Names of all of the citizens are put in a “black box” and eventually, a person is randomly selected to be stoned to death by their own family and fellow citizens. The reason for stoning, or the beliefs of the citizens, is to ensure there is a good crop yield for the year. Shirley Jackson uses the story to expose the subtle brutality in humanity and the dangers in social insecurities that lead to blind faith and following in traditions and cultures. Jackson uses plot and setting to illustrate the subtle brutality in humanity. Characters
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how shirley jackson's the lottery illustrates a fantasy about an isolated community that takes part in sacrificial ritual that can only be described as vile and barbaric.
- Analyzes how shirley jackson uses the setting and plot of the lottery to illustrate human tendencies of brutality.
- Analyzes how the characters in the lottery expose the dangers of social insecurities. old man warner is a prime example of people blindly following tradition.
- Analyzes how shirley jackson conveys the message of human brutality, and the dangers of social insecurities, by using symbolism to illustrate following traditions blindly.
- Analyzes how the "black box" in the lottery is used to hold the names of all the citizens in the town.
1330 wordsRead More - Theme Of Death In The Lotteryanalytical essayThe stones were heavily emphasized throughout the story. It is later revealed that they are used to murder the individual who is unfortunate enough to get the marked slip of paper. The method of stoning is a punishment from biblical times. The townspeople, who believed themselves to be good people, used a savage form capital punishment due to their superstitions. Not only did the adults stone individuals every year, the children were involved as well. The children, specifically the boys, were recruited to collect the stones for their ritual every year. The beginning of the story tells of the boys collecting stones until they created “a great pile of stones in one corner of the square and guarded it against the raid of the other boys,” (Jackson 133). The boys collected the arsenal for the townsfolk to use against their victim. The children grow up surrounded by barbaric actions that they will grow up to accept it like their parents. An example of the brainwashing effects is in the end of the story. The townspeople showed no remorse when they descended on Tessie with the stones. Encouragements were said by a few townspeople to get the stoning started. Tessie continued to scream about the unfairness of it all but no hesitation was told to have occurred. The townsfolk in “The Lottery” were truly reduced to barbaric or savage individuals every
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how tradition, such as human sacrifice, has been extinct for centuries because people began to understand how morbid, barbaric, and unfair the old ways were.
- Analyzes how the black box presented in the story may represent death. the box is worn down from years of use, mimicking the weathered and dead look of the grim reaper.
- Analyzes how the stones represent the barbaric nature of the townspeople in "the lottery."
- Analyzes how mr. summers is responsible for the death of an individual, like a god, and administers the lottery each year.
- Analyzes how mr. summers used a black box to deliver death to the townspeople by stoning. jackson uses symbols to show the dark side of the town and humanity.
891 wordsRead More - Roald Dahl a Norwegian author, in 19 54. It is a Black comedy and was
In this essay, the author
- Describes roald dahl's black comedy, a norwegian author, in 1954.
- Describes who or what caused her to feel her terror.
- Describes males as "such as would occur to a clever and ruthless man."
- Opines that she may not be able to survive on her own, she needs his help.
- Narrates how she was letting all her love for home, it was then that it hit her.
- Explains that he gives a moral, which is, do not do to.
- Opines that dr roylott's death is likely to weigh heavily.
- Opines that he may have wanted the story.
- Opines that the crime is not the point in this case.
- Opines that they prefer "lamb to the slaughter" for the ending.
- Opines that if he hadn't been alive, maybe this is a hint telling us.
- Analyzes how she liked to be in his company, no matter what mood he was in, as long as she was happy.
- Analyzes how dahl may be trying to say that in a world as uncertain as this.
2161 wordsRead More - American Flag Stands For Tolerance By Barbara Jordananalytical essayOn lottery day, everybody politely and cheerfully converses with one another, making jokes and laughing. But when it’s time for everyone to open the slip of paper they drew from the old box, things definitely take a dark turn. The head of household that draws the one paper with a black dot on it must make the other members of their family draw a slip. The family member that draws the second dotted slip is stoned to death as a sacrifice to help ensure a good harvest, whether that person is a toddler or an elderly man or woman. One of the sickest parts of the whole ordeal happened after Tessie Hutchinson drew the paper that sealed her fate: one of the villagers handed Tessie’s young son Davy a stone to throw at his own mother. The people that had been casually speaking with Tessie just minutes beforehand are now taking her life, solely because they believe it will make the fall harvest plentiful. There isn’t discrimination in this text as much as there is conformity. The people of the village are ready and willing to stone someone to death because tradition has told them that it was a good thing, so they follow through with it, even though they’re committing murder. Everybody has their traditions that other may find weird, but brutally killing
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the first collection of the textbook revolved around relating and interacting with other people, and is inspired by barbara jordan's quote, "we, as human beings, must be willing to accept people who are different from ourselves."
