Analysis: A Perfect Day For Bananafish

1024 Words3 Pages

The sight of a person’s best friend dying before their eyes because they accidentally took one step too far is horrifying. Or their friend was far too brave and marched onto a slaughtering trap that leaves nightmares for decades. Realizing that in the front lines, no one can be trusted to protect anyone will make a person paranoid, even when they’ve come back to their warm families. There are sights caused by the evils of humanity that one cannot forget in the acts of war and terrorism. Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is common among war veterans, leaving them detached from society. Seymour Glass in A Perfect Day for Bananafish shows signs of PTSD and depression through his poor relationship with Muriel and her family, his inclination …show more content…

He finds their innocence endearing and comforting in comparison to adults who are “victims of their own gluttony” (Cotter). His conversation with Sybil shows how his mind works similarly like a child, mimicking their simple and honest thoughts through his preferences in swimsuit colors. However, they share a conversation that remind the audience that Seymour isn’t a child himself when he indirectly picks at Sybil for bullying a dog and compares her to Sharon who is nice and doesn’t poke at dogs. His story about bananafish has Sybil thinking that whatever she saw in the water were the very same creatures from the tale. Seymour falls for her naivety and kisses her foot out of gratitude because “she shares his non-materialistic view” …show more content…

When placed in a setting with another adult, he is paranoid. He views people as “bananafish that are overly greedy” and made an assumption that a woman is staring at his feet then calls her a “sneak” since he believes that she was doing it in secrecy. “Seymour is literally fed up with the nauseous phoniness of those around him” (Cotter) and would react in loud outburst that is unacceptable in a social environment. Though the women protests that she was not staring at his feet, she is put off by his attitude towards her and makes a quick leave. To Seymour, it must have seemed like she was embarrassed that she was “caught” and only reinforced his beliefs. Right after her exit, he claims to have “two normal feet”, but in reality he is very insecure about them for reasons most likely related to his traumatizing experiences in the war.

Open Document