Does Detecting Breast Cancer with MRIs Increase the Rate of Mastectomies?

Does Detecting Breast Cancer with MRIs Increase the Rate of Mastectomies?

Length: 892 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the last years, Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) has become a very popular method used for the early detection of breast cancer, because it has greater sensibility than mammography. But, opponents of MRI are concerned about this type of examination because of the belief that it may increase rates of mastectomy. However, different studies have been performed and no proof of this has been recorded (Dang and Zaguiyan et al 937). Although many people think that mastectomy may increase with MRI’s, I feel that these types of screenings should be more recommendable for women at high risk for breast cancer, because cancer, if not treated on time might be fatal.
Mammography has been traditionally used for breast examination, in order to detect abnormalities, but women with dense breast tissue are not very sensitive to this modality. (Dang and Zaguiyan et al 937). Due to this fact, I think MRI’s may permit higher rates of survival than mammography, because it can give more visible results and it has higher sensibility to breast tissue. However, I understand that there is often a concern that use of MRI may increase rates of mastectomy, but this belief has been proven to be mistaken.
Between 1997 and 2003, The Mayo Clinic Rochester carried out an analysis that demonstrated that magnetic resonance imaging for breast cancer did show an increase of mastectomy. But, concurrently that same increased was shown among patients who had never had an MRI (quoted in Dang and Zaguiyan 937). The results seem to have no relation between increased rates of mastectomy and MRI’s, and conclusions may be disturbing.
However, according to the Saul and Joyce Brandman Breast Center, Department of Surgery and the Cedars –Sinai Medical Center; unlike The Mayo...

... middle of paper ...

...e. Unlike mammography, MRI is painless, and cancer if not detected on time is deadly. Due to this fact, I believe MRI it should be recommended for women at high risk of cancer, because once a person discovers they have cancer there are indefinite options for treatment.
Despite the fact that MRI may give incorrect diagnosis, hundreds of women die every year from breast cancer. Also, increased rates of mastectomy seem to be so controversial, that people think mammography would be more preferable than MRI. But clearly a cancer battle requires a lot of braveness and having a family with such an exaggerated record of breast cancer, sets me in the position that if looking towards the new technology, women can help themselves by using MRI for early detection of breast cancer. To make sure cancer does not take any more victims, the will to live each day is very important.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Causes And Treatment Of Breast Cancer

- Breast cancer is one of the top causes of death in women and it often occurs in menopausal women and can range from age 40 and up. It starts with having a mammogram which is the initial screening, then if there is a suspected spot, the patient is called back for a biopsy. A biopsy is taken to examine if it is cancer. The doctor will then recommend if a lumpectomy or mastectomy is needed. Percutaneous ablations on women with breast cancer is not as common as having lumpectomies or mastectomies because generally doctors recommend having a lumpectomy or mastectomy done depending on the type of cancer, size, and location....   [tags: Cancer, Breast cancer, Cancer staging, Oncology]

Better Essays
1565 words (4.5 pages)

Types Of Mastectomies : The Surgeon Essay

- There are different types of mastectomies. Which one your surgeon performs depends on the type of breast problem you have. The surgeon will make a cut in your breast and perform one of these operations: • Subcutaneous mastectomy: The surgeon removes the entire breast, but leaves the nipple and areola (the colored circle around the nipple) in place. • Total or simple mastectomy: The surgeon cuts breast tissue free from the skin and muscle and removes it. The nipple and the areola are also removed....   [tags: Cancer, Breast cancer, Biopsy, Breast]

Better Essays
1640 words (4.7 pages)

Essay Detecting the Signs and Symptoms of Lung Cancer

- ... So even if you are a non-smoker but the people around you do, you are still at risk. When someone puffs cigarette and a person breathes the smoke, consider yourself smoking. Some chemicals also predispose lung cancer. These include radon, arsenic, chromium and asbestos. Exposure to these chemicals becomes more challenging because some of them are impossible to sense. Radiation therapy or of any kind destroys both abnormal and normal cells which makes the exposed individual at risk. 2. Other Parameters in Lung Cancer Screening Genetic Make-Up and Family History People who have first and second degree relatives diagnosed with lung cancer have greater risk of the disease....   [tags: Prevention, Smoking, Radiation]

Better Essays
748 words (2.1 pages)

