Embryonic Research: A Battle of Fallacies Essay

Embryonic Research: A Battle of Fallacies Essay

Length: 1435 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Many women are eager to become a mother, but infertility prevents some women from satisfying this need. To counter this widespread problem, we develop reproductive choices. One of the most important choices is in vitro fertilization. Even though this method significantly increases pregnancy rate in infertile women, it comes with the problem. Underlying in vitro fertilization is research on living human embryos. We need to research on countless living embryos in order to develop clinical in vitro fertilization. This stirs public attention on its morality. Society asks: Are we killing thousands of human life while we are developing method to give birth to other ones? This question is crucial because it is asking very foundation of our morality. We need to find the answer which can be proved thoroughly relevant, or otherwise, we are undermining our moral standard itself. To resolve this ethical dilemma, we turn our expectation to bioethicists because we need reliable thought, concrete argument, and plausible solution, and they seem to be only kind of people we can rely on. With our expectation, we tend to trust them. But the reality is opposite. The arguments from bioethicists may not be reliable as promised. We have to be conscious and cautious when we are considering their arguments. After contemplating two essays from both sides of the argument, “The Meaning of Life –In Laboratory” by Leon Kass and “Progeny, Progress, and Primrose Paths” by Samuel Gorovitz, we see the dialogues arguing on this moral issue contain amount of weak arguments and even logical fallacies.
We may focus first on the arguments against embryonic research. Among prominent opponents of embryonic research is Leon Kass, who wrote “The Meaning of Life –In Lab...


... middle of paper ...


... rely on them. As important as moral standard discussing in embryonic research issue is the logical standard. Logical fallacies might make the essay look more attractive, but after being scrutinized, the presence of logical fallacies degrades value of essay itself. It is not until the bioethicists give us the candid but concrete arguments on morality of embryonic research that we can trust them and take them into account while we are struggling to make this crucial decision, drafting our policy on this important and sensitive issue.



















Work Cited

Samuel Gorovitz, “Progeny, Progress, and Primrose Paths,” The Ethics of Reproductive Technology (New York: Oxford University Press, 1992), 117-127

Leon Kass, “The Meaning of Life–In the Laboratory,” The Ethics of Reproductive Technology (New York: Oxford University Press, 1992), 98-116

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Embryonic Research Essay

- Many women are eager to become a mother, but infertility prevents some women from satisfying this need. However, modern biotechnologies combined with changed norms of culture now provide them reproductive choices such as in vitro fertilization. In order to develop these reproductive choices, we need to research on living human embryo. Because its procedures terminate the life of embryo, embryonic research stirs up public attention on its morality. Society questions if these methods are morally right....   [tags: Morality, Logical Fallacies]

Powerful Essays
1068 words (3.1 pages)

The Path Of Embryonic Stem Cell Research Essay

- The path of embryonic stem cell research The great debate about embryonic stem cell research maybe over. What is the debate of embryonic stem cell. The debate is whether or not it is ethically or morally right to kill an embryo for a life, to save a life. The research behind the embryonic stem cell(hES cell) is promising though, and we may have found an alternative way of obtaining it because we can sidestep the issue of morality by using induced pluripotent stem cell for research rather than embryonic stem cells....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Powerful Essays
1217 words (3.5 pages)

A Research Study On Embryonic Stem Cells Essay

- Embryonic stem cells are being researched worldwide in an attempt to provide treatment for some degenerative diseases and human injuries. Although research is still being undertaken, these stem cells are providing a positive outlook on potential treatments however; as a potential human life is involved, is the use of embryonic stem cells to treat human diseases justified. Embryonic stem cells are obtained from the human embryo, which is developed from a fertilised egg (NIH, 2010). These embryonic stem cells are known as being pluripotent; the ability to develop into virtually any cell within the human body (Science Daily, 2014)....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Powerful Essays
1698 words (4.9 pages)

