Adorno and Horkheimer's Dialectic of Enlightenment

3203 Words7 Pages

Adorno and Horkheimer's Dialectic of Enlightenment

'Myth is already enlightenment; and enlightenment reverts to mythology'

(Dialectic of Enlightenment XVI)

Adorno and Horkheimer's obscure and nihilistic text Dialectic of Enlightenment (DoE) is an attempt to answer the question 'why mankind, instead of entering a truly human condition, is sinking into a new kind of barbarism' (DoE, p.xi). The result is a totalising critique of modernity; a diagnosis of why the Enlightenment project failed with no attempt to prescribe a cure. This is achieved by a historical-philosophical study of the mythic world-view of animism and anthropomorphism and the Enlightenment attempt to dissolve myth through objectification and instrumental reason. DoE also uses Homer's Odyssey as a metaphorical interpretation of this historical change, where Odysseus is the prototype of the bourgeois man.

This study reveals for Adorno and Horkheimer the failure of the Enlightenment project. Enlightenment has no claim to being less a myth than the mythology it failed to escape. This new myth is defined for them by the drive to dominate nature at the expense of alienation of man from nature and from his own inner nature. They follow the appearance of the subject as it is objectified alongside nature, and is dominated with it. The subject becomes an object and his intellect becomes instrumental, and all instinct and sensory experience that fails to be productive in the pursuit of domination is repressed, man becomes mechanized. They also assert that class domination is a direct and inevitable consequence of the attempt to dominate nature, and is therefore inescapable.

Background to the text.

Adorno and Horkheimer, members of the Frankfurt school in Germany, wrote DoE (which was completed in 1944) while Fascism, a kind of barbarism never seen before, was threatening Europe. They viewed this as the epitome of the self-destructive nature of enlightenment, the final evidence that it would never result in 'a truly human condition'. They wrote in the introduction to DoE that 'the indefatigable self-destructiveness of enlightenment…requires philosophy to discard even the last vestiges of innocence in regard to the habits and tendencies of the spirit of the age' (p.xi), hence the intensity of their critique.

Being part of the Frankfurt school, Adorno and Horkheimer were influenced...

... middle of paper ...

...kfurt school, does not accept Adorno's solution. He believes Adorno is being too nihilistic in [continued next page] allowing no way to escape instrumental rationality. Habermas's main philosophical project has been to resolve this problem, to allow for the possibility of substantive rationality (i.e. rationality that is not aimed at power and domination but, rather, validity) and, thus, to save the project of the Enlightenment. The result is a theory of open communication that is aimed at an 'ideal speech situation', that is, at a discourse not tainted by instrumental aims.

Bibliography:

Theodor Adorno and Maw Horkheimer: The Dialectic of Enlightenment (Verso: London, 1997).

Theodor Adorno: Negative Dialectics (Routledge: London, 1990)

Jurgen Habermas: The Entwinement of Myth and Enlightenment: Re-reading Dialectic of Enlightenment, in Jay Bernstein (ed.): The Frankfurt School: Critical Assessments vol.3 (Routledge: London, 1994).

Axel Honneth: The Critique of Power: Reflective Stages of Critical Social Theory (M.I.T: Boston, 1991).

Göran Therborn: The Frankfurt School, in New Left Review (ed.): Western Marxism: a Critical Reader (New Left Books: Norfolk, 1977).

Show More
Related

  • Self Discovery In Frankenstein

    937 Words  | 2 Pages

    Experiencing a mental state where the world appears at odds is not a foreign idea: feelings of isolation, persecution, and unhappiness with society. Nevertheless, the journey to self-discovery does not adhere to a universal guideline. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Jean-Jaques Rousseau’s Reveries of the Solitary Walker explore how experiences with exile shape attitudes towards society and nature. However, through a comparative analysis of the texts, their difference lie in the positive and negative impacts of forced and voluntary exile; Rousseau’s self-imposed isolation is enriching while the creature’s forced exile is second-rate. This essay seeks to examine the implications of solidarity and how it impacts their journeys to self-discovery.

