Choice Vs. Chance in "Pride and Prejudice"

832 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Pride and prejudice critical analysis

Joel Weinsheimer's article "Chance and the hierarchy of marriages in Pride and Prejudice" defines chance as "ignorance of causes and consequences" and supposes it to be the driving force behind the action and ending of the novel (405). Events such as Elizabeth and the Gardiner's change of plans to Derbyshire and Darcy's business that brings him to Pemberley are given great importance as chance happenings. I suppose too, that the relationships of Charlotte-Collins, Lydia-Wickham, Jane-Bingley, and even the nonexistent ones of Miss Bingley-Darcy, and Elizabeth-Wickham serve an important role in bringing together Darcy and Elizabeth by chance. But to believe that the action of the novel is dictated by chance seems foolhardy; it is a theory that is too neat and tidy to be entirely plausible to me. Weinsheimer's article lists "Jane Austen's method of establishing chance as a credible and effective plot device" (405). I would argue that it is careful choice in marriage, not chance, which dictates the happiness of the characters. Discretion of choice is, simply put, the balance between love and love of money, and takes into consideration wealth, rank, acceptable character traits, a reasonable show of emotion, and general attraction. It is not by chance that there are only four truly happy individuals at the end of the novel, but rather because the others made such poor choices.

Austen makes it clear throughout her writings that marriage for mercenary reasons such as for money, attraction, a home or rank is a bad idea and the ending of Pride and Prejudice is witness to this: Charlotte Lucas and Mr. Collins end up avoiding each other, Mr. Bennet continuously takes amusement at his wife's expense, and Lydia soon loses Wickham`s affec...

... middle of paper ...

...ng force behind his unsatisfying yet entertaining marriage.

Weinsheimer's article defines an ideal choice as one that "is made in full awareness of motives and consequences." I argue that it is seldom in real life or fiction that individuals are able to make a choice in full awareness of its consequences, and likewise, most individuals would shy away from making an uninformed choice. Most of Austen's characters seem to be making educated choices where they are somewhat aware of or can at least guess the consequences of their actions. As a reader I resent the idea of chance being given such importance where it is undeserved.

Works Cited

Austen, Jane. Pride and Prejudice. Ed. Robert P. Irvine. Ontario: Broadview Press Ltd., 2002.

Weinsheimer, Joel. "Chance and the Hierarchy of marriage in Pride and Prejudice." ELH Vol. 39, NO. 3 (Sep., 1972): 404-419.

Show More
Related

  • Similarities Between Pride And Prejudice And A Thousand Splendid Suns

    1818 Words  | 4 Pages

    At this point in time, love was overcoming all situations. Not only that, but the book represents the pressures women had to rely on men. The ending is progressive as seen with the main characters marriage situations. Darcy and Bingley are both financially secure unlike the Bennet sisters or Charlotte Lucas whose families need to work for their money and the land would be inherited by someone else. Women were to be married off to have at least some fortune. However the two Bennet sisters (and also most of the male characters), Jane and Elizabeth, choose love over wealth status. Especially seen with Elizabeth in chapter 19, her consistent rejection towards Collins’s proposal gave the reader proof that she doesn't want to marry for money, she could've said yes and been set for the rest of their life and inherit her father’s estate, but ended up marrying Darcy who she fell in love with. Darcy threw away his possible marriage with Miss de Bourgh, Bingley threw away the possible marriage with Miss Darcy (even though his sisters kept trying to get them two together because Miss de Bourgh is upper class compared to Eliza), and both of them could've been set for life and benefited from their wives money instead of marrying the middle class Bennet

    Read More

  • Elizabeth and Darcy: Flaws and All

    546 Words  | 2 Pages

    Marriage was not about love in the 19th century, and this is shown when Charlotte Lucas marries Mr. Collins. Charlotte needs to secure a future for herself, and marriage is the only option for a woman to improve her financial standing. Additionally, Mrs. Bennet constantly tries to marry her daughters off throughout the novel. In the 19th century, the only reason women really existed was for marriage. ...

