A Comparison of Quebec to the Rest of Canada

analytical Essay
1364 words
1364 words

Quebec’s social identity and defining characteristics contradict and conflict with those of rest of Canada. Since the genesis of our country, the political, social disagreements, and tensions between Quebec and the rest of Canada have been unavoidable. Utilizing Hiller’s key contradictions in the analysis of a Canadian society, we will compare and contrast the nature of the societal identity in Quebec compared to that of rest of Canada, emphasising on the major differences and tensions between the province and the rest of the country.

Although Quebec is in Canada, a majority of Quebecers do not identify with the national identity of Canada. Both societies create a sense of identity as well as nationalism (Hiller, 295). Hiller mentions two approaches to assessing Canadian identity; the unitary approach and the segmentalist approach (Hiller, 277). The unitary approach suggests that society consists of people who regardless of their ethnic back ground, identify as belonging to the national society, while the segmentalist approach concentrates on groups and communities that share racial, linguistic, occupational, or cultural similarities (Hiller, 28). While most Anglophones are more unitary or pan-Canadian, Quebec heavily identifies with the segmentalist approach. This dissimilarity of identity perspective may be problematic for the country, at the same time however, it can also be viewed as a struggle where contradictory parties find a way to compromise and reshape Canadian society together (Hiller, 277). Canada’s former Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau made it his objective to unite Quebec with the rest of Canada. In 1969 Trudeau’s government implemented Bill C-120, otherwise known as the Official Language act, which made French an...

... middle of paper ...

... Analysis (5th ed.), Toronto: Pearson Prentice-Hall.
Bélanger, Claude. "The Official Languages Act of Canada - Studies on the Canadian Constitution and Canadian Federalism - Quebec History." .Marianopolis College, Nov. 2005. Web. 02 Apr. 2014.
CBC-Digital. "CBC Digital Archives - Separation Anxiety: The 1995 Quebec Referendum - Separation Anxiety: The 1995 Quebec Referendum." CBCnews. CBC/Radio Canada, 06 Mar. 2014. Web. 02 Apr. 2014
Dougherty, Kevin. "Marois Ready to Use Notwithstanding Clause to Protect Charter." Montreal Gazette. 31 Mar. 2014. Web. 02 Apr. 2014.
Polese, Mario. "Regional Economics." The Canadian Encyclopedia. HISTORICA FOUNDATION, 02 July 2006. Web. 13 Mar. 2014.
Tencer, Daniel. "Income Inequality: Canada Does Surprisingly Little To Reduce Wage Gap. “The Huffington Post. The Huffington Post, Winter 2013. Web. 02 Apr. 2014.

In this essay, the author

  • Analyzes how hiller's key contradictions in the analysis of a canadian society will compare and contrast the nature of the societal identity in quebec compared to that of rest of canada.
  • Explains that although quebec is in canada, a majority of quebecers do not identify with the national identity of canada.
  • Analyzes how hiller recognizes and identifies five key contradictions in the analysis of identity.
  • Analyzes hiller's second key contradiction: insularity vs openness. quebec society is more closed minded and extreme as it promotes the quebecois identity.
  • Analyzes hiller's legitimacy vs. illegitimacy debate, stating that legitimacy has to do with what is regarded and considered lawful and proper.
  • Analyzes hiller's fourth key contradiction: centralization vs. decentralization is needed to build a strong canadian society, while the government of quebec challenges and undermines the federal government.
  • Concludes that there are remarkable differences between quebec and canada. while most of anglo canada is unitary, quebec leans towards the segmentalist approach.
  • Explains that bélanger, claude, and dougherty, kevin, were interviewed about the 1995 quebec referendum.
Get Access