Donoghue V. Birmingham Water Works Essay

Donoghue V. Birmingham Water Works Essay

Length: 1533 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Donoghue v Stevenson was the case that changed everything. Before this case, a contract could not impose limited liability on a stranger. Thus meant that a third party who suffered loss and damage as a result of a breach of warranty in a contract between two other parties could not sue.

A clear description of negligence was set out in the case Blyth v Birmingham Water Works

‘‘…. the omission to do something which a erasable man, guided upon those considerations which ordinarily regulate the conduct of human affairs, would do, or doing something which a prudent and reasonable man would not do.’’ - Alderson B.
To sue under negligence, the plaintiff must show that there is:
A duty of care
Breach of that duty

In the case Winterbottom v Wright, the plaintiff entered into a contract with the Postmaster General to drive a mail coach. The plaintiff was injured when the coach collapsed. The coach had been supplied by the defendant and given to the Postmaster General. The judge ruled in favour of the defendant. Lord Abinger thought it would be ‘’most absurd and outrageous’’ to impose limited liability on the defendant who had no relationship with the defendant in the first place. The judge was concerned that if limited liability had been imposed, it would open the floodgates to countless other claims.

However in Donoghue v Stevenson, Lord Atkins established the Neighbour Principle. He held that a duty was owed when a relationship of proximity was present between the plaintiff and the defendant. On the 26th August 1928, May Donoghue went to a cafe with a friend called The Wellmeadow Cafe. Her friend purchased a bottle of ginger her and an ice cream. The ginger beer was in a bottle that was made...

... middle of paper ...

This now sealed the floodgates in the courts.

Up until 2002 in Ireland we had adopted the Anns approach until the decision in Glencar Exploration plc v Mayo County Council. They adopted the Caparo which is still used in English and Irish courts today. The plaintiffs had been granted licences by the Minister for Energy to look for gold in Mayo. They had spent a lot of money doing this project. Mayo County Council adopted a mining ban in their development plan. This plan was held to be ultra vires. The plaintiff sued Mayo county council for negligence but the Supreme Court dismissed the claim because the Council did not owe the plaintiffs a duty of care.
Now we use a four step test to determine if a duty of care exists:
Reasonable Foreseeability;
Proximity of relationship;
Countervailing public policy considerations, and;
Whether it is just and reasonable

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Letter from a Birmingham Jail

- Letter from a Birmingham Jail      Is an individual ever morally justified in breaking a law?  The answer to this question is yes.  There are several reasons that have made me believe that it is morally justifiable in breaking the law; however the most convincing comes from Dr. Martin Luther King in his letter from a Birmingham Jail.  " We can never forget what that everything Hitler did in Germany was legal..." (Classic Arguments 668).  King went on in his letter to say that it would be against man made law to help a jew in Nazi Germany.  What King said in his letter has to make a person think that not all laws are good for the group in society and morality is a justifiable excuse...   [tags: Letter from Birmingham Jail]

Strong Essays
855 words (2.4 pages)

Martin Luther King 's Letter From Birmingham Jail Essay

- Through reading Martin Luther King’s Letter from Birmingham Jail, it is hard not be impressed and taken aback by his eloquence with words, especially when you factor in that he is writing this letter from inside of a jail cell. He demonstrates how educated and intelligent he is as he is able to write this lengthy letter, complete with biblical citations and references, from within the jail and without access to any resources (Maranzani, 2013). Through reading King’s letter, and admiring his employment of Aristotle’s canons of rhetoric, and other rhetorical strategies, as well as his effective use of pathos, I have discovered that there are many underlying elements that go into being an effe...   [tags: Rhetoric, Letter from Birmingham Jail]

Strong Essays
1518 words (4.3 pages)

The Shortage Of Water Is A Global Issue Essay

- The shortage of water is a global issue that effects not millions, but billons of people worldwide, it was recently discovered that the perceived water scarcity was wrong instead of affecting 1.7 to 3.1 billon people are short of water for a month out a year is actually 4 billon people. And why is that. Many reasons. To begin fresh water that we drink, bathe in, irrigate our fields for agriculture is only 3% of the worlds water; the rest as you know is made up of salt water, our oceans. Two- thirds of that fresh water comes from glaciers the rest is unusable and unreachable....   [tags: Water, Water resources, Water crisis]

