Audobon/Dillard Essay

643 Words2 Pages

Individuals have their own unique perception of beauty. In 1813, John James Audubon got to experience the extremely rare phenomenon of seeing incredible masses of pigeons in flight. In 1974, Annie Dillard witnessed a similar occurrence as Audubon, with the exception of the flocks that she came across consisting of starlings. Both writers recorded their engagement with the birds. Both writers also grasped the splendor of the spectacle, expressing it to being “extreme” and “unexpected”. The only occasion that the two writers’ perspectives correspond to each other is their recognition of the beauty that was within the wonder that they witnessed. Although both Audubon and Dillard realize the magnificence of the phenomenon, their general outlook and how they are affected by their experiences differ. Audubon and Dillard hold opposing views in terms of their portrayal of the flocks of birds. Audubon starts is passage off by stating that he “observed” the birds flying in “greater numbers” than he had ever seen in the past. He conveys this first encounter as more of a scientific inquiry, detecting that there is a strangely abundant amount of pigeons in flight altogether. Afterwards, he began to “count” the flocks of birds, making a “dot for every flock that passed”, and stopping after 21 minutes after finding the task he undertook “impracticable.” Audubon attempts to gather quantitative information on the pigeons as a typical objective scientist would do, and the fact that he stopped counting as soon as he felt that it was of no use or reason of doing so anymore proves that Audubon observed the birds objectively. Later on that day, Audubon mentions how he had unsuccessfully ran multiple “trials” to “reach” and “disturb” the birds with his... ... middle of paper ... ...d genuine excitement, although the reasons were still scientific. The birds’ effects on Dillard, on the other hand, contrasted from how the birds had affected Audubon. Throughout her whole encounter with the starlings, Dillard “didn’t move” at all. She was mesmerized from when the birds first appeared to her up until they had wiped out into the woods. As the birds disappeared into the trees, she “stood with difficulty” with her “spread lungs [roaring]” Ultimately, Dillard was appalled by the magnificence of the flocks in flight. Audubon and Dillard’s general outlook of the flocks of birds in flight and how they are affected by their experiences differ. In the end, both writers exhibit their own perception of beauty through their encounter with the birds, although Audubon saw the beauty in factuality, and Dillard saw it in her own interweaved thoughts and emotions.

Open Document