preview

Arguments for Legalizing Gay Marriages

Good Essays
Homosexual Marriage Since 1971 when the first same sex couple Richard John Baker and James Michael McConnell applied for a marriage license and were denied in the Baker vs. Nelson ruling, America has been forced to debate whether homosexuals should be allowed to be married even though they are not the classical definition of a couple. There are many opinions about this subject from government officials, religious leaders and even the president of the United States. Homosexuals should be allowed to be married because they need to be treated fairly and equally. Homosexuals have been denied the right to be married because many people feel, "The union of a man and woman is the most enduring human institution, honored and encouraged in all cultures and by every religious faith" (George W. Bush). Since marriage wasn't clearly defined in our Bill of Rights, The Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) was started. This clearly defined that marriage is "the legal union between one man and one woman" (The Defense of Marriage Act). At present 37 states have DOMA and Super DOMA laws. Now many republicans are pushing for The Marriage Protection Amendment to be added to our constitution. Human right activists say that "this amendment is simply too extreme. It would single out a group of Americans for discrimination, something that the vast majority of Americans are against." (HRC.com). Many states now provide civil unions as an alternative to marriage for homosexuals. While many people are satisfied with these laws because they are protecting the traditional idea of marriage, other people, both homosexuals and heterosexuals are saying that these laws are not only unjust, but unconstitutional. Many people can not understand why homosexuals a... ... middle of paper ... ...tment to each other; it is also a business union that comes with certain stability and benefits. Just because homosexual marriage does not fit in with our traditions doesn't mean it's wrong. Homosexuals are different, but different doesn't mean inferior. Homosexuals want to be treated with the same fairness and equality as everyone no more, no less. Homosexuals should be allowed to be married. It was never stated in our founding documents that marriage was between one man and one woman. It was only after homosexuals wanted the same rights as heterosexuals that DOMA was created. It is clear that homosexuals are not asking for anything extra, they just want fairness. They should not have to petition for these rights. Gay Americans must be extended its rights; Heterosexual America must be made to understand that these rights do not in any way abridge their rights.
Get Access