Compare And Contrast A & P And Railway Club Blues

1073 Words3 Pages

Empathy is when a person tries to get down to help and understand another person that needs help whereas sympathy is where a person just looks and feels bad or jealous by judging at the surface of another person’s behaviour and appearance. In “A&P” and “Railway Club Blues”, the behaviour and fashion differences in youth demonstrate the contrast between the older and younger generations. Also, the older generation often feel empathy rather than sympathy to the the younger generation because they see themselves in the the younger generations. Lastly, the results of feeling empathy towards the younger generation are either the younger generation accepting or rejecting the older generation. As a result, In "A&P"and “Railway Club Blues”, the authors …show more content…

In "A&P" and "Railway Club Blues", the authors used contrast to illustrate the difference between the youth of the older generation and younger generation. In the short story "A&P", Lengel the manager shows that he is anxious, disappointed not content when he repeated “this isn’t the beach” twice while giving a “Sunday school superintendent stare” to the girls that wearing bathings suits in a grocery store because the tennagers in his days were not as wild as the girls. Also, Lengel’s disappointment was because of the girl’s lax behaviour and still think what they are doing is not wrong. On the other hand, in " "Railway Club Blues", the protagonist compared his youth as “simple punks [with] drapes and duck-ass hair” as to the teenagers with “shaven heads and crests of orange hair” on the train. The protagonist also mentions that they were “the heroes for another year” as to teens on the train that think they are now the current heroes. The authors of both “A&P” and “Railway Club Blues” used contrast by comparing the behaviours and …show more content…

When the “decently dressed” Lengel tried to tell the girls to be “decently dressed” because the girls were wearing “bathing suits”, the girls first argued they “are decent” and left because the girls thought what they were doing was not wrong since they have different perspective than Lengel. The result of feeling empathy for the younger generation in "Railway Club Blues" is that the older generation saw the younger generation as themselves and the protagonist mentioned that teens were the “Strange children of the simple punks we were”. Also, despite of the younger teens “clothes are odd [and] their attitudes obscure”, the protagonist saw their faces that gave him “a kindred memory” of how the teens “repeat the ancient dance”. Ultimately, because the two generations were able to enjoyed a small jazz performance together, the protagonist felt “all cardboard boundaries are erased.”. Both authors used contrast to show the results of feeling empathy for the younger generation, and in “A&P”, the result of Lengel feeling empathy for the teenagers is that he was rejected by the youth due to their contrasting perspectives. When the protagonist from “Railway Club Blues” felt the “boundaries are erased” when the music began to play, this demonstrates how the the protagonist felt how everyone shared the same feelings and empathize the teens despite

Open Document