Analysis of Gender Essay by Myra Jehlen

905 Words2 Pages

In her essay “Gender” Myra Jehlen analyze the concept of gender in relation to literature. She explores the notion of sexual identity, specifically conceptions of masculinity and femininity. She first expresses two different ways of thinking about the nature of gender: as natural or as cultural. After introducing readers to these two major perspectives, Jehlen discusses the relationship of gender and sex. Ultimately, through her examination of the ideology of gender, Jehlen represents gender as a performance, which she both emphasizes and rationalizes through her reading of Huck Finn. In introducing readers to the nature/nurture debate of gender, Jehlen supports the Nurture side. She explains that the dominant view of gender is that it is natural (264). This essentialist view holds that gender is “rooted in biology”, that it is inherent (264). In contrast, there is an alternative perspective (i.e. nurture) that has been gaining popularity. This view holds that gender is not biologically based, but rather it is a cultural construct that is socially learned (264). In other words, gender is a category and the characteristics attributed to this social category are culturally/socially defined. Speaking in the context of literature, Jehlen states that “the character conventionally assigned men and women in novels reflect history and culture rather than nature . . . [they] are neither timeless or transcendent” (264). In other words, conceptualizations of gender in literature are situated in a culture and historical context ; the context out of which a work of literature emerges molds the interpretation of gender in that work. Given that literature is a form of symbolic culture, that it has culture within it as much as... ... middle of paper ... ...hink more critically about gender when reading literary texts, for them to also come to find new and unobvious definitions/conceptualizations of gender. Jehlen does not only call into question conceptualizations of gender. She offers a fresh perspective on the concept, arguing that gender is a cultural performance. Her careful reading of this scene from Huck Finn, examining of an array of gender related dichotomies (nurture/nature, culture/nature, man/woman, masculine/feminine, etc.) and Huck’s identity in flux demonstrate her argument. Her argument for gender as a performance offers a new conceptualization of the term/concept, and it also helps to show that the concept is indeed relevant to texts that are not commenting directly on gender (such as Huck Finn). Overall, Myra Jehlen’s representation of gender adds a new layer to the conversation on gender.

Open Document