Strong Essays
844 words (2.4 pages)

Letter from Birmingham Jail Essay

- Race. It is a word that is associated with many thoughts, words, and emotions. The color of peoples' skin is the first thing that is noticed. Throughout history people have judged and mistreated because they were of the wrong  race. A prime example of this is the racial tension between blacks and whites. The driving force behind this tension is the past. For many years blacks were mistreated and abused based solely on the color of the skin. In Martin Luther King J.R.'s "Letter from Birmingham  Jail", he uses references to the past and people of the past to strengthen his point....   [tags: Letter from Birmingham Jail Essays]

Strong Essays
613 words (1.8 pages)

Ballad of Birmingham by Dudley Randall Essay

- Ballad of Birmingham by Dudley Randall In 'Ballad of Birmingham,' Dudley Randall illustrates a conflict between a child who wishes to march for civil rights and a mother who wishes only to protect her child. Much of this poem is read as dialogue between a mother and a child, a style which gives it an intimate tone and provides insight to the feelings of the characters. Throughout the poem the child is eager to go into Birmingham and march for freedom with the people there. The mother, on the other hand, is very adamant that the child should not go because it is dangerous....   [tags: Analysis Ballad Birmingham Dudley Randall Essays]

Strong Essays
822 words (2.3 pages)

Exploration of Civil Disobedience in Sophocles' Antigone, King's Letter from Birmingham Jail, and Plato's From Crito

- Exploration of Civil Disobedience in Sophocles' Antigone, King's Letter from Birmingham Jail, and Plato's From Crito Civil disobedience spawns a major and widely debated issue by many who established by well-known intelligent scholars and many examples of civil disobedience become displayed. The acts of civil disobedience can be noted in major works such as Sophocles?s Antigone, King?s ?Letter from Birmingham Jail?, or even from Plato?s ?from Crito?. A specific claim exemplified throughout these works make that civil disobedience races in gaining popularity and should remain allowed, and continued to be seen as a solution to reform poorly established laws....   [tags: Antigone Letter Birmingham Jail Crito]

Strong Essays
582 words (1.7 pages)

Essay Dudley Randall's Poem Ballad of Birmingham

- Dudley Randall's Poem Ballad of Birmingham The poem 'The Ballad of Birmingham', by Dudley Randall, is based on the historical event of the bombing in 1963 of Martin Luther King, Jr.'s church by white terrorists. It is a poem in which a daughter expresses her interest in attending a civil rights rally and the mother fearful for her daughter's safety refuses to let her go. In the poem the daughter in fighting for the course of the operessed people of her time/generation instead of going out to play....   [tags: Dudley Randall Ballad Birmingham Essays]

Strong Essays
585 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on Letter from a Birmingham Jail and The Declaration of Individualism

- Letter from a Birmingham Jail and The Declaration of Individualism Although the time periods and goals may be different the method for bringing about change is usually the same, this method is protest. This method is supported by two different people, in two different time periods, with two different goals; these two people are Thomas Jefferson and Martin Luther King Junior. Martin Luther King Junior's letter from a Birmingham Jail was an expression of his encouragement for protest against tradition and established laws and a justification for his actions....   [tags: Letter from Birmingham Jail]

Free Essays
849 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Martin Luther King's Letter from Birmingham Jail

- It was change created by a human for the human, a change which made the life of others livable. During the civil rights movement in America in 1960’s various techniques were used to gain the civil rights for the black people in a series of which came the “Letter form Birmingham jail” written by Martin Luther King himself. King's "Letter from Birmingham Jail" was a profound and persuasive written argument which captured the emotions of many people encompassing rigid life experiences, educated observances, and deeply rooted spiritual beliefs....   [tags: Civil Rights King Birmingham]

Strong Essays
1166 words (3.3 pages)

Water Governance Essay

- According to previous literatures, the act of participation by the public had proven to bring success in producing sustainable water resource management (Jansson, 2005). However the remaining questions were who should participate, when, why and to what extent is public in the context of ‘public participation’. Principle 10 of the Rio Declaration on Environment and Development highlighted that public participation is crucial when dealing with environmental related issues (United Nations Conference on Environment and Development, 1992; cited in Kakebeeke, Wouters & Bouman, 2000)....   [tags: resource management, water industry]

Strong Essays
1633 words (4.7 pages)