A Rhetorical Analysis Of 'Proficiency' By Shannon Nichols

1211 Words3 Pages

In “Proficiency” Shannon Nichols explains her experience with taking the ninth grade proficiency test and how it has altered her love for writing. Shannon Nichols was an honor roll student throughout elementary and middle school who never received anything below a 3.0 GPA and loved writing just as much as she loved math. In March of her eight grade year, Shannon Nichols had to complete the ninth grade proficiency test which determines whether a student receives their diploma. She was smart and she knew it which lead her to assume she would, without a doubt, pass every section of her test. She felt the test was challenging, but had confidence she had passed. To her surprise she passed every section excluding one, writing. She could not understand how she could have possibly failed. “How could I have screwed up writing? I surely spelled every word correctly, used good grammar, and even used big words in the proper context. How could I have failed?” exclaimed Nichols. Ultimately, she got over it. She continued her honors English class and passed with an A. By October she felt she was …show more content…

In the article Rick Diguette explain why he considers teaching college English a battle. He discusses the attitudes and behaviors he has witnessed with college students. The battle is largely fought against bad habits such as misspelling. Students were often told to not worry about the spelling but to express themselves. Professors also encounter the whining behavior. This behavior is associated with students who feel and believe that they have received a grade lower than the grade they believe is deserved. Another behavior they experience is the confidence barrier that freshman students have. Students who believe they were more than good at writing papers enter college with the same attitude, and they resist if a professor attempts to tell these students

Open Document