The Threat of Anne Hutchinson
Seventeenth century England brought about a great deal of religious change. In 1606, when King James came to power, the theology of the Anglican Church drifted towards the idea that individuals could achieve salvation through their actions during life (Wheeler & Becker, 36). The transition to this belief system brought enough controversy to cause one group of reformers to seek a new colony: the Puritans of Massachusetts Bay. Following a more Calvinist theology, this group of people sought to reform the church based on the belief that individuals could not influence the will of God (Lecture, 9/21/15). One of the 14,000 or so puritans who sought out a new life in this new land was Anne Hutchinson. Shortly after her
…show more content…
Their religious beliefs were much different from the beliefs of the rest of the colony, and they were much more forthcoming about their opposition to the belief system of the ministers in Massachusetts. However, they were not exiled until something went blatantly wrong, as when Wheelwright stood up during a lecture and encouraged other members of the church to band together against the corrupt “enemies of Christ” (Wheeler & Becker, 54). In both cases, the men were given chances to reconcile, and they were only banished reluctantly. While these were the only two names mentioned by Becker & Wheelwright, there were probably countless others who continually broke laws to a much higher degree than Anne did. Wheelwright’s actions are probably the most paralleled to Anne’s. Since Mrs. Hutchinson was harboring members with different religious ideas, she was seen as the leader of said group. Similarly, Wheelwright was calling on others to follow him in his own belief system. The only difference, however, is that Wheelwright blatantly called other ministers and authorities “enemies of Christ,” making him a more direct threat to the colony. Why, then, did the court feel justified to treat Anne with less fairness and respect than the men who came before …show more content…
Today, scholars study history, and from the past can analyze the importance of change. During that time, however, it was common for people to feel like life would never change (Lecture, 9/14/15). This means that even small actions can pose a great threat for a new colony such as Massachusetts Bay. So even though Anne may not have taken the largest actions, she was a leader of change. She defied the expectations that puritan leaders had for the women at the time, and her role in society was so different from the norm that leaders saw her as a potential threat. Because of this, the court felt empowered to put her to trial which would lead to her eventual excommunication and
The Church of England was not a good religion during the sixteenth century, the puritans want to practice their own religion but the Church of England would not allow them. People didn’t want to obey the churches authority anymore. The Puritans it particular did not want to follow the Church of England. Over time, “the church of England began to crack down on those who refused to bow to their authority” (www3.gettysburg.edu) this caused the Puritans to leave England. The puritans left England and went on a dangerous journey to be free from the church. It was so bad that, “it got to the point where the puritans decided to face the dangerous journey to the New World rather than be persecuted for their religion” (www3.gettysburg.edu) these people would rather put their lives and families in danger than to be put down by the Church of England. There were ranks inside the church and women were at the bottom.
Anne Marbury Hutchinson was the second born child of a Cambridge educated, outspoken Anglican preacher named Francis Marbury. She was born at a time when he was openly quarrelling with church leaders about their "catholic tendencies" and the selection of "ill-educated Bishops that in turn chose poorly trained ministers" (LaPlante, p. 33). Francis was eventually put on trial and accused of being a Puritan. He won his trial but was removed from his church and sentenced to be at home. This time was to have a big impact on the lives of his children, especially Anne.
In the 1700’s the Puritans left England for the fear of being persecuted. They moved to America for religious freedom. The Puritans lived from God’s laws. They did not depend as much on material things, and they had a simpler and conservative life. More than a hundred years later, the Puritan’s belief toward their church started to fade away. Some Puritans were not able to recognize their religion any longer, they felt that their congregations had grown too self-satisfied. They left their congregations, and their devotion to God gradually faded away. To rekindle the fervor that the early Puritans had, Jonathan Edwards and other Puritan ministers led a religious revival through New England. Edwards preached intense sermons that awakened his congregation to an awareness of their sins. With Edwards’ sermon, “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” he persuades the Puritans to convert back to Puritanism, by utilizing rhetorical strategies such as, imagery, loaded diction, and a threatening and fearful tone.