    Read More

  • Marriage in Pride and Prejudice

    495 Words  | 1 Pages

    Marriage in Pride and Prejudice It is a truth universally acknowledged that a single man in possession of good fortune must be in want of a wife." Jane Austen provides subsequent argument with the first line of her novel, Pride and. Prejudice. The.

    Read More

  • Reputation and Love in Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen

    1583 Words  | 4 Pages

    Bloom's Guide to Pride and Prejudice. N. p. : n.p., n.d. print. Johnson, Claudia Durst, ed., pp. 113-117.

    Read More

  • Elizabeth Bennet Foil

    1050 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Pride and Prejudice, Elizabeth Bennet’s journey to love and marriage is the focal point of the narrative. But, the lesser known source of richness in Austen’s writing comes from her complex themes the well-developed minor characters. A closer examination of Charlotte Lucas, Elizabeth’s dear friend in Pride and Prejudice, shows that while she did not take up a large amount of space in the narrative, her impact was great. Charlotte’s unfortunate circumstances in the marriage market make her a foil to Elizabeth, who has the power of choice and refusal when it comes to deciding who will be her husband. By focusing on Charlotte’s age and lack of beauty, Austen emphasizes how ridiculous and cruel marriage can be in this time.

    Read More

  • Comparing Male Dominance in Pride and Prejudice, Mansfield Park, and Emma

    3346 Words  | 7 Pages

    Works Cited Austen, Jane. A. Pride and Prejudice. Norton Critical 3rd edition, ed. Donald Gray. New York and London: Norton, 2001.

    Read More

  • Themes Of Marriage In Jane Austen's Pride And Prejudice

    1258 Words  | 3 Pages

    Since the beginning of time, marriage exists as a large part of life. The values of marriage change on a year to year basis and as trends continue to change so will marriage. There have been numerous reasons for marriage throughout time such as arranged, wealth, love or many others. In the 18th century, many marriages were based on one’s class and wealth and not true love. Today, many marriages do not take wealth or class into account they focus on that person’s inner self and love. Marriage exists as an overlying theme throughout Pride and Prejudice and every marriage appears for a different reason.

    Read More

  • Essay On Mr Darcy Character Development

    1037 Words  | 3 Pages

    Each of Jane Austen’s characters in her novel, Pride and Prejudice, experiences a significant character development. Whether the change occurs by self-realization or through the assistance of another character varies from each individual character. For Austen’s leading man, Mr. Darcy, his character improvement is documented through his two marriage proposals to Elizabeth Bennet and her subsequent first rejection of his proposal. His first proposal demonstrates his extreme arrogance, elitism, and blindness to his many flaws. While his latter proposal shows not only the recognition of his deficiencies, but the overall improvement in his mentality. Mr. Darcy’s two proposals, though having the same intended end result, are completely different

    Read More

  • Social Norms in Jane Austen´s Pride and Prejudice

    1189 Words  | 3 Pages

    Austen’s Pride and Prejudice is well noted for its ability to question social norms. Most importantly, Austen explores the institution of marriage, as it was in her time, a time where many married for security rather than love. Her characters Elizabeth and Charlotte are renowned even more for their outspoken nature and different views on marriage. Though both Elizabeth and Charlotte yearn for a happy marriage, Charlotte has a more pragmatic and mundane approach while Elizabeth is more romantic and daring with her actions. Through the romantic involvements of both Elizabeth and Charlotte, Austen shows that happiness in marriage is not entirely a matter of chance, but is instead contingent on an accurate evaluation of self and others

    Read More

  • Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice Characters and Social Expectations

    1861 Words  | 4 Pages

    England, under James 1st rule was a vastly altered period compared to our now modern society. So many of the values held during this time, have now been discarded and forgotten. Jane Austen grew up in the Romantic period and experienced a world which was divided, whether through education, class, status, fashion, abilities, gender and etiquette. Her novel, Pride and Prejudice is counted as one of the great classics of English Literature. Austen engrosses readers to live in her world for a time and experience a society filled with matchmaking, romance, marriage and gossip. Every one of her characters is so distinctive and has a clearly outlined caricature. Each of their diverse values conveys a different thinking of the time. Pride and Prejudice is preoccupied with the gentry and most of the social aspects which consumed these people’s lives. There were so many expectations of how you would behave in public, but of course not all of these were upheld. Elizabeth Bennet, Mr Darcy, Mrs Bennet and Charlotte Lucas are four characters which keep such strong beliefs about the social norms. These characters are expressed so descriptively and through their personalities readers can learn just how the numerous social standards were received.