- Analyzes how ronald j. allen's article, american flag stands for tolerance, talks about the release and dropping of charges of gregory lee johnson, who burned an american flag during a government protest in 1984.
- Analyzes how barbara jordan's quote applies to the main plot of to kill a mockingbird. the blatant racial discrimination expressed by the jury is shocking but unfortunately not unexpected.
- Analyzes how barbara jordan's quote applies to the short story, the lottery, in that everyone in the village conforms to a sadistic tradition even though someone is killed every year.
- Analyzes how barbara jordan's quote, "we, as human beings, must be able to accept people who are different from ourselves," applies to every text in collection 1.
911 wordsRead More - Compare And Contrast The Lottery And First They Cameanalytical essayThe lottery is a story about a village that has been blindly following this tradition for many years. Everybody has been copying what has been done for years. They are picking a name from a hat and killing the person. One character, Tessie, comes late and seems less eager than others. Then she gets chosen as the victim. In First they came, it is a poem about soldiers who are taking people from certain groups like “Socialists, trade unionists, and Jews.” away. The author does not speak out against it, and they came for him.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how the lottery and first they came have the theme standing up for what is right might not be easy. people who are going along with the crowd may be scared that they will be hurt.
- Analyzes how the lottery is about a village that has been blindly following this tradition for many years. tessie comes late and seems less eager than others.
- Analyzes how the lottery ritual is done every year and is considered normal. the poem is about a war, and people are being captured and it seems like it has not gone on for generations.
- Analyzes how the lottery, mr. summers, mrs. delacroix, tessie's friend, and the nazis were the ones taking people away. both texts were about injustice being done.
- Analyzes how the poem repeats the same words over and over. tessie's family gets selfish and wants her daughter included in the draw.
- Explains that both texts have a theme that it is hard to go against what the group is doing, and sometimes it may be too scary to speak up.
- Analyzes how the lottery and first they came have the theme standing up for what is right might not be easy. people who are going along with the crowd may be scared that they will be hurt.
- Analyzes how the lottery is about a village that has been blindly following this tradition for many years. tessie comes late and seems less eager than others.
- Analyzes how the lottery ritual is done every year and is considered normal. the poem is about a war, and people are being captured and it seems like it has not gone on for generations.
- Analyzes how the lottery, mr. summers, mrs. delacroix, tessie's friend, and the nazis were the ones taking people away. both texts were about injustice being done.
- Analyzes how the poem repeats the same words over and over. tessie's family gets selfish and wants her daughter included in the draw.
- Explains that both texts have a theme that it is hard to go against what the group is doing, and sometimes it may be too scary to speak up.
1386 wordsRead More - Comparing Lamb To The Slaughteranalytical essay“It’s the same old story. Get the weapon, and you’ve got the man.” (Dahl, 322) The first story is called A Brief Moment in the Life of Angus Bethune. It’s about a high school senior who is considered “not normal.” He gets bullied and comes from a bigger family. The second story is called Lamb to the Slaughter. It’s about a woman named Mary Maloney who spontaneously decides to kill her husband, Patrick after he reveals that he is leaving her. The protagonists of each short story, Mary Maloney, and Angus Bethune seem to have some similarities as well as many differences. Both characters have slight mental issues and high intelligence. The difference is that Angus gains a potential lover and Mary kills her soon to be ex-husband.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes the similarities and differences between mary maloney and angus bethune. both characters have slight mental issues and high intelligence.
- Compares angus bethune's low self-esteem with mary maloney, who is in love with her husband. both have a subtle mental health concern.
- Analyzes how angus and mary share the similarity of being very smart. both protagonists are resourceful and knowledgeable.
- Analyzes how mary killed her cheating husband, and angus got the girl of his dreams.
