The perception of religion is different for everyone and for the grandmother in the story, “A Good Man is Hard to Find”, being a lady with good Christian values was how she defined herself. The grandmother’s innocence of the evil existing in the world cost her and her family their lives. The story “Cathedral” however, has a more positive outlook on faith. The narrator, “Bub”guided by a blind man named Robert was able to visualize and draw a picture of a cathedral, without really knowing what one was. This essay will examine how the outcomes of both stories were affected by the beliefs of those involved.
The grandmother’s views good/bad was based on how she was raised. Her family was good because they were white, attended church and believed in Jesus Christ. Understanding the true concept of Christianity is another story. During her final moments of life, this grandmother had doubts about her faith (O’Connor 1203).
What put this family into the clutches of the Misfit when they should have been heading to Florida? It was another case of the grandmother getting her own way. Bailey had no intention of stopping anywhere, but a story about an old plantation got the older children begging to see it, so he turned back just to shut everyone up. Pitty Sing, the grandmother’s cat jumped up on Bailey’s neck as he was driving down the dirt road, causing their car to roll into a ditch. (1196-1197). As luck would have it, the Misfit and his two buddies were right in the area.
After watching her family being led into the woods and hearing gunshots, the desperate grandmother tried to save herself. She called upon Jesus and tried to use every trick she could think of, including telling the Misfit, “You’ve got good b...
... middle of paper ...
...his is a defining moment for Bub; he realized that Robert helped him see how blind he had been to the blessings in his life up to this point.
Bub was amazed at the image he and Robert created. Bub was convinced that he knew nothing about cathedrals or art, and he had just learned differently (575). Bub had been shown that all is not as it appears in life. Roberts’s faith in Bub had made him accomplish something he never even imagined.
Both stories show the power of faith. Robert had faith that Bub could demonstrate a cathedral for him and so it happened. The Misfit was able to murder a family because of his belief in his own persecution, which justified his actions. Faith is the conviction of a person’s ideals. These ideals can sometimes accomplish wonderful things like the cathedral drawing or a horrible event like the murder of an entire family.
In Flannery O’Connor’s short story A Good Man is Hard to Find, there are two main characters whose faith should be analyzed: “the grandmother” and “the Misfit”. We can use Paul Tilloch’s six components to analyze their faith. The grandmother seems to have a great understanding of what faith is in five of the
Not long after being on the dirt road the grandmother recalls a “…horrible thought…” that sent shock waves through her feet scaring “… Pity Sing the cat [, and causing it to] spr[ing] onto Baileys shoulder”(O’connor.428). Bailey not long after loses control of the car and crashes them into a ditch flipping the car a couple times. The author noting that “The horrible thought she had had before the accident was that the house she had remembered so vividly was not in Georgia but in Tennessee”(O’connor.428). The authors insight on the grandmother allows the reader to fully understand the grandmothers selfishness and inability to admit she was ever wrong in anything she did. It is not long after the foreshadowing catches up to the helpless family stranded in the midst of nowhere as a strange car slowly approaches them with three men in it. The grandmothers outspokenness is once again continued as she made it vocally known that she recognizes the misfit as one of the men. It is at that moment the misfit says “…it would have been better for all of you, lady, if you hadn 't of reckernized me”(O’connor.429). The reader can conclude the fate of the family at this point and lay blame everything that has happened on the grandmother. Soon after killing the rest of her family the grandmothers social order begins to vividly and rapidly change as she tells the misfit to “pray” and even tells him “…you’re one of my babies. You 're one of my own children”(O’connor.432-433). The reader can now see the grandmothers transformation as she lives the last couple minutes of her life she talks about Jesus, and even considering the misfit to be a “…good man at heart”(O’connor.430). Not long after the grand mother is shot through her chest several times and is carried into the woods and placed next to the rest of her
This unnamed character feels superior and far more knowledgeable to that of the rest of her family while truth behold, she is just as manipulative, sneaky and selfish as the rest of them. She treats her son like a foolish idiot, is critical and judgmental of his wife. She is constantly nagging on the children and revels a greater moral attitude towards them. The plot begins with a family car trip in which they ironically run into a criminal they were trying to travel away from all because the Grandmother insisted on a detour to see an old house. Throughout the story, theology is depicted in a tricky way. God is mostly nonexistent but assumed to be believed in by the Grandma because she is a “perfect lady.” It is not until the final scene when the Misfit threatens her life, that she finally experiences a moment of grace by recognizing him as one of her own children. O’Connor demonstrates a strong belief in the salvation of religion by describing the Grandma sitting perfectly and looking up into the cloudless sky after her death. Through the Grandma’s character, it is learned that O’Connor believed everyone deserves to be saved no matter how sinful his or her actions may
...interracial relationships. However because of the way he acts when he hears about the two of them, it is obvious that he has led a sheltered life. But even after his entire life of not understanding what was going on in the world around him, one night with Robert enlightened him and changed his view on people and his surrounding environment.
Bub felt and understand the meaning of cathedral after being in Robert's position.and that pushes him to understand allots of things around him,because he now knows what it means to too feel something rather than just visualizing it. and he admit it by saying “My eyes were still closed. I was in my house. I knew that. But I didn't feel like I was inside anything.” because now he feel what is inside of hime self not what is around him.
