Doubt: Comparing the Play and Movie

Doubt: Comparing the Play and Movie

Length: 1022 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

The differences between the movie doubt and the play have significant differences that would influence ones opinion about certain characters and situations in the story. Though the differences are few one would agree that at least one of these differences are game changers or at the very least they get you thinking and having doubts of your own.

John Patrick Shanley creates a movie as a whole I feel was more informative than the play. In the play you have 4 characters Sister Aloysius, Father Flynn, Sister James, and Mrs. Muller. While the movie introduces a few other characters, for instance the children. For me the children made a difference because they for one made me understand what kind of kids Sister James was dealing with. I really thought that being able to see the way Father Flynn interacted with all of the young boys including Donald Muller was really helpful when trying to draw your conclusion of Father Flynn versus when reading it your left to imagine for instance; what some of the kids are like. The way the book sets you up your left leaning to Father Flynn being exactly what Sister Aloysius accuses him to be. We also get to see how sister James interacts with the kids and how Sister Aloysius influences her to change the way she deals with and teaches her class.

There is other little differences that I noticed added to the story that were in the movie and not the play. There are several scenes where Mother superior is interacting with Sister Veronica. Because of some of these scenes you see another side of Sister Aloysius that presents a more compassionate lady not so wrapped up in doubt. Although Sister Aloysius comes off as a strict woman that really has no sympathy for anyone or anything, which kind of makes you question how the heck she ended up as a nun. In the movie you can clearly see that she has a softer side and actually is hiding behind that tough façade she puts up.

Another scene I believe is important that is missing from the play is the scene where sister James sees Father Flynn putting the white t-shirt back in the locker which is pivotal to the whole premise of the story, without Sister James seeing that she would have never brought it up to Sister Alyosius and we would been left to question Sister Alysosius’s accusations even more.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Doubt: Comparing the Play and Movie." 16 Oct 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Educating Rita - Comparing the Movie and Play

- Educating Rita - Comparing the Movie and Play     The play Educating Rita by Willy Russell gained great popularity especially during the early eighties. There has also been a movie made from it starring Julie Walters and the more famous Michael Caine. As so often the case, the movie was more elaborate with additional scenes, some of which were spoken of or retold by the actors in the play. The movie also included several actors while the play only featured two, Frank and Rita.      After having read the play and seen the movie I am struck by a number of differences....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Research Papers
961 words (2.7 pages)

The Crucible - Comparing Play And Movie Essay

- Arthur Miller's play, The Crucible, and the movie with the same name have many differences and similarities, all of which contribute to the individual effectiveness of each in conveying their central message. There are several additions and variances in the movie. First of all, the scene where the children and Tituba are dancing in the forest is never seen in the forest; we simply learn of it from dialogue. This scene was most probably added in the movie for a dramatic effect: foreshadowing....   [tags: arthur miller film Nicholas Hytner]

Research Papers
978 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Comparing Shakespeare's Hamlet and the Movie, The Lion King

- Comparing Shakespeare's Hamlet and the Movie, The Lion King There is no doubt that today's entertainment has lost most of its touch with the more classical influences of its predecessors. However, in mid-1994, Walt Disney Pictures released what could arguably be the best animated feature of all time in The Lion King. With a moral base unlike most of the movies released at the time, TLK placed a children's facade on a very serious story of responsibility and revenge. However, this theme is one of the oldest in history, and it is not the least apparent in one of the oldest works of literature by The Bard himself, William Shakespeare....   [tags: Shakespeare Hamlet Compare Contrast]

Research Papers
2196 words (6.3 pages)

Comparing Shakespeare's "Othello" and Nelson's "O" Essay

- William Shakespeare’s Othello & Tim Blake Nelson’s “O” each demonstrate the issues of their respective contexts through the chosen mediums of both composers. Shakespeare’s Othello uses the medium of theatre to present ideas such as jealousy, appearance versus reality and racism through a variety of literary techniques while also encompassing the conventions of a classic Shakespearean tragedy. These ideas remain universally relevant in Blake Nelson’s modern day adaptation “O” which parallels the ideas conveyed in Othello through its cinematic techniques....   [tags: Literary Analysis]