- Compares angus bethune and mary maloney's intelligence and mental problems. both characters are similar, but also very different.
692 wordsRead More - Compare And Contrast The Lottery And First They Cameargumentative essayBoth “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson and “First They Came” have the same themes that can and can’t relate to each other. “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson is about a small town doing a ritual every year with a death lottery to help grow their crops. “First They Came” by Martin Niemoller is about how the Nazis came for the different people and the narrator didn’t speak out for them and there was nobody left to speak for him. If you don’t speak out for something sometimes bad things don’t change.
In this essay, the author
- Compares the themes of "the lottery" by shirley jackson and "first they came".
- Compares "the lottery" and "first they came", where people believe killing one person per year will help the crops grow.
- Analyzes how the narrator regretted not speaking out for the people in "the lottery". the people of "first they came" could have spoken up to end the ritual, but they didn't because they were too afraid of what the other townsfolk would think.
- Compares "first they came" and "the lottery" in that nobody was brave enough to speak up for each other, so the onslaught of people kept going.
- Analyzes how "the lottery" and "first they came" teach different life lessons.
459 wordsRead More - Similarities Between The Hunger Games And The Lotteryanalytical essayIn stories that both end with innocent people being brutally murdered for the sake of upholding a tradition, there are bound to be similarities. The Hunger Games, directed by Gary Ross, is the story of a girl who is chosen as a sacrifice in the annual Hunger Games, forced to fight and kill tributes from other districts to survive. The Lottery, by Shirley Jackson, is the story of a woman who is chosen as a sacrifice in the annual lottery, stoned to death by the people in her village. The Hunger Games and The Lottery have similar symbols, characters, and settings.
In this essay, the author
- Compares the stories of the hunger games and the lottery, which end with innocent people being brutally murdered for the sake of upholding a tradition.
- Analyzes how the mockingjay pin that katniss everdeen wears in the hunger games represents the rebellion against the capitol and the potential for change in the bleak society that the lottery is set in.
- Analyzes how high society dissociates from the cruelty of the hunger games and forces tributes to play to a crowd to get sponsors.
- Analyzes how president coriolanus snow, the leader of panem, has a strong influence on everyone involved in the 74th annual hunger games. mr. graves is the postmaster, which gives him authority based on communication with areas outside the village.
- Analyzes the similarities between the hunger games and the lottery. both have settings where the population has become completely desensitized to murder, symbols that represent society’s potential to change the tradition, and characters that influence the events surrounding the sacrifice.
828 wordsRead More - Dahl's Lamb To The Slaughteranalytical essayIn Dahl’s “Lamb to the Slaughter”, a very happy and pregnant wife waits for her husband to come home from work. She notices that he is very unusual in his responses and character. To her surprise, her husband tells her that he is leaving her for another woman and that she shouldn’t get upset because he will make sure that she will be taken care of. In a silent rage, Mrs. Maloney hits him on the back of the head with a frozen leg of lamb and kills him instantly. She stages the house as if a robbery happened and proceeds to put the leg of lamb in the oven. She then rushes to the grocery stuff to get the rest of the stuff for “dinner” and upon her return calls the police to report the murder. After the police finish questioning her and searching
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes dahl's "lamb to the slaughter" where a pregnant wife waits for her husband to come home from work. she hits him on the back of the head and kills him instantly.
197 wordsRead More - These two are short fiction stories by American writers of the 20th century with both having a common social and religious setup. ‘The Lottery’ by Shirley Jackson is based on a small American town described by an annual ritual they refer to as the lottery in which through a lottery game a member of the society selected is stoned to death. The lottery is based on the families and with the argument that it’s with this tradition, they get a good harvest, Warner quotes, “Lottery in June, corn be heavy soon (Jackson, 25).” On the other hand, ‘The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas,’ describes the communal setup of the imagined city of Omelas, a city of delight and unbelievable happiness. The story presents the summer festival celebrated in Omelas which is very vibrant and glorious. Though the writer does not give an account of the social, political and economic setup of omegas. On the contrary, the state of happiness and splendor
In this essay, the author
- Compares the theme of sacrifice in the two short stories and how its history of humanity in relation to the current social and religious setup.