Literary historicism, in the context of this discussion, describes the interpretation of literary or historical texts with respect to the cultural and temporal conditions in which they were produced. This means that the text not only catalogues how individuals respond to their particular circumstances, but also chronicles the movements and inclinations of an age as expressed in the rhetorical devices of its literature. Evaluating the trial of Anne Hutchinson within such a theoretical framework means speculating on the genesis of her theological beliefs with recourse to prevailing theories of gender, class, and interpretation. Because texts are self-contained spheres of discourse, nuanced interpretations of them can be undertaken with greater assiduity than in the case of individuals whose private experiences remain largely concealed from the interpreter's knowledge. A historical analysis of Anne Hutchinson herself is hence, in the present discussion, secondary to the analysis of how she comes across in textual discourse as a palimpsest of seventeenth century gender controversy.
A Puritan lawyer, John Winthrop, immigrated to New England because his views on religion were different from those in England. Even though Puritans are Protestants, Puritans tried to purify the English Church. In 1630 on board of the Arabella on the Atlantic Ocean on way to Massachusetts, he wrote “A Model of Christian Charity” which gave his views on what a society should be. ‘…the condition of mankind, [that] in all times some must be rich, some poor, some high and eminent in power and dignity, other mean and in subjection….[Yet] we must knit together in this work as one man.’ (Doc. A). In this he is saying that men may be different but to make a new world work, they must work together. All through his speech he mentions God. For example, he opens his sermon with ‘God Almighty in his most holy and wise providence…’. This shows that in New England, the people were very religious.
How was Anne Hutchinson's trial an ordeal for her and how was it an ordeal for
For instance, she fought with Henry many times for the sake of Elizabeth, and the most important is that she chose death so that her daughter would have a better life. Anne was a very respectable character for the most part. She was unselfish in the end, choosing to die for the sake of her daughter. She tried to stand up for herself as a woman in a male-dominated society. Though she did not succeed in the end, she made a strong point that she would not be controlled by anyone but herself.
Rebecca Nurse was known to all as a saintly woman. She followed God with all her heart, soul, mind, and strength. The Lord was her savior and protector. But because of mass hysteria, Mrs. Nurse was incriminated of exploiting witchcraft. This aghast most people because the most religious person they knew had been a witch. This was false. Rebecca Nurse was not a witch and had not demonstrated witchcraft by any means. She was innocent. She, like John Proctor, was solicited by Reverend Hale to confess but to no avail. Rebecca Nurse had held an immaculate reputation, and she was not about to let it get defamed by some false accusation. Rebecca Nurse, again like John Proctor, was hung for her falsely accused treacherous actions. This again is a prime example of what people will go through in order to keep a reputation that is accepted by
An outspoken female in a male hierarchy, Hutchinson had little hope that many would speak in her defense, and she was being tried by the General Court. In 1636 she was charged with hersey and banished from Massachusetts Bay Colony. Several years later, when she moved to New York, she was killed in an Indian attack. Anne challenged the Puritan clergy. She believed that: "1.One can feel one's salvation and is filled with the spirit of God after conversion.
The church and Christian beliefs had a very large impact on the Puritan religion and lifestyle. According to discovery education, “Church was the cornerstone of the mainly Puritan society of the 17th century.”( Douglas 4). Puritan laws were intensively rigid and people in society were expected to follow a moral strict code. And because of Puritans and their strict moral codes, any act that was considered to go against this code was considered a sin and deserved to be punished. In Puritan theology, God h...