The Incidence Rate Of Cervical Cancer Essay

- indigenous Australians. The incidence rate of cervical cancer also higher among Indigenous females as it is reported that they are 2.8 times higher live with cervical cancer and 3.9 times death rate from cervical cancer than non-Indigenous females. Indigenous female are less likely to attend cervical screening may be a contributing factor in the higher rates in Indigenous females. According to the cancer database created by the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2013a, p.15), the Indigenous population is 1.9 times more likely to be diagnosed with lung cancer and non-Indigenous Australians are 30% more likely to develop prostate cancer than Indigenous Australians....   [tags: Cancer, Metastasis, Epidemiology]

Better Essays
1242 words (3.5 pages)

Survival Rate Is An Incurable Brain Cancer Essay

- Glioblastoma Glioblastoma (pronounced like glee O blastoma) is an incurable brain cancer,Survival rate is usually measured in months.This became a word that was instantly defined, researched, dissected, feared, and tried to comprehend and understand by family,friends and acquaintances of Larry McKee (McKee)who was personally affected from this single word, it was quickly added to their vocabulary, because of the of the events that transpired on October 22, 2011 that forever changed lives “Glioblastomas are tumors that arise from the astrocytes- the star-shaped cells that make up the “glue-like,” or supportive tissue of the brain....   [tags: Cancer, Oncology, Brain tumor, Brain]

Better Essays
913 words (2.6 pages)

The Rate Of Human Cancer Cell Lines Essay

- The first aim of this project was to evaluate the emph{in vivo} growth rates of human cancer cell lines before they were xenotransplantated into zebrafish larvae. The zebrafish with xenotransplanted cells were maintained at 34$^circ$C to ensure the survival of both zebrafish and human cells. The results demonstrate that all human cell lines grow at slower rate at 34$^circ$C. Furthermore, the rates of growth are affected by the temperature of continuous culturing prior to seeding, as shown for U-251 mCherry that was maintained at 34$^circ$C three months before the emph{in vitro} experiment....   [tags: Immune system, Cancer, Neutrophil granulocyte]

Better Essays
1575 words (4.5 pages)

Cancer, Cancer And Treatment Of Cancer Essay

- “Since 1990, over 6 million Americans have died of cancer, more than the combined casualties from the Civil war, WWII, and the Vietnam and Korean conflicts combined” (Faguet, p. 5). According to American Cancer Society projections, there were 1,529,560 new cases of cancer in 2010. Cancer is becoming more and more common around the world. New cancers are constantly being discovered. Researchers are finding new ways to detect cancer and treat it so that the fatality rate does not rise. However, there are some cancers that researchers have not yet discovered a cure for....   [tags: Cancer, Breast cancer, Prostate cancer]

Better Essays
1297 words (3.7 pages)

Breast Cancer : Cancer And Cancer Essay

- About 12% of women in the United States will develop breast cancer in their lifetime, more than any other type of cancer (, 2015). Many people lack the knowledge of how breast cancer is developed. Some people think they will not get cancer because they do not smoke cigarettes, but this is not the only cause of cancer developing in the breast. Anyone can get cancer. Everyone is potentially at risk for developing some form of Cancer (American Cancer Society, 2015). Some risk factors cannot be changed such as age, race, and gender....   [tags: Cancer, Breast cancer, Cancer staging]

Better Essays
948 words (2.7 pages)

Breast Cancer : The Most Common Cancer Essay

- For anyone who has had cancer or had a family member go through cancer knows that it can be a very scary thing to handle. Thankfully, much research has gone into cancer and have been able to diagnose it earlier and earlier with new and upcoming technology. Everywhere you go you see fundraisers for breast cancer. After skin cancer, breast cancer is the most common cancer in women. Although men can get breast cancer, it’s most common in women. Fortunately, breast cancer survival rates have been increasing, “thanks to a number of factors such as earlier detection, new treatments and a better understanding of the disease,” (Edwards, 2014)....   [tags: Breast cancer, Cancer, Oncology, Breast]

Better Essays
1859 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on Cancer : Cancer And Cancer

- Cancer is a disease with many diseases and though the stages of cancer may be referred to by the same name, each kind of cancer has individual symptoms and affect the body in unique ways. Overall, some kinds of cancers are more prominent than other. Statistically speaking, lung cancer, breast cancer, colorectum cancer, and prostate cancer are most commonly treated in the cancerization field. However, that does not mean that the uncommon kinds of cancers are not as severe as the most common types of cancer....   [tags: Cancer, Oncology, Brain tumor, Cancer staging]

Better Essays
736 words (2.1 pages)