Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Western medicine vs traditional medicine
Western medicine vs traditional medicine
Western medicine vs traditional medicine
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Western medicine vs traditional medicine
The Eastern Cultures’ Healing Powers: The Western Cultures’ Greatest Asset
Quick Fix culture and the Attitude Adjustment Culture The Western Culture focuses on two methods of healing: chemically engineered compounds and surgical procedures. For instance, in the United States, individuals have the option of antidepressants with or without the aid of cognitive therapy(Selhub 2007) Most individuals choose the quick approach due to its alluring quick fix scheme. These contrasts different from the Eastern Culture’s main focus: the power of the mind and the energy from within: mind, body, and soul. The effects of Eastern Culture’s approach have been proven to be enduring and beneficial to the individuals involved. The Western Culture would greatly
…show more content…
Mind, body and soul co-exist in the Eastern Culture. “The Eastern idea of health and disease is look upon as the two sides of a coin…Every individual person is in a state of balance between external insults and internal defensive mechanisms.” ( Tsuei 1978). For example the Eastern approach takes in account of heavens and the earth” ( Tsuei 1978). If in curing the sick you do not observe the records of heaven nor use the principle of earth , result will be calamity.” ( Tsuei 1978). The Eastern culture looks at the universe and the laws of nature, in choosing treatment for their …show more content…
The way that the Western and Eastern cultures interpret the body and mind is like looking at a painting. One individual may interpret it as a symbol for a deeper meaning, while another individual may simply look at the painting and perceive only the image that is projected in front. The Western Culture identifies stress and emotions as a liability to an individual’s overall health. At one time there was a correlation between the feeling of grief and death. For instance, when a wife had passed away and a month later her husband passed away, it was thought that the reason of death was grief. Therefore, the death certificate would read “Grief” as probable cause of death. Times have changed and this is no longer acceptable. One cannot prove that grief causes death. In the Western Culture the mind and body treatment consists of regulating stress instead of an invisible internal energy that the Eastern Culture believes in (Selhub 2007).In some ways the Western Culture lets a little bit of the Eastern Culture come in treating patients. Some Western Physicians have looked into Transcendental Meditation, Mindful Meditation, Guided Imagery, Progressive muscle relaxation, Hypnosis and Autogenic training. Patients have shown increases in elevated moods and health. However, the skepticism is still high. One article states that “Better studies are necessary to determine fully what the benefits of meditation are for patients
Leaving them with feelings of “gratitude”, “indebtness”, “responsibility”, and a whole “new view of reality”. Western healing “validates the individual’s experiences”, while “tackling general” and “specific problems” in one’s “life” (Reynolds, 2016). Last but not least is the difference in settings for the healing process. Western psychotherapy is done through counseling (talking) usually once or twice a week depending on type and reason for therapy Rose, 2015). It’s done through “therapeutic relationships”, “dialogs”, and “communication” to help individual’s “overcome problematic thoughts, and/or behaviors”
One such philosophy that has been growing in popularity throughout the West is Tibetan Buddhism. I believe that Western society has reached a point where we must try something new in order to help increase the happiness of its citizens and that Tibetan Buddhism may hold the answer. After studying and examining the similarities and differences between Buddhist and Western psychotherapy philosophies and goals, there is st...
Ramaswami, S. & Sheikh, A. (1989). Buddhist psychology: Implications for healing, In A. Sheikh & S. Sheikh's Eastern and western approaches to healing: Ancient wisdom & modern knowledge, NY: John Wiley
In Eastern cultures, meditation has been practiced for over two thousand years. Through this training a culture has developed in which an individual is empowered to engaged in preventative behaviors, which reduce stress and morbidity, resulting in a general state of wellbeing, with stability and mental peace in the face of everyday challenges (Richardson and Lutz, 2008). Over the last half-century, the western-scientific community has begun to evaluate the efficacy of the eastern methods of meditation. In the modern western world there is an over abundance of stress, pressure and over stimulation. These conditions often result in stress-related morbidity, high levels of anxiety and mental illnesses. This cause and effect relationship is well established, and typically emphasis is placed on symptom control and less on preventative behavior modification. There are clinically documented see table 1, meditation practices that can be taught over a short period of time to an individual which have been shown to have positive results. Meditation can be used preventatively in supporting immune function and during illness as a method to aid healing and wellbeing for nominal costs. This paper will make an literary examination of a variety of studies of which examine the role of meditation training in regards to promoting immune function in athletes, recovering cancer patients, in addition to reducing stress and promoting well being in business professionals, cancer patients and seasoned meditation practitioners.
Western imperialism in the 1800s and early 1900s had positive, negative, and long-lasting effects in countries like India, regions of South East Asia, and Africa. There were many social, economic, and political changes. For example, in Hawaii there was an abundance of sugar cane crops and the U.S sought out to make money by occupying Hawaii. This was beneficial for the businessmen because they were receiving large quantities of money. However, the local peoples deeply opposed the selling of their crops. Throughout the course of imperialism in the 1800s and early 1900s, many other countries and regions such as India, regions of South East Asia, and Africa were faced with hardships while the imperialists raced to gain the most control.
This paper will discuss three different religions that a health care provider may care for in the nursing field. It will discuss the spiritual perspective, as well as the critical components of healing, such as through prayer and meditation. The writer will give a brief summary of each religions belief. The three religions that will be discussed in this paper are Native American, Hinduism, and Buddhism. This paper will discuss what is important to people who are cared for of a particular faith by the health care provider who may have an entirely different belief system. The writer will discuss how a patient may view a health care provider who puts aside his or her own beliefs in the interest of the beliefs and practices of the patient that is being cared for. The writer of this paper is of Christian belief and will compare her beliefs of faith and healing with the three previously mentioned religions.
