Egalitarian Ethics Against The Relatively Right Essay

Egalitarian Ethics Against The Relatively Right Essay

Length: 1384 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Egalitarian Ethics Against the Relatively Right
In Book I of his Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle states the final good of humanity is eudaimonia—best translated as ‘human flourishing’—and “the good of man is the active exercise of his soul 's faculties in conformity with excellence or virtue” (1098a.15). In other words, the point of being alive is to be the best person one possibly can be. The question remains is whether eudaimonia can be accomplished using a blanket notion of virtue which is displayed by each person in the same way, or whether a person needs the freedom to determine how best to handle a given situation due to contextual occurrences and personal potential capacity. While universal theories most certainly have their place and applications, I am of the opinion that when it comes to morality, an individual needs to have the ability to figure out the best course of action in a given moment. Comprehensive moral theory enables each person to be exactly as virtuous in each circumstance as those around them, rather than to have an opportunity to display their own strong suits. One person may be more generous than another, who in turn may be fairer. The target strength of different virtues varies by person, and it is this variance which enables each person to have something to contribute to a community’s overall success. There is nothing to be gained by having each person follow the same definition of what it is to practice a virtue.
Julia Annas outlines, but does not advocate, a technical manual model of morality in which there is a decision procedure which includes “giving specific instructions for how to act which are applicable to everyone in the same way” (63). Aristotle suggests instead we must have the knowledge of h...


... middle of paper ...


...ble of.
While the technical manual model does have its strong points, including its wide application and its possession of a clear method of action, moral learning which instead enables someone to decide the best way to act depending on the intricacies of the situation and the particular aspects of the actor’s personality has the best chance of giving people the opportunity to expand their moral growth. If virtue depends on actions which are deliberately chosen, for their own sake, and done for the right reasons then true, genuine virtue is simply not possible in a society which advocates the use of an all encompassing application of moral virtues. What is appropriately virtuous for one is not appropriately virtuous for all, and each individual must have the opportunity to determine what is appropriate and possible for their own set of circumstances and abilities.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Ethics And Ethics Of Business Ethics

- Business ethics could be categorized as one of the least studied topics, although it has been widely acknowledged to be great significant (Bushe & Gilbertson, 2007). Being in the competitive market, most enterprises have either formal or informal ethical code to assist them in determining whether certain business activity is acceptable or not, especially when managers face dilemmas (Velasquez & Velazquez, 2002). This is because behaviors are justified by theories, orienting from the most basic question “what is the right thing to be done” (Grace, 1998; Takala, 2012)....   [tags: Ethics, Immanuel Kant, Deontological ethics]

Better Essays
1822 words (5.2 pages)

Essay about The Ethics Of Virtue Ethics

- Secondly, the possibility of the right to lie is refuted on the basis of virtue ethics, which maintains that lying is morally wrong though the argument or claim is less strict as compared to Kant’s statement. Virtue ethics generally provides a different approach to ethics by focusing on character development of individuals. As a result, virtue ethicists tend to look at what people should be with regards to their character rather than determining the right or wrong of a behavior simply on the basis of reason and desired and undesired behavior (Mazur par, 5)....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Virtue ethics, Virtue]

Better Essays
1687 words (4.8 pages)

Ethics : Deeper Into Ethics Essay

- Deeper into Ethics Ethics is defined as a study that deals with what behavior is considered to be, good or bad. Ethics is about doing what is right for other people throughout society (Kraft). Ethical principles result from religions, philosophies, and cultural ideas. The world is changing and so is everything in it, judgments about what is ethically right and wrong are also changing. Ethical relativism is important within society, along with utilitarianism, deontology, virtue-based ethics, and ethical principles of healthcare....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Utilitarianism]

Better Essays
1104 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Poverty Is Morally Right Or Wrong?

- Global Poverty Poverty has a crippling effect on those who must live in it. There is little to no access to health care or even education. Infrastructures such as transportation, sanitation, and safe water are done without. Basic rights, basic needs are deprived of. But what is even more unfortunate is the lack of voice these individuals have when it comes to their suffering. There are people who have an abundance of food, clothing and items in general yet others are forced to scrape up a meal for the day....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Value, Virtue]

Better Essays
1103 words (3.2 pages)

The Ethics Of Ethical Conduct Essay

- Ethical conduct is one of the purpose of many factors, of being religious affiliated. Many workplaces, daily operations would need an individual making decisions. Moreover, main religious worldwide teach their members moral educations that do not support unethical behaviors. Because they are religious, the teachings make them be against bad actions to their fellow workmates. “Super-natural being holds all persons answerable for their whereabouts in the world” (Emerson & McKinney, 2010). Most religious people, who follow their religion, are likely to be punished for the way they act in a workplace because that’s their religion....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Religion, Virtue]

Better Essays
2404 words (6.9 pages)

The Ethics of Gun Control Essay

- The Ethics of Gun Control The phrase "Gun Control" means different things to different people. One bumper sticker states that "Gun Control means hitting your target." However one defines gun control, the mere mention of it brings controversy. Opposing sides have for years fought over the laws that govern firearms. For the purposes of this paper "Gun Control" is defined as policies enacted by the government that limit the legal rights of gun owners to own, carry, or use firearms, with the intent of reducing gun crimes such as murder, armed robbery, aggravated rape, and the like....   [tags: Constituton Bill Rights Right To Bear Arms]

Better Essays
1769 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on The Rational Woman's Right to Abortion

- A nineteen year old girl lies frozen in the fetal position; taking three positive pregnancy tests has thrown her into a nightmare. Reflecting on one poor decision she made- one pill she skipped- she imagines foregoing all of her dreams of getting a doctorate in order to become another working-class single mom. She disregards this option upon much deliberation and decides to have a medical abortion. Holding no beliefs about souls residing in unborn embryos or fetuses, she is relatively unshaken by the procedure and makes a commitment to be more vigilant moving forward....   [tags: sexual education, religious groups]

Better Essays
1788 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on Against Sweatshops

- Some companies have acceded to public pressure to reduce or end their use of sweatshops. Such firms often publicize the fact that their products are not made with Anti-globalization activists and environmentalists also deplore transfer of heavy industrial manufacturing (such as chemical production) to the developing world. Although chemical factories have little in common with sweatshops in the original sense, detractors describe them as such and claim that there are negative environmental and health impacts (such as pollution and birth defects, respectively) on workers and the local community....   [tags: Business Ethics]

Better Essays
1140 words (3.3 pages)

What is Computer Ethics? James Moore Essay

- In today’s world of connected computers, ethics has a very important role in ensuring that ICT professionals maintain their integrity. Philip Argy, the President of the Australian Computer Society was quoted saying in 2007 that ethics is “doing the right thing even when no one is looking” (Worthington 2008). James Moor, who wrote a paper titled “What is Computer Ethics?” in 1985 summarised that with computers being universal tools, it has enabled us to do things that we could have never been able to do before....   [tags: codes of conduct, penalty, computers]

Better Essays
1713 words (4.9 pages)

Management Planning and Ethics Essay

- Management Planning and Ethics The recent breakdown in trust resulting from the lack of character of some leaders in corporate America should cause less finger-pointing and more serious introspection. These leaders are not from outer space, here to impose some alien standard of conduct, but came from among us and as such, reflect attitudes and values that we have lazily slipped into. The tendency is to punish the “evil-doers” and move on confidently in the knowledge that the problem has been solved....   [tags: Morals Ethical Managing Essays]

Better Essays
1140 words (3.3 pages)