    Read More

  • Pride In Jane Austen's 'Pride And Prejudice'

    1204 Words  | 3 Pages

    Even after its publication in 1813 Jane’s Austen’s romantic and wonderfully written masterpiece, Pride and Prejudice, remains an absolute joy to read for thousands and thousands of readers across the globe. The 19th century novel enchants the youngest of readers to the wisest of souls. Many individuals all over the world, very much like us as university students here at Villanova, are quite intrigued by the amazingly created characters, impressively dynamic portrayal of an oppressively class-bound culture, and the vitality of a strong woman at the center of the novel. Jane Austen presents the reader with the most tantalizing and illustrious opening sentence, which enamors the reader and never lets go. "It is a truth universally acknowledged,

    Read More

  • Infatuation Of Marriage In Jane Austen's Pride And Prejudice

    1327 Words  | 3 Pages

    Jane Austen, also criticizes marriage based on convenience and money. She criticizes through the experiences of Charlotte and Collins. The characters Charlotte and Collins are “perfect” for each other, they are both fake, selfish and scheming. In the nineteenth century, “most” not all women had this mindset where they wanted to marry successful and rich men to secure their futures. Love meant nothing to these types of women. Materialistic things meant everything. Charlotte Lucas is a character that only got married to secure her future. “Miss Lucas perceived him from an upper window...and instantly set out to meet him accidentally in the lane” After Charlotte finds out collins had been

    Read More

  • Characters In Pride And Prejudice

    1191 Words  | 3 Pages

    The story of Pride and Prejudice starts with a ball, this is the first time that Elizabeth and Jane met Mr. Darcy and Mr. Bingley . While Jane and Mr. Bingley immediately began to take a liking to each other, Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy certainly did not enjoy each others company, as upon their first meeting, Mr. Darcy had gravely insulted her with comments about her looks and also by not asking her to dance. Over the course of the next few meetings, Elizabeth,s hatred of Mr. Darcy grew until she could not see past her hatred of Darcy to any of his good qualities or his personality. A few weeks after these happening Jane Caught a sickness from riding to Mr. Bingley 's estate in the rain. There She stayed for weeks with poor health. Elizabeth came to stay with her during this time to bring her comfort.while staying with Jane at Mr. Bingley 's, Elizabeth spent more time with Mr. Darcy and the rest of the inhabitants at the house. During the time Elizabeth was there, Mr. Darcy was slowly growing fond of Elizabeth 's good humor and charm, even though her opinion was not changed and she still thought of him in disgust. Upon returning home, Jane and Elizabeth discover that their cousin,Mr. Collins, who is the potential heir

    Read More

  • The Relationship between Elizabeth and Darcy in Pride and Prejudice

    923 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the 19th century, a controversy arose over what the true foundation and purpose for marriage should be. The basis of this conflict was whether one should let reason or emotion be the guide of their love life and if a balance between the two could be maintained. The relationship between Elizabeth and Darcy in Jane Austen's book Pride and Prejudice depicts such a balance, thus becoming the model for Austen's definition of a perfect couple and for true love. Their relationship is neither solely based on a quest for money on Elizabeth's part or emotions that blind the couple from all other important aspects of life. The significance of having this balance is portrayed through the inability of the other couples in the story to reach an equal amount of happiness as Elizabeth and Darcy because of their pursuit of either reason or passion.

    Read More

  • A Critical Review of Pride and Prejudice

    945 Words  | 2 Pages

    2 Feb. 2010. Moore, Catherine E. “Pride and Prejudice.” Master Revised Second Edition (1996): Literary Reference Center. EBSCO. Web. The Web.

    Read More

More about Choice Vs. Chance in "Pride and Prejudice"

Open Document