    Read More

  • Comparing The Social Contract And The Leviathan

    1688 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Social Contract and the Leviathan by Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Thomas Hobbes, respectively, contextualizes man’s struggle to escape a brutish, short life within the state of nature. Man is confined in a lawless world where the words mine and thine are interchangeable, and where there is no regard for private possession; this indifference even extends to the right over someone’s body. And while there are those who revel in freedom from the synthetic chains of law, the reality of life in the state of nature- a life of constant war and distrust for one’s neighbor- trumps any short lived joys or monetary gains. Although it may seem like there is no hope for man in this state, Hobbes and Rousseau presents us with a way to escape this tragic

    Read More

  • Landscape Technician

    410 Words  | 1 Pages

    Compliance with all safety regulations of assigned tasks, and ensure a clean and safe working environment with active participation in the health and safety program

    Read More

  • Abigail Adams: Foundation of American Feminist Revolution

    1835 Words  | 4 Pages

    Beginning in 1654, the idea of Republican motherhood became a central theme in the social milieu. Republican motherhood stressed that the daughters of the patriots should be raised to uphold republican ideals, including liberty, patriotism, independence, and self-sacrifice, in their own families. Women, as housewives and caretakers of the family, could then pass on these notions to their sons and strengthen them in their husbands (Kennedy, Cohen, and Bailey). Although Republican motherhood technically relegated women to the domestic sphere, it nevertheless placed a strong emphasis on their education. Women had to be schooled in virtue so that they could pass these values onto their children. In one of John Adams letters to Abigail, he tells her that nothing is “more honorable for a woman, than to contribute…to the formation of an husband, a brother, or a son”

    Read More

  • Breaking Chains: My Enlightenment Journey from Catholic Church

    1149 Words  | 3 Pages

    The word enlightenment can mean different things to different people. But according to Immanuel Kant, enlightenment is when a person grows out of his or her self-imposed immaturity.  He defines it by saying, “Immaturity as one 's inability to use their own understanding without the guidance of another”(Kant, 1). Having our reason instead of following the in the footsteps of people who influence us. Also, that people impose immaturity on themselves because they fear the use of their own understanding without someone else 's help. In this essay, I will argue my own immaturity that I had with the church, showing how t being brought up in the Catholic Church can inflict this kind of immaturity without knowing, with issues arising that helped me see past my own immaturity, and the transformation of breaking out into my own enlightenment.

    Read More

  • American freedom

    886 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Revolutionary War had a major effect politically on the Colonists, mainly the women. Prior to the war, women lacked all rights; they were expected to cook, clean, and raise families. However, after the revolution, women began to gain more rights. Women gained the power to be able to divorce their husbands if they chose to, something they never could have done before. “The expansion of the public sphere during the era of the Revolution offered women an opportunity to take part in political discussions, and read newspaper¬”(On The Equality of the Sexes (1790), 154). After the revolution women were allowed to join conversations that had to do with politics, they were given the right to educate themselves about the government by reading the daily paper. During American Revolution, some women fought alongside the men while other women helped injured soldiers regain their health. The actions taken by the women caused the ideas about women to change after the war, even The Revolution was accompanied by dramatic changes in the lives of women. Before the Revolution, many women were involved in campaigns to boycott British imports. During the war, many women made items for the war effort and ran farms and businesses in the absence of their husbands. After the Revolution, American women, for the fir...

    Read More

  • Napoleon - an enlightened despot

    1003 Words  | 3 Pages

    13 Dec. 2004. Gay, Peter. The Enlightenment: An Interpretation. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1996. Kreis, Steven.

    Read More

  • Revolutionary Ideology And Women's Rights

    955 Words  | 2 Pages

    During the American Revolution period, women were inferior or subordinate to men in all aspects. Women did not receive the same educational opportunities as men, all unmarried women required male guardianship, and women had no legal rights. During the early part of the American Revolution, John Adams, a representative for Massachusetts in the Continental Congress, and his wife, Abigail Adams, corresponded with each other through written letters between the periods March 31st, 1776 through May 4th, 1776. Abigail urged John, and members of the Continental Congress, to remember women when drafting laws for the new United States. She pointed out to her husband that men should not have unlimited power

    Read More

  • The Nature of Existence and the Existence of Nature

    1633 Words  | 4 Pages

    Kant, Immanuel. “An Answer to the Question: What is Enlightenment?”. The Longman Anthology Of World Literature Vol D 2nd Edition. April Alliston. Pearson, 2009. 599-604. Print

    Read More

  • Enlightenment In Franz Kafka's A Report To An Academy

    1320 Words  | 3 Pages

    Franz Kafka’s short story “A Report to an Academy” follows the story of an ape named Rotpeter who is forcibly removed from his homeland and transitions to living as a human. Rotpeter’s journey is symbolic of the journey of the ordinary human towards enlightenment. First, he is ignorant, then he is forcibly awoken from his former state, then he must work hard at first to begin his journey to enlightenment. The latter progression from semi-enlightened to mostly-enlightened is easier than the initial parts of the journey, but for Kafka, enlightenment is impossible to fully attain. He showcases this with the “tickling at the heels” (Kafka 3) that “everyone on earth feels” (3); this “tickling” (3) is the lingering unenlightenment that haunts everyone and threatens to return at any moment. Kafka uses the story of Rotpeter to show that no one can ever completely achieve a state of enlightenment.

