Music And Western Culture Essay

1500 Words3 Pages

Many musicological studies that have made available to us in recent years seem to suggest that music is inherently tied to the Western culture. A case in point is the account presented by several historians of country music suggesting that this particular genre of music has its social origins in the early 20th-century Southern United States, and that New Orleans is the center of many African American musical styles (Manuel 417). Although these accounts may be valid, it may be misleading to hold the perspective that music is inescapably tied to the Western culture and its assumptions. If we take a closer look at all the societies and cultures known to us and evaluate all the historical societies to the level that we can possibly discern, we …show more content…

Here, two important arguments arise: the first point of view deals with the way prehistoric societies in Africa and alleged ‘uncivilized’ places performed the rituals with music as a central feature. If music is inescapably tied to Western culture, then one wonders how these prehistoric societies had perfected the art of singing in funerals and weddings long before they were exposed to colonization by the Western world. The second point deals with how music, culture, and tradition are essentially interconnected. Here, available literature shows that “people remember what is good or useful and share it with next generation and with their neighbors” (Garfias 2). As opposed to arguing that music is tied to Western culture, it is more prudent to contend that music has characterized all cultures since prehistoric times, only that the most important and useful elements of our music that we have learned are diffused and carried on to newer generations (Garfias 2; Frith …show more content…

Although these scholars are in agreement that no consensus seems forthcoming on the origins of music, they all agree that music is not only universal but also a substantial aspect of every known culture (McDermott 164). Some of the proposals that have been suggested to describe the origin of music include the conception that “music is merely an accidental byproduct of traits that evolved for other purposes, but also various proposals for potential adaptive functions, ranging from the promotion of social cohesion to the facilitation of infant-parent interactions” (McDermott 164). These suggestions, in my view, progress the nature-nurture debate that cement the universality paradigm at the expense of Western culture predisposition. They show that music is unavoidably tied to genetic and environmental influences, rather than western culture and its assumptions. The suggestions also show that innate influences, rather than western culture, are a more appropriate explanation of how individuals develop or internalize their musical capabilities. Overall, therefore, the notion that music is inescapably tied to Western culture is not supported by

More about Music And Western Culture Essay

Open Document