Kleinman, A. 1980. Patients and Healers in the Context of Culture: An Exploration of the Borderland between Anthropology, Medicine, and Psychiatry. University of California Press.
Getting a massage with jan, and learning even more about traditional chinese medicine has motivated me to seek out other forms of traditional chinese forms of healing such as reflexology, acupuncture and a more structured form of meditation. Jan explained that life is all about balance, and even in western medicine, when balance is off problems form. It has made me think even more about how out of balance people are, and how much commitment it takes to be in constant balance especially with the large amount of technology, and poor diets in today’s society.
Compared with individualistic Western cultures however; health professionals such as psychiatrists and other medical doctors are not yet fully trained to deal with patients complaining of symptoms that are not necessarily somatic. This is due to the fact that “for decades since the late introduction of psychiatry as a subject in medical schools in Asia, all that was taught was 10 lecture-demonstrations of the severely psychotic or depressed mentally ill patients, more as oddities in medical practice than as ill persons who needed to be understood.” (Deshvara) Thus with medical professionals being unable to fully provide an unconditionally positive and supportive environment needed for the growth of mentally ill patients; placing the pressure on one’s self to heal quickly in order to decrease the chances of a negative reputation among the community and among family members increases. Moreover, in collectivist cultures, emphasis on somatic complaints may result from the belief that emotional distress is caused by physical ailments and that it will cease upon proper medical treatment for the physical problem. By emphasizing the importance of physical,
Terrence, Clifford. Diamo Healing: The Buddhist Medicine and Medical Psychiatry of Tibet. Motilal Banarsidass. 2003.
One of the oldest and most complete medical systems ever developed is traditional Chinese medicine. The Taoist ideas and the importance of nature have been intertwined with Chinese Medicine from the ancient beginnings of Chinese culture. “'Tao' or way, is the major idea of Taoism: 'Man models himself on earth, earth on heaven, heaven on the way, and the way on that which is naturally so'. Taoism teaches that human beings should be in harmony with nature, that is, with Tao” (Y). Taoism celebrates the forces of nature and recognizes the interplay of yin and yang in all things. The Taoist principles of Yin-Yang, the eight principles, Chi energy, and the five elements are tools used in Chinese medicine to comprehend the web of phenomena as it relates to health and well-being. The philosophic view of the human body is to regard it as a microcosmic reflection of the universe. Therefore healing and medicine should maintain the body’s balance, both internally and as one relates to the external world (Freeman, 314). It is their goal the patient’s body, microcosm, resonates in balance with the universe, the macrocosm. The Taoist notion of integrating mind, body, and spirit for good health is one of the main foundations of Chinese medicine to this day. Acupuncture, Chinese herbology, and Tai Chi are all techniques of Traditional Chinese Medicine (Ivker, Anderson, Trivieri, Morris, and Nelson 479-480).
The Western culture has evolved over a span of several years with various civilizations specializing in specific aspects of life or nature. In essence, Western civilization dates back to the BCE periods when Ancient Greece, Mesopotamia, and Ancient Rome reigned. Each of the Western civilizations came with a clear lineage that portrayed such attributes as property rights, free market economy, competition, personal freedoms, and innovation (Perry, 2013). Besides, the western civilizations came at different periods with some of the attributes evolving or remaining unchanged throughout the lineage. However, the non-western civilizations contributed towards such attributes to a given extent, primarily because of the interactions among
In this paper I will be discussing the two most prevalent models of health. These two models of health are not, of course, total opposites. Similar to terms such as gay and straight they are two definitive labels placed upon a broad spectrum that is hardly definitive. There exists in this case as well a large clouded middle between the two limiting labels. These are collections of thoughts about how to go about continuing life. These two paradigms in modern healthcare I hope will one-day come to know one another. For now let us say that in generally speaking there are two different approaches or models of medicine and they are allopathic and holistic. Allopathic is another term for our modern western medicine, which in the United States is the dominant one and the one most familiar to the masses. The other, the holistic model, also known as alternative, is commonly associated with older ideas that originated in the East.
Every year, approximately 230, 000 to 400. 00 deaths are caused by iatrogenic deaths ( in other words, these are deaths caused by wrong medical treatments). Two of the prominent yet some what contrasting types of medicine are, Ayurveda, the Indian traditional medicine, and Modern (aka western) medicine. Both of these have their own processes and methods of healing, which over the years have created their own followers. While Ayurveda addresses the root causes of the disease through identifying the imbalances in the elements, called “Doshas”, it also emphasizes on a spiritual lifestyle which for most people in today's world is a sea change. On the other hand, western medicine addresses the symptoms and provides instant albeit temporary relief for suffering. Needless to say there are more followers of the western medicine due to its immediate impact on subsiding the pain. Out of lack of awareness to the significance of traditional medicine, especially Ayurveda, many doctors and researchers are against the use of Ayurvedic and traditional medicines, which limits the potential of curing certain ailments of patients without additional side effects.
There are a lot of different cultures in the world we live in today. Finding the place you belong and discovering your own culture can be a challenge. This is especially true when you look at culture as an individual versus culture in your family, or even within your community. I’ve always been very family oriented, so that plays a big part in who I am and how my family’s dynamic works. I believe that my family has had a huge impact on the development of my culture, and I hope that I have had the same impact on theirs.