    Read More

  • Praxis In Nursing

    1191 Words  | 3 Pages

    65). To some, this may be seen as problem-solving, but it goes beyond that. “Emancipatory knowing requires seeing the larger picture and correcting social processes, patterns, and structures that create social inequities and injustice” (Chinn & Kramer, 2010, p. 67). This means that as nurse, you are able to step back, see the whole picture, and reevaluate your perceptions. By reevaluating your perceptions, inequalities and injustices are uncovered. “When what has not been perceived before is seen, it then seems to become perfectly obvious. Ways to effectively change the situation begin to make sense, and praxis occurs” (Chinn & Kramer, 2010, p.

    Read More

  • Rousseau and Marx: Property and Inequality

    1831 Words  | 4 Pages

    Marx, Karl, Friedrich Engels, and Robert C. Tucker. The Marx-Engels reader. 2nd ed. New York: Norton, 1978. Print.

    Read More

  • The High Enlightenment and the Low-Life of Literature

    2167 Words  | 5 Pages

    Today, as historians look at the enlightenment they look at it through the eyes of the great thinkers.“The philosophic spirit itself took refuge in the writings of some great men”(D’Alembert,7).They helped create knowledge in how it is viewed today. However, the question remians what is the category that these men fall into. There are many different names and definitions of what these men can be called and who qualifies to fit in this group. It is said that many of the men that were classified in the category were not actual philosopher thinkers that expanded the mind and challenged thought. In the essay “The High Enlightenment and the Low-Life of Literature” by Robert Darnton he discuses the status of these philosophes that were being produced during the High Enlightenment. He argues that “the summit view of eighteenth-century intellectual history has been described so often and so well that it might be useful to strike out in a new direction, to try to get to the bottom of the Enlightenment, and try to penetrate into its underworld...from below”(Darnton,57). He decides to look at the status of the enlightenment thinkers during this time to see the social standing that they had and the influence upon the world around them, not from the overall philosophes. Not from their works that were produced or the social responses to them; from the actual men of letters themselves.Darnton criticizes other historians for having looked at the Enlightenment “only through the eyes of this elite and proposes that, instead, we examine it from the perspective of those who failed to break into this closed elite of ‘literary aristocrates’”(Who were the Philosophes, 44).

    Read More

  • The 21st Century Enlightenment

    750 Words  | 2 Pages

    The 21st Century Enlightenment is a tribute to the 18th century founders of society and the inspiring pioneering spirit. It talks about RSA role and how it performs as an organization. The RSA debates the ideas and values that transform the world to being sufficient to solving the challenges that the world faces and new ways of thinking more influential. The RSA focus is to get the world to embrace core principles of autonomy, universalism and humanism, restoring dimensions to seeing new ways to fulfilling new ideas, society committing to stimulating new thinking, social innovation, and powerful ethos of collaboration (RSA, 2010). Enlightenment has shaped modern values, norms, and lifestyles.

    Read More

  • The Age of Enlightment

    1517 Words  | 4 Pages

    The term “Enlightenment” carries with it many different connotations. Most commonly it can be described as a movement towards some type of ultimate insight or awareness, emphasizing reason and individualism rather than tradition. In the 17th century what were once considered some of the most powerful of the social systems, law and politics, were critically rejected and the powers of reason and scientific research were embraced. Along with this shift came a break with tradition and an adoption of a critical stance in regards to modern reality. Kant’s response to this question of enlightenment set the stage for countless arguments on the true meaning of this mysterious concept, and additionally marked a critical point in our existence. This notion that we as humans must obtain Enlightenment was something Kant truly believed in, but his suggestions as to how we obtain this were somewhat controversial and contentious. Nevertheless, his goal was clear. First, people must break free from the “guardians” who regulate the ways in which we think, and second we must illuminate the path so as to light the way for others to follow. This notion of our essential Enlightenment is exactly why Foucault uses the term “blackmail”, because in his eyes there is no need to be for or against Enlightenment. To him the most important aspect of Enlightenment, is that Enlightenment itself is examined as a whole. What Foucault really wants us to do is take a step back, and truly dissect the foundations of autonomy that we seemed to have built many of our structures upon. It is necessary that we draw our own conclusions of Enlightenment based s...

    Read More

More about Adorno and Horkheimer's Dialectic of Enlightenment

Open Document