When her outward attempts fail, the grandmother turns inward to her knowledge of Christ in a last ditch effort to save her life. Suddenly, the grandmother and The Misfit move into an intellectual conversation about Christ. At its climax, The Misfit becomes emotional, “‘Listen lady,’ he said in a high voice, ‘if I had of been there I would of know’…his voice seemed about to crack” (21). Their discussion stops at this point, and finally reaches the core of O’Connor’s moral code. Merely knowing about Christ does not equate with salvation; it requires a true connection to God. In this moment, everything has been stripped away from the grandmother’s life, and she is able, for the first time, to find her relationship with God. “The grandmother’s
"Cathedral" is a short story ultimately about enlightment, finding something more meaningful and deeper with in one self. Although from an observing point of view nothing more in the story happens then a blind man assisting the narrator in drawing a cathedral. Although as known, the narrator's experience radically differs from what is actually "observed". He is enlightened and opened up to a new world of vision and imagination. This brief experience will have a life long effect on him. The reason for this strong and positive effect is not so much the relationship made between the blind man and the narrator or even the actual events leading up to this experience, but rather it is mostly due to what was drawn by the narrator.
In Flannery O’Conners, A Good Man is Hard to Find, the use of allusions convey the theme of death. While they were all driving through Georgia, the grandmother noticed this landscape. “They passed a large cotton field with five or six graves fenced in the middle of it, like a small island.” (132) The six graves emphasize the theme of death. In Baileys family, there are six members. This highlights the fact that they are going to die later on. Additionally, the island too, represents death and isolation. Towards the ending of this short story the family members are surrounded by the men and the misfit. This can allude to how an island is fenced (just like how the graves were fenced) by a body of water. Moreover, in this short story,
Faith is something a person must have inside them to be able to succeed. Success and failure are two completely different things, but faith is what separates the two. In the short story “A Fable with Slips of White Paper Spilling from the Pockets” by Kevin Brockmeier, the author illustrates the struggles a man must overcome in society and the obstacles he must overcome when his faith is tested to the limit. In the fable, the author uses symbols of faith, magical elements, and realistic struggles to divulge the morals and struggles of life.
anyone like the grandmother. The good man is also not like the Misfit, his men, or any of the other person in this story. At long last, the grandmother discovers that the only real Good Man is Jesus. It is, actually, possible to find Him, but one must have faith. The grandmother must leave all of her manipulative self-centeredness, her focus on earthly things and showing of her Christianity by just talking and not by actions. In exchange for her sinfulness, she is given the Grace of God, forgiveness and the hope of Paradise. In the end, she finally meets Jesus and is transformed by the Grace of God. This enables her to show love and grace towards the Misfit, who has just had her family brutally murdered. For the grandmother it is hard to find the Good Man, but at the end of her journey she finally finds Him and is now with Him in
In Cathedrals, the narrator starts his journey to enlightenment once the blind man enters the house. The first step towards the narrator’s understanding is when he learns that Robert smokes. The narrator believed in a misconception that blind people did not smoke because they are unable to see the smoke. However this was disproved when Robert smoked his cigarette. This caused the narrator to feel more connected to the blind man, because even though Robert was different, they both had a similarity. The second step, that shows the narrator’s change in perspective, occurred when they ate dinner. This scene alludes to The Last Supper, because of the wine, bread, and prayer. This also shows that the narrator’s disposition is slowly transfiguring. The final step towards the narrator’s epiphany is when Robert asks him to explain what a cathedral is. After the narrator draws the cathedral on the paper, Robert tells him to close his eyes. This act forces the narrator to experience what Robert experiences every day. The narrator not only sympathizes with Robert for the first time, but he truly understands that being different is not bad. In A Good Man Is Hard to Find, the grandmother experiences an epiphany as well. While she is trying to explain to the Misfit that he actually is a good man, she realizes the flaws that she possesses. At the end of the story the grandmother cries out, “‘why, you’re one of my
In Raymond Carver’s story, “Cathedral,” the story tells of how a close outside relationship can threaten a marriage by provoking insecurities, aggravating communication barriers, and creating feelings of invasion of privacy. The husband in the story is given the gift of seeing the cathedral through a blind man’s eyes. Although the title suggests that the story is about a cathedral, it is really about two men who come together and share a vision and realize it is he who is blind.
In Raymond Carver’s story “Cathedral” the narrator learns what it means to “see” through someone who cannot. To see is to be able to view the things around us while putting aside preconceived notions or fear about these objects or people. In order for this to occur once must overcome what they feel is out of the ordinary and learn to accept things as they are. At first the narrator is doesn’t accept the man and uncomfortable around Robert. The narrator soon comes to understand this when he puts aside his fears, and judgments that he can see more than what meets the eye, and the freedom that comes along with this seeing.
In Aldous Huxley’s “Brave New World” and Flannery O’Connor’s “A Good Man is Hard to Find” the reader is let into two different worlds that take place in two completely different eras. Brave New World takes place 500 years in the future and is about a dystopian future. It shows how people are separated into different caste systems and are conditioned into how they should act. A Good Man is Hard to Find takes place in the 1930’s and is mainly about the goodness that an individual has. In both texts, the authors use of society and class, religion, and the contrasting ideas of freedom and manipulation help further the idea of how a class system can have the same meaning no matter what era.
In Flannery O 'Connor 's short story, A Good Man is Hard to Find, the theme of good vs. evil unravels throughout the series of tragic events. The Grandmother’s epiphany introduces the idea of morality and the validity is left to the interpretation of the reader. By questioning the characteristics of right and wrong, morality and religion become subjective to personal reality and the idea of what makes individuals character good or bad becomes less defined.