Arguments Against Mandatory Helmet Laws In The United States

806 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The helmet law debate

Motorcycle Helmets Motorcycle helmet laws have been a controversial topic for decades. Now that the motorcycling community has multiplied many times over, the subject is even more relevant. Motorcycle safety activists, insurance companies and people who have never even been on a motorcycle will argue for State Laws that dictate the use of motorcycle helmets. On the flip side, bikers and avid motorcyclists will argue against those same laws. I am a biker, advocate of motorcycle safety and a very avid motorcyclist who chooses to wear a helmet every time I get on a motorcycle. I do not agree with making mandatory helmet laws. Making safety minded decisions and safe cycling is a decision that has to be made by the rider him or herself. People should not worry about wearing a helmet when riding a motorcycle. According to Steve “Red” Barron, helmets are not safety devices for motorcyclists …show more content…

The AMA believes that adults should have the right to voluntarily decide when to wear a helmet. A person that makes a conscious choice to be safe is very different than one who decides to accept more risk than they can handle. Contrary to popular belief, motorcycle accidents and/or crashes are not prevented by mandatory helmet laws. People riding on a motorcycle should be required by state law to wear a Department of Transportation (DOT) certified helmet. Most recognize that motorcycles are more dangerous than a car or truck. Rider fatality in crashes are up to 30 times higher than that of the average motorist in a car or truck (Davis Law Group P.S., 2016). Yet, in most states, less vulnerable motorists that are protected by steal and safety glass are required by state law to wear a seatbelt. Stricter restraint laws apply to children under a certain age or weight, dependent on the

Show More
Related

  • Sport Safety: Should headgear be made mandatory for all contact sports?

    787 Words  | 2 Pages

    Wearing headgear has many positives, reducing injuries is the most obvious one and it could be argued that its help reduces the chance of injuries and even death. At an elite level, Chelsea goalkeeper, Petr Cech is convinced that wearing headgear saved him from suffering extended injuries after colliding with Fulham striker Orlando Sa back in September 2011. Headgear offers a form of padding when worn. It allows juniors and elite athlete’s the reduced chance of head wounds. By this it means it allows for less “cracked skulls”, scars, wounds and so on. It gives a stronger protection on the softer part of the skull which is more prone to damage...

    Read More

  • Is It Proper to place someone in jail for a seatbelt violation

    1523 Words  | 4 Pages

    In North Carolina, the “Click It or Ticket” program was put into place in 1993 by former Governor Jim Hunt to increase safety belt and child safety use rates through stepped up enforcement of the state’s safety belt law. According to North Carolina’s safety belt law all drivers and front seat passengers over the age of 16 are required to wear safety belts. Children less than age 16 are covered under the North Carolina Child Restraint Law. This law requires that children must be buckled up no matter where they are seated in the vehicle. Violators of the safety belt law are issued tickets and are subject to a fine of $25 plus $50 court costs. These violations have been defined as “infractions” and are not entered on driving records. In addition to this, effective January 1, 2005, any child less than 8 years old or 80 pounds in weight must ride in a booster seat. Violations of this law will result in a $25 fine plus court costs as well as having 2 points placed against driver’s license. However, drivers cited for this violation of this law for a 5,6, or 7 year old will be able to have the charges dismissed if they present proof to the court that they have acquired an appropriate restraint for that child. Statistics have been gathered on safety belt use since this program began and has shown that seat belt use has increased from 65 percent to 84 percent. It has also shown that fatal and serious injuries in North Carolina have been cut by 14 percent. Resulting in a savings of at least $135 million in health care related costs. Other positive ef...

    Read More

  • Bull Riding Case Study

    927 Words  | 2 Pages

    Bull riders face a tremendous risk of injury with each ride on a two-thousand pound bull. There are many different body mechanics involved in the sport of bull riding. Injuries caused by bull riding can be very serious and even life-threatening at times. Protective gear is available for bull riders, if they choose to use it. With this being said, does protective gear help prevent bull riding injuries?

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Ski Helmets

    747 Words  | 2 Pages

    For children in this group, a helmet can save you or reduce the severity of the damage via 53%. The same studies, cited using the US Consumer Product Safety Commission, show a forty-four% prevention and reduction in injury among adults.

    Read More

  • America Needs a Motorcycle Helmet Law

    874 Words  | 2 Pages

    Helmets drastically reduce the tremendous number of deaths caused by head injuries as well as reducing the severity of any ...

    Read More

  • Distracted Driving And Driving Laws: Causes And Consequences

    876 Words  | 2 Pages

    Every person who has gets behind the wheel of a motor vehicle will be involved in some sort of automobile collision at some point in his or her lifetime. Traffic accidents account for over twenty thousand deaths each year and more than ten times as many injuries. There are a number of factors that contribute to these types of collisions, however, new and evolving laws can account for a large portion of successful preventable measures. In order for laws to be changed or added for the purpose of safer roads and highways, lawmakers have to first look at what factors contribute to such unsafe conditions. The top five causes of automobile accidents that cause injury are distracted drivers, driver fatigue, drunk driving, speeding, and aggressive driving. Laws can be proposed to reduce and even eliminate each of these risks.