Research Papers
2075 words (5.9 pages)

John Patrick Shanley's Doubt Essays

- Douglas Light said that our imagination is better than any answer to a question. Light distinguished between two genres: fantasy from fiction. He described how fantasy stimulates one’s imagination, which is more appealing, but fiction can just be a relatable story. In the same way, Books and movies are very different entities. In the short parable Doubt, the readers are lured in to the possibility of a scandalous relationship between a pastor and an alter boy. The readers’ curiosity is ignited because they are not given all the details....   [tags: play analysis]

Research Papers
2373 words (6.8 pages)

Essay on Comparing Hitchcock’s Films, Shadow of a Doubt and Vertigo

- Comparing Hitchcock’s Films, Shadow of a Doubt and Vertigo Francois Truffaut, when referring to Hitchcock said that “he exercises such complete control over all the elements of his films and imprints his personal concepts at each step of the way, Hitchcock has a distinctive style of his own. He is undoubtedly one of the few film-makers on the horizon today whose screen signature can be identified as soon as the picture begins.” Many people have used Hitchcock as the ultimate example of an auteur as there are many common themes and techniques found amongst his films....   [tags: Movie Film Essays]

Research Papers
487 words (1.4 pages)

Doubt : A Play About A Priest Essay

- Doubt Doubt is a play about a priest who is being accused of having sexual interactions with the only black boy in the Catholic school and the principal, Sister Aloysius, is determined to prove her suspicions to be true. While it can be unclear throughout the play and even at the end if Father Flynn is innocent or guilty both Patrick Shanely and the cast of Doubt, put on by The University of Alabama, keep the mind wondering if there was a chance he could have been innocent. The importance of characters, their actions, and even the design of the costumes can help one determine if Father Flynn interacted inappropriately with the boy or if it appeared wrong due to a poisoned mind (Father Flynn...   [tags: Emotion, Feeling, 2002 albums, Theatre]

Research Papers
928 words (2.7 pages)

Hamlet Is No Doubt A Complex Play Essay

- Considered to be one of the most famous playwrights written in the history of English literature, Hamlet is no doubt a complex play and far from being easy to decipher. The protagonist finds himself entangled within a slew of different predicaments ranging from love, incest, death, murder, and even touches upon the spiritual world when his father’s apparition presents himself with the task of avenging his death. How he goes about handling all of these difficulties has been a debate for decades and continues to baffle even the greatest minds today....   [tags: Characters in Hamlet, Hamlet, Gertrude]

Research Papers
1086 words (3.1 pages)

Father Flynn in John Patrick Shanley’s Doubt Essay

- It is difficult to make the decision if Father Flynn is innocent or guilty. In John Patrick Shanley’s Doubt; a parable, he eclipses the truth very well. The scenes about the toy, the camping trip and the undershirt cause much confusion; causing the audience to go back and forth in their minds and doubt Father Flynn. Law says that people are innocent until proven guilty although; realistically, everyone knows that people are guilty until proven innocent. It is very possible that Father Fynn is only helping Donald, because he is less fortunate than the other students at his school; and it is also very possible that he is hurting the child by molesting him....   [tags: John Patrick Shanley, Doubt]

Research Papers
856 words (2.4 pages)

Essay No Doubt

- In the begaining - In Anaheim California Eric Stefani Gwens older brother would write songs like (Stick it in a hole) about a pencil sharpener, and forcing Gwen to song with John their singer. In December of 1986 their singer John Spence quits and forces Gwen to sing at their first gig. In the summer of 1987 Gwen and Tony (their basses) start going out.December 21-1987 John Spence shots him self in a park in Anaheim Cal. In the spring of 1988 the heavy metal guitarist Tom, a college student,refuses his sisters offer to play in her band to play in No Doubt.In 1987-1988 part of the then underground-ska-scence, No Doubt built a huge following of " rude boys" and after...   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
539 words (1.5 pages)

To me this at least puts a little validity to what Sister Alyosius is accusing Father Flynn of.

