Dr. Germain 's Play, Freud 's Last Session, By Freud And Lewis Essay

Dr. Germain 's Play, Freud 's Last Session, By Freud And Lewis Essay

Length: 1111 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Coexist eternally? Today, an emerging belief is that all paths, all religions, lead to the same place. Everyone takes their own way that satisfies and works for them, but in the end all will be together in a perfect realm. While this may sound appealing and nice in contrast to the totalitarian view, meaning one truth, it is impossible for this to work. In St. Germain’s play, Freud’s Last Session,” Freud and Lewis both make absolute truth claims that completely contradict each other. It is impossible for these exclusive claims to both be true, and they clearly end in entirely different places. While both men make compelling arguments, Lewis’ argument of moral codes proves to be the most dangerous and strongest argument.
Lewis makes many compelling arguments that poke holes in Freud 's philosophy, all of which have major consequences. Lewis’ strongest argument, however, is his claim on the existence of moral codes. World War Two is being fought right outside their window when Freud claims that religion is an excuse for the war. Lewis states that accepting that moral law is at work is the first step. He points to societies throughout history: “Moral codes have existed throughout time. Tell me one civilization that admired theft of cowardice. Mankind has never rewarded selfishness”(13). The idea that all cultures view theft as wrong even those that are completely atheistic, point to a higher being that created these moral laws making this argument extremely dangerous to Freud’s philosophy. The argument is brought back to the war as Lewis asks if the Nazis are right in their selfish actions after Freud claims, “selfishness rewards itself” (13). Freud replies no revealing the truth in Lewis’ claim to a higher degree: “So there is a mor...


... middle of paper ...


...ne making it severely dangerous to Freud.
Freud and Lewis, an atheist and a Christian, have entirely different worldviews leading to their opposing perspectives on most of life 's questions and issues. Despite their differences, Freud and Lewis were able to disagree in a civil manner. Both men set a good example of how to disagree disagreeably as they truly attempt to understand the other’s perspective.While both men did this well, Lewis’ point on the existence of moral codes proved to be the strongest and most dangerous argument discussed throughout their conversation, as it points to the existence of a God. At the end of the day they come to realize that trying to solve the world’s greatest mystery is impossible, but one can learn many things from their argument about how to approach those with different beliefs with a humble and understanding attitude.






Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Play: Freud's Last Session Essay

- “Do you count on your own tomorrow?” This is a simple yes or no question, but the answer is based highly on a person’s beliefs, morals, and worldviews. Sigmund Freud and C.S. Lewis were two of the greatest minds of the twentieth century, and the two join together in the play, Freud’s Last Session. Sigmund Freud was born in the Austro-Hungarian Empire in 1856. Supporter or non-supporter, everyone agrees that Freud was one of the most influential scientists of the 20th century. Freud focused mostly on the interaction of the conscious and unconscious mind....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Belief Comparison]

Strong Essays
1099 words (3.1 pages)

Personal Statement On The Group Session Essay

- his was our third group session, it was a different experience as I was the group leader this time around. In following previous protocol, I led the group by “checking in” and asking how everyone’s week has been going. As each member shared their feelings/thoughts and small comments, I had disclosed how nervous I was feeling about running a group for the first time among professionals in training. By disclosing such limited information, I noticed the group was surprised by my confession. One member flashed a smile at me in disbelief, while another member giggled to herself and said, “Wow, I would never have known you get nervous in front of people.” While it seemed to catch everyone’s attent...   [tags: Leadership, Emotion, Session, The Members]

Strong Essays
1061 words (3 pages)

I Am A Last Session Essay

- Jad, I am going to consider this our last session, I could continue to see you forever, but we are about to run out of things to talk about so here goes (know Ill always reply to you, you are a phenomenal), you along with God, Family, Friends and Emory have killed the Charlie and Ben. The only one left is Charles B. I appreciate you checking on me, I did resign on Tuesday and told my boss I had left all my baggage with you (speaking hypothetically, some are to small minded to get it), but that’s one of the ways I am “unique”....   [tags: If You Have to Ask, Need, Want, Sanjay Gupta]

