Clean Air Act Case Study

771 Words2 Pages

1. Explain what is meant when the Clean Air Act is described as "a classic command and control statute"? What are the shortcomings of a command and control system as applied to the environment? The classic command and control system of the Clean Air Act focuses on controlling pollution in the air to a minimum level. There are three types of standards within the command and control system, which include ambient, emission, and technology. Ambient standards regulate the pollution around a surrounding area of an environment. Emission standards regulate emissions level allowed. Technology standards require certain techniques, technologies, and practices to be used. (Command and Control) Costs are not taken into account when enforcing the command …show more content…

The cost of the reduction in pollution is streamlined over an entire area. For an example, the Clean Air Act required the city of St. Louis to cut the emissions of the certain amount. There are two factories that could cut their emissions, with a paper factory paying $4 per ton and a brewery paying $600 a ton. The command and control system would require both the paper factory and brewery to cut emissions by ten tons each, costing $6,040. The new tradable permits solution allows the brewery to pay the paper factory to cut their emissions by 20 tons and reducing the total cost of the reduction to $80. (Crandall)
2. Using internet sources discuss the main health effects of air pollution and rank them in order of economic cost per year. You can use national, international, or state-level figures but be consistent in your use of the data.
There are six common pollutants in the air, which include ozone, particulate matter, carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxide, sulfur dioxide, and lead. These pollutants led to many different symptoms across the United States. Ozone pollution leads to impaired respiratory system. Particulate matter affects respiratory systems, causes cancer, and premature death. Carbon monoxide affects the bloodstream and reduces oxygen to the body’s organs. Nitrogen oxide causes influenza. Sulfur dioxide effects respiratory illness and pulmonary defenses. Lead causes effects in the liver, …show more content…

What is an AQCR? Find one attainment AQCR (anywhere in the U.S.) and one nonattainment AQCR. Describe them briefly and compare and contrast their characteristics THAT PERTAIN TO ATTAINMENT STATUS. Air quality control regions (AQCR) were designated by the federal government to implement air quality standards in regions based on urban-industrial concentrations, jurisdictional boundaries, among other factors. (Reed, 1986) The AQCR deems to be classified as attainment and nonattainment area according to the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS), which set the pollution level of the six common air pollutants. An AQCR may have attainment for one pollutant and have nonattainment for another. (Fact Sheet: The Clean Air Act: Prevention of Significant Deterioration (PSD) and New Source Review

Open Document