Analysis Of Carmen By Georges Bizet

706 Words2 Pages

The synopsis of the opera Carmen by Georges Bizet is about a woman named Carmen. She is introduced with a song about the natural of love Habanera. She is surrounded by men, which plead with her to choose a lover, but end up throwing a flower at José who shows no interest in her. José is engaged Micaela, whom his mothers approve of. She brought him a letter from his mother saying she wants him to hurry up and marry Micaela. First, José finally decides to heed to his mother request, then Carmen reveals her affection for him by throwing a flower to him. Carmen has committed a crime, she attacks women with a knife. Jose ties her hands, but later to release her because she sings a song that mesmerized him.
For this reason, José is arrested for disobeying orders and is …show more content…

Unknowing to him, she has already moved on to Escamillo. He begs her and pleaded with her. Carmen rejected him. Overwhelm by his emotion, and he stabs her. Additionally, he sings her name out loud in sorrow.
Similarly, Carmen resemble Nedda in I Pagliacci. Both operas are about love and passion that ended tragically.First, Nedda is a woman who was in an abusive relationship with her alcoholic husband who loves her passionately. Nedda was in a relationship out of fear because her husband says that if she ever tries to cheat on him. He will kill her. Nedda and Carmen has a sort of seductive way, and this seduction attracts unwanted and wanted attention.
Second, Nedda cheated on her husband and got caught, but try to hide the identity of the man she cheated with. Her husband ends up killing her then killing her partner in crime by stabbing them both. The difference is Nedda is an adulterer and Carmen is an assaulter. The reason why the committed such act places them in a difficult situation. When it comes to Nedda, the audience sympathizes with her than at a time do not. Not to mention, it’s hard to decide rather she is a hero or she is a bad

Open Document