Strong Essays
1588 words (4.5 pages)

The Movie The Last Airbender Essays

- This past weekend, I watched the movie The Last Airbender, and I knew immediately that it would be a film I’d remember months later - just not for the right reasons. M. Night Shyamalan has brought yet another failure to the big screen reminiscent of his last two movies Lady in the Winter (2006) and The Happening (2008). Only this time, it’s much worse. The Last Airbender is an utter disaster. I can’t remember the last movie I watched that was quite as bad as this one. There shouldn’t have been at least something that went right....   [tags: The Last Airbender, Avatar: The Last Airbender]

Strong Essays
891 words (2.5 pages)

Therapy Session Reflection Essay example

- Therapy Analysis The purpose of this paper is to examine the efficacy of my work as a co-therapist during the fifth conjoint session with the simulated couple; Katy and Michelle. I will discuss our therapy agenda and the goals we hoped to attain during the session. It is prudent to begin by giving a brief outline of the couple’s presenting problem and the patterns of dysfunction that I have identified within their relationship. In my opinion, it is the therapist’s job to recognize patterns and behaviors that disrupt the intimate bond between the partners....   [tags: Therapy Session Analysis]

Strong Essays
1905 words (5.4 pages)

A Research Study On The Experimental Session Essay

- The participants were 21 (19 female and 2 male) undergraduate students enrolled in a general psychology laboratory class at Anderson University in Indiana. The participants were selected by convenience sampling, and they received a grade for participating in and completing the experiment. Every participant completed the experiment. The participants were separated into two groups. The first group consisted of numbers 1-11 that listened to music first, whereas the second group consisted of numbers 12-21 that conversed with the passenger first....   [tags: Experiment, Stanford prison experiment, Chair]

Strong Essays
1027 words (2.9 pages)

The 2016 Florida Legislative Session Essay

- The 2016 Florida Legislative session is over and once again for public education many legislators wrote and voted for educational legislation against the expert advice of locally elected school boards, superintendents, teachers and perhaps worst of all parents. What has become most upsetting isn 't only those that wrote these harmful legislation but those that put their personal agendas again before our student 's and local school, and blindly vote in support of these terrible education mandates and laws....   [tags: Education, High school, Teacher, Charter school]

Strong Essays
1012 words (2.9 pages)

Technology and Beckett’s Play, Krapp’s Last Tape Essay

- Technology and Beckett’s Play, Krapp’s Last Tape “bois seul bouffe brûle crêve seul comme devant les absents sont morts les présents puent sors tes yeux détourne-les sur les roseaux se taquinent-ils ou les aïs pas la peine il y a le vent et l’état de veille”[1][1] -Samuel Beckett, Untitled As an avant-garde writer and a trend starter, Beckett was intensely in touch with his own time and its most significant realities, one of which being technological progress....   [tags: Krapp’s Last Tape Essays]

Strong Essays
1174 words (3.4 pages)

Third Session Transcription Analysis Essay

- During the recording of my third transcription, I felt more comfortable , I had already build a relationship with my client at this point. I was able to remember information from the previous session and notice facial expressions and tone of voice when she talks about certain topics. This time she had concerns about not being able to spend much time with her son, as she will like. In other hand she as her son complaining about mom no being home as much and how she explain the situation to her son....   [tags: psychological therapy]

Strong Essays
632 words (1.8 pages)

Essay on Play Is A Child 's Work And Play

- Play is a child’s work and play is important for the child’s development and for children to bond with their parents and caretakers. Playing with your child offers an opportunity to get to bond and create a strong relationship. As a parent, guardian or caretaker you have taken the role of being the child’s first teacher with much of the teaching happening through play. While playing with the child it teaches them rules and what is expected out of him or her. As they grow, play teaches the child how they are expected to act in society and at home....   [tags: Play, Learning, Play, Child]

Strong Essays
1816 words (5.2 pages)