Effectiveness Of Civilian Oversight Models For Police Wrongdoing Essay

Effectiveness Of Civilian Oversight Models For Police Wrongdoing Essay

Length: 809 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Throughout the evolution of police, there has always been an unsteady relationship with the public. The waver in civilian’s confidence in law enforcement agencies can be attributed to the increase in police misconduct, or corruption. Then a new strategy called, civilian oversight model was introduced giving regular citizens the chance to have a say in police conduct. The public was in full support of the new model implemented through the law enforcement agencies. However, there was disagrees in the police field with the public having more power over there actions. The increased implementation of civilian oversight models for police wrongdoing has both positive, and negative attributes to the community as a whole.
Police misconduct is a widely recognized problem throughout the law enforcement agencies. The set amount of training a cadet, wanting to be a police officer has to go through is suppose to set them up in the real world out on the streets. However, this is not always the case, real world dangers and factors come into play. Sometimes the training an officer receives before being sworn in is not enough to prepare them for what he or she may encounter. Citizen satisfaction with police encounters is a product of the congruence between individual expectations of service and the perceptions of the actual service rendered (Brown). The term ‘misconduct’ or ‘corruption’ is not always an obvious offense to an individual. A general idea of misconduct performed by an officer is: sexual misconduct, prisoner mistreatment, traffic violations, evidence manipulation, and unauthorized disclosure of information (Gottschalk). To try to counter balance the police misuse of power the civilian oversight model was created.
The process...


... middle of paper ...


...vement. We have the police who disagree, and the public who agrees with the ability to get involved with the overseeing of police misconduct. I believe the civilian oversight model is a great method that was developed because it allows for civilians and officers to work hand in hand together to overcome a situation. Although law enforcement agencies are against the model there are ways to ensure a better opinion of the model. The training of oversight staff and volunteers can make sure that adequate individuals are chosen to hold position in the model. Oversight systems can require that a department supervisor attend hearings, and be called to answer questions about the department’s policies (Finn). Altogether, the law enforcement department and the public are moving towards a better correlation together with the civilian oversight model in effect.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Being Citizen Involvement And Oversight Of The Police Department Essay example

- Having citizen involvement and oversight of the police department, especially when investigating issues of misconduct or corruption, is likely to result in a more objective and thorough investigation. The police departments that utilize the civilian/citizen oversight boards do this to deter misconduct of police officers and block the opportunity for a police officer to be able to conceal and/or destroy evidence. The use of an ‘outside agency” can also demonstrate to the public that “one of them” (average person) is looking into the issue....   [tags: Police, Constable, Police brutality]

Better Essays
1011 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Effectiveness Of Current Police Responses

- Effectiveness of Current Police Responses to street robbery In order to measure the effectiveness of the implement responses to the problem, the condition and measures of the problem before and after the implementation of the responses should all be taken and compared. One notable thing is, not only the target are, but also the surrounding area should be measured, so that whole image can be captured, and spatial displacement of the problem can be witnessed if it happened. Monk, Heinonen and Eck (2010) gave five potentially useful measures of the effectiveness of responses to street robbery: 1. reduced overall number of street robberies in your community, 2. reduced number of robberies at hot...   [tags: Crime, Police, Robbery, Law enforcement agency]

Better Essays
809 words (2.3 pages)

Effectiveness Of Current Police Responses Essay

- Effectiveness of Current Police Responses to street robbery In order to measure the effectiveness of the implement responses to the problem, the condition and measures of the problem before and after the implementation of the responses should all be taken and compared. Moreover, not only the target area, but also the surrounding area should be measured, so that whole image can be captured, and spatial displacement of the problem can be witnessed if it happened. Monk, Heinonen and Eck (2010) gave five potentially useful measures of the effectiveness of responses to street robbery: 1. reduced overall number of street robberies in the community, 2. reduced number of robberies at hot spots, 3. r...   [tags: Crime, Police, Robbery, Law enforcement agency]

Better Essays
732 words (2.1 pages)