In 1630, the Massachusetts Bay Company set sail to the New World in hope of reforming the Church of England. While crossing the Atlantic, John Winthrop, the puritan leader of the great migration, delivered perhaps the most famous sermon aboard the Arbella, entitled “A Model of Christian Charity.” Winthrop’s sermon gave hope to puritan immigrants to reform the Church of England and set an example for future immigrants. The Puritan’s was a goal to get rid of the offensive features that Catholicism left behind when the Protestant Reformation took place. Under Puritanism, there was a constant strain to devote your life to God and your neighbors. Unlike the old England, they wanted to prove that New England was a community of love and individual worship to God. Therefore, they created a covenant with God and would live their lives according to the covenant. Because of the covenant, Puritans tried to abide by God’s law and got rid of anything that opposed their way of life. Between 1630 and the 18th century, the Puritans tried to create a new society in New England by creating a covenant with God and living your life according to God’s rule, but in the end failed to reform the Church of England. By the mid 1630’s, threats to the Puritans such as Roger Williams, Anne Hutchinson, and Thomas Hooker were being banned from the Puritan community for their divergent beliefs. 20 years later, another problem arose with the children of church members and if they were to be granted full membership to the church. Because of these children, a Halfway Covenant was developed to make them “halfway” church members. And even more of a threat to the Puritan society was their notion that they were failing God, because of the belief that witches existed in 1692.
They were rebellious, even though they were watched closely by their masters and were isolated from each other. Throughout history, many women tried to change the role of women in society. For example, Anne Hutchinson was a religious woman that opposed the church fathers of the Massachusetts Bay Colony by saying "that she, and other ordinary people, could interpret the Bible for themselves." She started to hold big meetings for women (and even a few men came) to hear her criticize local ministers. She was put on trial twice for two separate reasons, but she still stood her ground. The first trial was by the church for heresy and the other was by the government for questioning their authority. Eventually, she was banished in 1638 from the colony. However, this didn 't stop future women from trying to gain independence from traditional values and
This was a common concern at the time, seeing as the Puritans had sailed across the Atlantic Ocean and were free from the influence of the Catholic Church for the first time. Life in the colonies was difficult and it led to questioning, such as Bradstreet’s, to surface as people asked themselves if they were making the right choice by seceding from the Catholic Church. After all, “They have the same God, the same Christ, the same word. They only enterpret it one way, we another.” (Bradstreet 164). This, however, does not convince Bradstreet that the move to the New World was a mistake. She unveils a harsh criticism, writing “but the vain fooleries that are in their religion together with their lying miracles and cruel persecutions” are enough for her to discredit the argument, stating that the Catholic Church is unquestionably wrong in her mind (Bradstreet 164). Though she admits that their teachings “hath sometimes stuck with me, and more it would,” she still reassures herself that she trusts the theology of the Puritans and remains strong in the consensus of those in the Massachusetts Bay area that firmly resist the dogma of the Catholic Church (Bradstreet
In the next and final part when Anne starts talking about the scripture god revealed to her. In the middle she says: “but after he was pleased to reveal himself to me”, “He” being god. That was kind of like the icing on the cake. What got John Winthrop really mad was the fact that Anne said that god was pleased to reveal himself to her this is a big part because Anne is a woman and women are looked down upon in their society. The way Anne acted during her trail compiled with the fact she was a woman and her claim of personal revelation sealed her ticket out of Massachusetts Bay. As I have said before this case shows Annes fiery spirit and her willingness to rebel against oppressors. This document is very important, it shows the “chain of respect” if you could say. It shows that men believed to be superior to women and above them as well.
The “Trial of Anne Hutchinson” written on 1637, was during the period where women are to subject to the man. Hutchinson being a woman did affect her trial. This is seen in the trial with Governor John Winthrop. He mentioned that she had done things that are not “fitting” for her sex. Not only did she get into trouble with the churches, who were headed by man, but was also accused for promoting her opinions that salvation is God’s gift that does not need to be earned. On the other hand from John Winthrop’s “Speech to the Massachusetts General Court” in July 3, 1645, he describes about two kinds of liberty, natural and moral. “Natural” liberty was liberty to do good or evil; it is based on one’s opinion. This form of liberty is less inconsistent