    Read More

  • Mandating Seat Belt Usage vs. Freedom of Choice

    941 Words  | 2 Pages

    Even though there are some statistics that may show a lower rate of injury or death if you wear a seat belt when in an automobile accident, I do not feel that the government has the right to make wearing a seat belt mandatory for adults because by making seat belts mandatory it takes away from our right to freedom of choice, and wearing a seat belt does not eliminate the risk of injury or death as people have been injured and/or killed due to wearing a seat belt Current seat belt law originated from federal legislation in the 1960s that made it mandatory for all automobile manufacturers to include seat belts in their vehicles as a standard feature. Originally, the purpose of a seat belt was not to protect the occupants in the case of a crash, but rather to physically keep them in the vehicle, as driving was bumpy business. However, in today’s times, mandatory use of a seat belt falls under various states purview. Each state implements its own laws regarding enforcement of seat belt use.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay: Helmet Laws For Motorcyclists

    913 Words  | 2 Pages

    Laws should be developed and enforced requiring motorcyclists to wear helmets, regardless of age or state. Nevertheless, several people would say helmets are not essential. However, research has been done and evidence has been shown that helmets are important for safety and should be mandatory. Meanwhile, others say that making laws on helmets are against human rights and can cause injuries due to the weight of the helmet. Without a helmet law for everyone riding on a motorcycle, unfortunately the world would see more fatal accidents. Making helmet laws mandatory would be beneficial for everyone on the road.

    Read More

  • Helmet In Sports

    1201 Words  | 3 Pages

    While the use of helmets does aid in protecting players from brain trauma, they also increase the risky behavior of players; this is called risk compensation. Risk compensation is the adjustment of individual behavior, responding to the perceived changes in risk (TheFreeDictionary.com). Most people that wear helmets have a pre-conceived idea that, because they have a helmet on, they can possess more daring behaviors and be fine. The helmet is basically thought of as a tool to hit harder, or improve performance in today’s culture. Adventure writer and pilot, Lane Wallace (2011) accurately understands the dangers of helmets being used incorrectly, and how they are used as weapons instead of safety. Wallace also theorizes like the NFL, a change in football culture and of viewpoints towards helmets would vastly reduce trauma to the

    Read More

  • Bike Helmets

    1319 Words  | 3 Pages

    The opponents of helmet laws seem to have a good argument. Helmet use cannot prevent an accident and Department of Transportation statistics indicate seventy five percent of bicycle related deaths are in collisions with motor vehicles (American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons 2), which implies the real problem is with automobile drivers causing accidents with bikes.

    Read More

  • Motorcycle Trauma Case Study

    1205 Words  | 3 Pages

    This paper is being written to identify and provide demographic information on a population that has been through trauma and resiliency following motorcycle accidents. This population has been through some form of trauma whether they realize it or not. Some people deal with trauma differently. For example, many motorcyclists engage in drug and alcohol to feel most comfortable because they face traumatic situations on the road, daily. Many of the traumatic experiences are caused by automotive drivers. According to “Nolo” (2016), Crashes involving motorcycles and other vehicles account for fifty-six percent of motorcycle accident deaths. In the vast majority of these accidents, the car strikes the

    Read More

  • The Importance of Wearing a Seatbelt

    978 Words  | 2 Pages

    Car accidents are the leading cause of death for people under the age of 35. Wearing a seat belt can prevent death in about half of these accidents. Did you know that every 15 seconds someone is injured in an automobile accident if they are not buckled up, or that every 13 minutes someone is killed in a crash. Failure to wear a seat belt contributes to more fatalities than any other single traffic safety related behavior. According to the National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration seatbelts saved nearly 12,000 lives in the United States in the year 2000. The NHTSA estimates that more than 9,000 U.S. car accident fatalities in 2000 would have been avoided if the victims had been wearing seatbelts. Sixty three percent of the people killed in accidents were not wearing seat belts. The NHTSA a...

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Road Safety

    1109 Words  | 3 Pages

    There is a massive amount of car accidents that occur every day, that consequently become fatal. In many cases, the driver and the passengers do not have on a seat belt to prevent them from being thrown out of the car or colliding with another car, causing them to be thrown against the dashboard or some other tragic accident. Some people may think, “Wearing a seatbelt isn’t cool”, “I’m only going down the street” or sometimes just irresponsibly forget to put on their seatbelt when they are inside of a vehicle. You may think that wearing a seatbelt is not trendy and you are only making a quick trip going down the street to the corner store, however, you cannot control others actions on the road anything can happen in the blink of an eye.

    Read More

  • Outline for Bicycle Safety

    667 Words  | 2 Pages

    II.     According to the Bicycle Helmet Safety Institute, bicycle related crashes kill about 900 people a year and injure over half a million. Most bicycle deaths or accidents occur between 3-9 pm, and most often occur during the summer months. We can prevent these numbers by: wearing protective equipment, obeying the rules of the road, and being aware of your surroundings.

    Read More

  • Importance Of Road Safety Essay

    1116 Words  | 3 Pages

    Road safety is one of the most important aspects of daily living. Our vehicle is our main transportation from one place to another. The number of car and motorcycle accidents seem to be increasing because of the many distractions, the lack of safety measures and judgment to road conditions and weather. Not being cautious increases the chances of not only injuring ourselves but hurting others as well. On the road, you see people talking on their cell phones or texting, eating, putting makeup on, changing the radio station, reading or using your GPS while driving. These are all distractions that endanger drivers, passengers and bystanders safety. Safe driving involves off-road precautionary measures such as making sure tires are properly inflated, testing windshield wipers, getting regular oil changes and tune-ups and adjusting the mirrors. All of these actions can help prevent an accident. Unfortunately, not all of us decide to wear our seat belts when driving or turn signal ligh...

    Read More

More about Arguments Against Mandatory Helmet Laws In The United States

Open Document