Sample Resume : Civilian Oversight And Accountability Essay

- Writing Sample: Civilian Oversight and Accountability Law enforcement use of deadly and excessive force continues to create distrust among communities of color, while civilian oversight agencies aim to build community trust and confidence through external oversight. Historically, communities of colors have complained of excessive force or racism, which is “often the motivating factor behind the formation of civilian oversight boards” (Snow, 1992). Furthermore, current national events in which officer’s use deadly force has stimulated further interest in civilian oversight of law enforcement agencies....   [tags: Police, Police brutality, Law enforcement agency]

Better Essays
789 words (2.3 pages)

Aviation Oversight Essay

- Without the federal government’s direct oversight of development in aviation, much of the technology and advancements we utilize today would not be available. Previous to the Deregulation Act of 1978, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) monitored and controlled nearly every aspect of the industry. It wasn’t until after the act was released, did the aviation industry begin seeing its true potential in transportation. By the early 1900’s, with the aviation industry just beginning, many enthusiasts experimented with the new concept of flight and quickly began improving the basic concepts of aviation....   [tags: Aviation]

Better Essays
901 words (2.6 pages)

Police Corruption And Racial Biased Police Practices Essay examples

- The growing attention on police officers involved in shootings, police corruption and racial biased police practices has lead most cities and departments to seek out methods to change the way the public view them. One way in doing so is creating oversight organizations like citizen review boards. The creation of citizen boards increases citizens’ roles in the investigation of citizen complaints on police officers. The implementation of citizen oversight boards has created an effective mechanism on improving the quality of police affairs and restoring the public overall views of police departments....   [tags: Police, Police brutality, Constable]

Better Essays
937 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on An Evaluation of Security Acts and Models

- ... Unfortunately, this may also impose massive hardships by increasing the costs and labor for agencies to establish permissible access. However, this expected and justified expense comes with risk reduction. It is also worth noting that FISMA protects certain government information from being subjected to release by the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) (Feinberg, 2004). GLBA repealed acts such as the Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 and the Bank Holding Company Act of 1965, which barred financial bodies from performing any mixture of roles such as banks delving into insurance underwriting, securities, and other investment functions (Mamun, Hassan, & Maroney, 2005)....   [tags: information security, models, protection]

Better Essays
1683 words (4.8 pages)

Effectiveness And Effectiveness Of Law Enforcement Essay

- Effectiveness and efficiency correlate when discussing law enforcement. By definition, effectiveness is described as, “The degree to which objectives are achieved and the extent to which targeted problems are solved. In law enforcement, there are many problems that are faced on a daily basis. Being effective, one must analyze for a problem, target the problem, make changes to alleviate if not eliminate the problem, and determine how those crimes or issues resolved in a measurable way. In contrast to efficiency, effectiveness is determined without reference to costs and, whereas efficiency means "doing the thing right," effectiveness means "doing the right thing.” http://www.businessdiction...   [tags: Police, Law enforcement agency, Law enforcement]

Better Essays
974 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about The Rational Models of Policy Process

- ... The models are in the close system of process because no limitation on information, time and resources that needed in the cycle of policy. The rational model is not perfect in the practice. In some ways, the system is very useful in very modest and easy policy process which asking valid data instantly, enough time for examination and all resources of policy process is easy to get. Then, when the model is facing the issue of policy that complex and multi-dimensional aspect, the rational becomes less relevant in the exercise of policy process (Lindblom, 1959: 80)....   [tags: mechanical process, policy making, policy cycle]

Better Essays
1667 words (4.8 pages)

The Police Force Essay

- Throughout history the police force has severely changed, with the first forms of policing appearing in the Anglo-Saxon period in England; where the king would provide protection to the civilians for a tax (Mawby, 1999). Centuries later and the principles of protecting the people are generally the same. However, in recent times crimes and perpetrators are becoming more sophisticated; the need for higher abilities to control and manage these complicated situations is becoming more prevalent. It can be seen that the entry requirements into the police force are also dramatically increasing over the decades....   [tags: American History, Police Training]

Better Essays
1828 words (5.2 pages)