- Explains that sacrifice is the offer of possession or lives with a higher and divine religious purpose. jesus challenges the pharisees who brought to him the adulterous woman and wanted to stone her to death for her sins.
425 wordsRead More - Compare And Contrast The Lottery And First They Cameanalytical essay“The lottery” and “first they came” both have the same theme of killing people whether its tradition or just killing people in general you’re still following the same theme however the two story’s use different text structures to convey the message to the reader.
In this essay, the author
- Compares how the short story "the lottery" and the poem "first they came" use different text structures to convey the message to the reader.
- Analyzes how the poem "first they came" uses the idea of a poem to convey the message to the reader that the dialogue isn't that detailed.
224 wordsRead More - A Comparison Of Lamb To The Slaughter And Desiree's Babyanalytical essayThe many different styles of writing can be highly represented by the authors Kate Chopin, an African American writer during the late 19th century and Roald Dahl a British writer during the late 20th century. Furthermore, this can be represented in their stories Desiree’s Baby by Chopin and Lamb to the Slaughter by Dahl. Desiree’s Baby takes place during 1800s narrating a fictional story about a couple having partial knowledge of each others past falling in love and decide to have a child. However, when the couple later discovers their child was a quadroon, Armand finds his love for Desiree to be broken. Consequently, Desiree decides to kill herself and her baby. Resolving with Armand discovering his mother was African American. Moreover,
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how different styles of writing can be represented by s kate chopin and roald dahl. desiree's baby and lamb to the slaughter share numerous characteristics in styles and plots.
- Analyzes how irony was used in both desiree's baby and lamb to the slaughter.
- Analyzes how the irony throughout the story elaborates the meaning wanted to provide.
- Analyzes how desiree and mary reacted differently to their partner's heartbreak, killing themselves and their baby, while mary used her child as an excuse.
800 wordsRead More - Lamb To The Slaughter Compare And Contrastargumentative essayThe idea of stories and storytelling has been around for a long time. Stories are often meant to entertain the reader. However, stories are not always about happy things. Two stories that are examples of this include “The Way Up to Heaven” and “Lamb to the Slaughter.” These two books contain several similarities as well as several differences to one another.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that stories are often meant to entertain the reader, but not always about happy things. "the way up to heaven" and "lamb to the slaughter" have similarities and differences.
- Compares how "the way up to heaven" and "lamb to the slaughter" contain the murder of the husband in an unconventional way.
- Compares "lamb to the slaughter" and "the way up to heaven" in terms of plot lines, murder weapon, and how the women killed their husbands.
- Analyzes how "lamb to the slaughter" and "the way up to heaven" differ and are similar to each other. both stories reveal how affecting one’s emotions could result in a desired or undesired result.
486 wordsRead More - Compare And Contrast Lamb To The Slaughter And The Lady Or The Tigerargumentative essayIn the two well known stories, “Lamb to the Slaughter” and “The Lady or the Tiger,” both deal with relationships that have gone wrong. The story for “Lamb to the Slaughter,” starts out with Mary Maloney, who is pregnant and sews and waits for her husband to come home everyday. When her husband comes home one day and tells her that he is leaving her, she gets upset and ends up killing him with a frozen lamb leg. By the end of the story she is able to also get away with doing it. As for “The Lady or the Tiger,” this story deals with a King, whose daughter has fallen in love with a man who is not of the same status as she is. When the king finds out of this, he sends him to their version of a court system, which consists of choosing between two doors. One that has a tiger that will kill them and one that has a girl that the man will get to marry. The princess knows which door has each option in it and has the power to tell him which one to choose. Although in the end, the story never actually tells you which one she picks, and leaves it up to you to imagine what she does. Both of these stories have a lot in common, such as dealing with complicated relationships, as well as both of these women end up losing no matter what they choose.
In this essay, the author
- Compares the two well-known stories, "lamb to the slaughter" and "the lady or the tiger." both deal with complicated relationships and women end up losing no matter what they choose.
- Compares mary maloney's love for her husband and the princess who hated her for seeing the fair creature throwing glances of admiration upon her lover.
- Analyzes how mary maloney and the princess both have the power to kill their husbands, while in mary's case she killed her husband instead of facing the fact that he was leaving her.
- Analyzes how mary maloney would choose to send her husband to the tiger if she were in the princesses' shoes.
524 wordsRead More