Sister James is a key player in how much the story escalates at first but she quickly realizes that she is wrong. The thing about her is that she is a lot more sympathetic than Sister Aloysius. Sister James tried to get to the bottom the situation in the movie when she was talking to Father Flynn, but Father Flynns answers to sister James questions don’t really help you at all If your trying to make a decision regarding the accusations against him. I mean Father Flynns reaction to Sister James saying that she doesn’t think he did anything wrong leads you to believe that Father Flynn was innocent and until then I really had no clue. The one thing I will give sister James is that she is vocal about her decision to back up Father Flynn, and albeit she seems afraid of Sister Aloysius she doesn’t let her intimidate her.

There is one other instance that gets you thinking about a situation in the movie that is not elaborated on or made clear whatsoever in the play. In the scene where Sister Aloysius and Mrs. Muller are discussing Donald Muller the play goes over the conversation regarding the two in Sister Aloysius’s office and in the movie the first part of the conversation is in Sister Aloysius’s office and then the conversation resumes on a walk to Mrs. Mullers place of employment so she wouldn’t be late for work. During that walk a very important conversation takes place where Sister Aloysius is alluding to the lewd acts she is accusing Father Flynn of and Mrs. Muller reminds Sister Aloysius “it is only until June”. You also wonder why Mrs Muller seems like she is ok with the supposed abuse of her son. But a little later in the conversation things start to make a little bit of sense. Mrs Muller seems to lead the viewer to believe that maybe her son would be beaten if his father heard of the nature of the conversation. Mrs Muller even says things that would lead the viewer to believe that that there is a slight chance that her son might be homosexual. There is a very good chance that might be the reason she seems ok with what was supposedly going on between Donald Muller and Father Flynn. In my opinion abuse is abuse and if father Flynn was in fact abusing the kid his sexual orientation shouldn’t matter.

I am going to move on to the scene where Sister Aloysius and Father Flynn are in the Sisters office. I believe facial features that Father Flynn makes really plays with your mind. He looks appalled but defeated and willing to give up. Which brings me to my next point, why wouldn’t a man that was innocent off accusations fight tooth and nail to prove his innocence? If Father Flynn cared so much about Donald and the rest of the children why didn’t he bring anything up to his superiors, seems to me it would be worth it. This is portrayed in both the book and play but it is the issue that eats at me when I try and form my opinion on what I think went on in that school. To me father Flynn gives up way to easy and that made me think he didn’t want anyone else to know what he was being accused of. In the second conversation between Sister Aloysius and Father Flynn right after the conversation with Mrs. Muller Father Flynn gives his best argument and defends himself very well, but the he concedes. This is a great example to prove my earlier point of the author really wanting you to form your own opinion and experience doubt first hand. I can tell you I am still undecided about it all, and the fact that Sister Aloysius says she has doubt at the end is great and all but does not bring resolve to me, just means she had doubt and that an innocent man may have transferred for nothing.

You cannot blame sister Aloysius for having the thoughts she has, but we can all admit that she could have handled it in a very different manner. As I stated earlier in the paper the movie portrays different sides of Sister Aloysius, but even in her generosity she remains snide and full of animosity. She is very angry for some reason and she doesn’t let go of that anger until the very end of the movie when she breaks down. This is the part of the story that the movie and play both portray well thankfully because it is where the author takes his final stab and thoroughly confusing the hell out of everyone watching.

Father Flynn could have fought her on the matter and eventually the truth would have come out. When I sit and think about it though I don’t believe that this was the vision of John Patrick Shanley. In my opinion is that John Patrick Shanley leads the viewer to form his or her own opinion and to experience the feeling of doubt. I feel that the movie and the book are in most respects very much alike but I think the movie; at least for me made it a lot easier to form an opinion.

Works Cited

Doubt. By John Patrick Shanley. Dir. ohn Patrick Shanley. 2008.
—. Doubt a Parable. Theatre Communications Group, 2005.

Return to