The Process Of Embryonic Stem Cell Research Essay examples

- Introduction In this paper, I will explain and evaluate the process of embryonic stem cell research. I will discuss the historical background along with the scientific background on how embryos are gathered respectively. I will then go on to state two sides of a growing debate on whether or not we have the right to culture unborn fetuses in order advance scientific research and whether or not we have the right to use these embryos to increase the productivity of our lives when we are faced with life threatening circumstances....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Powerful Essays
1054 words (3 pages)

Embryonic Stem Cell Research Provides Revolutionary and Life-saving Breakthroughs

- "Stem cell research is the key to developing cures for degenerative conditions like Parkinson's and motor neuron disease from which I and many others suffer. The fact that the cells may come from embryos is not an objection, because the embryos are going to die anyway." -- Stephen Hawking The phrase “stem cell” calls to mind images of controversy: Pro-life picketers outside abortion and in-vitro fertilization clinics, patients with chronic disabilities waiting on a cure, scientists in a lab experimenting with a petri dish....   [tags: Embryonic Stem Cell Research Papers]

Powerful Essays
3830 words (10.9 pages)

The Debate Of Embryonic Stem Cell Research Essay

- ... Reagan chooses a style which is straightforward and casual. He uses an “everyman” approach which keeps his message simple and also allows it to be more relatable for his audience. Ron Reagan’s personal and publicly known experience of having a former president as father, who suffered and died from Alzheimer’s in itself is a form of ethos. He has first-hand experience of having a loved one affected by a fatal and debilitating disease which gives him more clout regarding the issue. Additionally, his argument is strongly based upon emotional appeals....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell, Stem cells]

Powerful Essays
727 words (2.1 pages)

Why Ban Embryonic Stem Cell Research Essay

- Stem Cell Research "The human being is single, unique, and unrepeatable, someone thought of and chosen from eternity, someone called and identified by name." This was the belief of Pope John Paul II (May). Stem cell research has shown promise and success for curing disease; however embryonic stem cell research must be banned because it requires the killing of embryos, there are alternatives, and embryonic stem cell research has had no successes. Shows promise and success Adult stem cells can be found in umbilical cords, placentas, and amniotic fluid....   [tags: degenerative diseases, embryonic cells]

Powerful Essays
1304 words (3.7 pages)

Logical Fallacies Of An Argument Essay

- Logical Fallacies of an Argument Logical fallacies are the most common argument a writer may encounter to attack the opposition intelligence and its understanding. Logical fallacies can be argued on internet and off internet. A logical fallacy can be defined as a type of argument that has a good reason, but is recognized as bad. Sometimes, finding logical fallacy in an argument does not mean it is untrue. Logical fallacy can be formal and informal. Formal fallacy is an invalid argument because people can persuade by the conclusion....   [tags: Fallacy, Argument, Logical fallacies]

Powerful Essays
1442 words (4.1 pages)

Supporting Embryonic Stem Cell Research Essay

- Supporting Embryonic Stem Cell Research Scientific research has the ability to help the terminally ill and disabled. Some people find this research is morally wrong. If this research helps people with disease and disability would you condone it. Today in The United States there is controversy facing embryonic stem cell research.People are dying because of the legal and moral obstacles involved in embryonic stem cell research. American citizens with illnesses and disease could be treated if this research was to continue at a much faster pace....   [tags: Embryo Embryonic Stem Cell Cells Essays Papers]

Powerful Essays
1525 words (4.4 pages)

Fallacies Essay

- Fallacies are all around us. Every time we turn on a TV, or a radio, or pick up a newspaper, we see or hear fallacies. According to Dictionary.com, a fallacy is defined as a false notion, a statement or an argument based on a false or invalid inference, incorrectness of reasoning or belief; erroneousness, or the quality of being deceptive (www.Dictionary.com). Fallacies are part of everyday and become a staple in certain aspects of life. Political campaigns and reporters would be lost without the use of fallacies....   [tags: Literature Literary Fallacies]

Free Essays
1581 words (4.5 pages)